Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The problem of the unit slope of the Brønsted plot for the proton transfer reaction from the “hard” CH-acids is considered by the example of a series of gas-phase deprotonation reactions of substituted benzenes with the CH2CN– anion. The discussion is conducted within the framework of the theory of non-equilibrium reactions. The use of intramolecular reorganization (IMR) method allows calculate directly the structure and energy of the activated complex. A comparison is made of two models. In model 1, as with the standard approach, proton tunnelling process is associated with the system potential V(r) (r is proton coordinate), whereas in model 2, it is associated with the potential of reaction zone X (including the breaking (A‒H) and formed (H‒B) bonds), VX(r). The VX energy has been calculated using the Mayer’s APOST program, designed to calculate the mono- and diatomic components of the system energy. The accepted level of calculation of the energies V and VX (HF/6-31G**//HF/3-21G**) has been determined by APOST program capabilities. Key feature of model 2 is almost complete insensitivity of the proton tunneling frequency, νt, to changes of reaction energy ΔE00. The end result is an increase of the Brønsted coefficient α from 0.67 (for model 1) to 0.83. It is shown that when going from the gas phase to the solution (reaction in DMSO medium), α value increases to 0.97.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Igor Romanskii (2020) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: