Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Introduction The juvenile court may issue an immediate supervision order if there is an immediate risk to a child’s health or development. Little is known about the decision-making process behind such orders. Aim This study aims to establish whether the advice that social workers give to child protection boards regarding the follow-up after an immediate measure is well-founded and traceable. Method We conducted a retrospective qualitative case file study, analyzing 50 files of children who received an immediate supervision order from a Dutch youth care organization. We assessed the advice using a tool based on Toulmin’s argumentation model and the three perspectives of evidence based (scientific, professional and client perspective). Results Advice to the child protection board was explicitly found in seven files (14%). Most of the advice was found in the child protection board’s report (52%). None of the advice included all Toulmin’s elements and all three perspectives of evidence-based practice. Although information was available elsewhere in the case files, this was not reflected in the advice. Conclusion The risk of not including this information in the advice is that vital information is not considered by the child protection board and, later, the court. We recommend that youth care organizations treat the advice as a distinct and critical decision, giving it separate status in protocols. Furthermore, we recommend using a model of argumentation and incorporating the three perspectives to ensure that critical information is well-founded in the advice.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Gabriels et al. (2026) studied this question.