Key result
Adopting strategies from high-performance disciplines such as aviation, Formula 1, and professional sports, including coaching, video analysis, and benchmarking, can improve surgical performance and patient safety.
Why the study?
Given the complex, error-prone surgical environment and evolving challenges like reduced trainee operative experience and increasing patient multimorbidity, learning from other high-performance disciplines may improve surgical performance and enhance patient safety.
Adopting systems approaches, coaching, and data-driven performance metrics from high-performance disciplines like aviation and Formula 1 can enhance surgical safety and excellence.
Hypothesis-generating for cross-disciplinary performance tools in surgery; leaves open need for prospective trials before adoption.
High-performance disciplines have always been concerned with safety and exceptional performance. They have established a culture of vigilance and accepted that human error is both inevitable and ubiquitous. These disciplines, therefore, have all implemented a 'systems approach' to error by focusing on predicting, preventing, rescuing and reporting errors that occur so that they can constantly adapt and improve. Given the complexity of surgery, and the error-prone environment within which it takes place, extracting positive behaviours from other high-performance disciplines will serve to improve performance and enhance patient safety. Surgery is being practiced in an ever-changing environment. Currently, there is less available operative experience for surgical trainees; multi-morbidity in patients is growing and rapidly evolving technology means that more high-tech equipment is being used in procedures. This article evaluates the effectiveness of current surgical protocol in reducing errors and possible modifications that can be made to fit the new environment that surgery is now being practiced in. It will then describe how three different high-performance disciplines: aviation, professional sport and Formula 1, have developed in their approaches to safety and excellence, which will serve as the basis for a discussion about what more can be learnt from these disciplines so that the surgical profession can continue to excel in the face of change.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Jessica O’Logbon (2020) conducted a review in Surgical safety and performance. High-performance discipline strategies (aviation, Formula 1, professional sports) vs. Current standard surgical protocols was evaluated. Adopting strategies from high-performance disciplines such as aviation, Formula 1, and professional sports, including coaching, video analysis, and benchmarking, can improve surgical performance and patient safety.
Synapse has enriched 5 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: