Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
An alcohol‐rich product obtained by Fischer‐Tropsch synthesis at 160–175° and 150 lb./sq. in. (gauge), in the presence of a cobalt catalyst has been examined. It was found that n ‐primary alcohols constituted 40% by weight of the organic liquid products (oil, spirit and organic matter in the water) and 92·4% of the total oxygenated products. The proportions of acids and carbonyl compounds were, therefore, markedly lower than those reported to be present in an iron‐catalyst product of the Hydrocol type. The proportion of methanol present was very low, ethanol was present in the largest proportion and the proportions of the alcohols higher than propanol decreased with increasing carbon number. The proportion of propanol was less than that of butanol or pentanol so that the carbon‐number distribution curve for the alcohols showed a marked inflexion in the C 3 ‐C 4 region, which is not shown by the published distribution curve for the alcohols in the Hydrocol product. From a study of the relative rates of decomposition of a series of n ‐primary alcohols at 150° in the presence of hydrogen and a cobalt catalyst, it was possible to plot a curve relating alcohol stability and carbon number. This curve resembled the distribution curve in showing a low value for C 1 , a maximum at C 2 and a marked inflexion in the C 3 ‐C 4 region, suggesting that the individual alcohols are present in the products of synthesis in proportions which are determined, at least in part, by their relative stabilities under the synthesis conditions. It is considered that the alcohol distribution curve is of a form which would be predicted if the mechanism of alcohol formation involved step‐wise addition of methylene radicals to one end of a growing chain terminated by a hydroxymethylene radical, and if the survival of the alcohols was controlled by their relative stabilities. From a consideration of the observed results and of those reported by other workers in the field, it is concluded that there is a balance of evidence in favour of the view that alcohols are the precursors of hydrocarbons in the synthesis.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Gall et al. (1952) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: