This is the authors' abstract. We don't add key points for this paper.
Over the past 40 years, case reports and case series have fallen out of favor as manuscripts deemed appropriate for submission and publication within health sciences journals,1,2 likely because they reside among the lowest levels of evidence in the Centre for Evidence-Based Medicine's hierarchy3 and generally receive far fewer citations than randomized controlled trials and meta-analyses.4 Although Physical Therapy (PTJ) has long deemed case report manuscripts acceptable for submission, providing they are novel and innovative, their representative publication in the journal has fallen off since 2010. A 2011 bibliometric analysis of articles published in PTJ from 1980 to 2009 showed that the percentage of articles that were case reports had remained relatively constant at 9.9%.5 However, my own analysis of PTJ articles published from 2010 through November 2018 revealed that the percentage of articles that are case reports (or case series) has dropped to 6.9%, representing a reduction of 43.7% from the previous 29-year period. From my viewpoint, the submission of case reports should be strongly encouraged and their value reassessed in PTJ such that their representation within the journal increases, at least to the previous level of approximately 10%. By describing a real-world example, I will argue for the benefits of case reports/case series as an important initial foray into a series of steps in establishing higher levels of evidence, such as randomized controlled trials (RCTs) and systematic reviews/meta-analyses. These benefits include the reduced expense of conducting case reports, their appeal to clinicians in reading and carrying them out, and their merit in generating hypotheses that will lead to loftier types of research that can subsequently support or refute their tentative findings.1,6 In 2000, a physical therapist colleague and I published a series of case reports in the Journal of Surgical Oncology.7 The goal of that case series was to examine any negative effects of vigorous, repetitive upper extremity (UE) exercise in potentially leading to lymphedema in a group of 20 women who had been treated for breast cancer, including axillary node dissection for breast cancer staging. In literature published prior to that study, breast surgeons and physical therapists had warned that such types of exercises could lead to the development of lymphedema in women at risk, like our participants.8–11 The data collected for this case series were sequential UE measurements collected by the 2 physical therapist authors before the intervention began, at the end of the intervention, and 5 months after its completion. The “intervention” comprised twice-weekly UE and back resistance exercises (eg, latissimus dorsi pull-downs, seated rows, bench presses), thrice-weekly aerobic activities, and twice-weekly, on-water training for dragon boat racing. Dragon boat racing is a recreational, competitive sport that involves paddling (2 paddlers abreast) a 40- to 60-foot heavy boat with a strenuous, repetitive, staccato motion of the UEs. Circumferential measurements were collected at 4 UE landmarks on both the involved (surgical side) and uninvolved extremities: the mid-palm, the wrist, 2 inches distal, and 4 inches proximal to the lateral epicondyle. Measurements were collected and recorded by one of the physical therapist authors, and interrater agreement between the authors was assessed for 3 participants’ (15%) involved UEs, resulting in 96% agreement. Clinically significant differences were defined as differences of ≥1.0 inch (2.5 cm) in circumference in the involved (surgical) UE compared with the uninvolved extremity at any of the 4 measurement landmarks at the final measurement session. This level of difference was consistent with definitions of “mild lymphedema” ranging from 2.5 to <3.0 cm.12,13 None of the 20 women showed a clinically significant difference in UE circumference at the final measurement time point, leading to the following conclusion: “This preliminary report suggests that women who have undergone axillary dissection and, in many cases, radiation for the treatment of breast cancer may be able to safely engage in strenuous, repetitive upper body exercise. This is a testable hypothesis that must be answered definitively through a prospective, well-controlled trial.”7(p98) In the 19 years since that case series appeared—the first study on vigorous exercise and lymphedema risk to appear in the peer-reviewed literature—13 RCTs have been published that have confirmed our tentative hypothesis (Tab. 1), that is, that UE progressive resistance exercise does not lead to a greater incidence of lymphedema in women at risk. In addition, 13 systematic reviews (2006–2018) further support those early findings (Tab. 2). The hypothesis set out in this case series led to multiple studies at the highest levels of evidence, thus supporting the value of publishing such reports as the initial line of inquiry.14 Randomized Controlled Trials Confirming That Upper Extremity Resistance Exercise Is Safe for Women Living With Breast Cancera ALND = axillary lymph node dissection; BC = breast cancer; BCRL = breast cancer-related lymphedema; SLNB = sentinel lymph node biopsy. Articles that cited Harris & Niesen-Vertommen case series.7 Randomized Controlled Trials Confirming That Upper Extremity Resistance Exercise Is Safe for Women Living With Breast Cancera ALND = axillary lymph node dissection; BC = breast cancer; BCRL = breast cancer-related lymphedema; SLNB = sentinel lymph node biopsy. Articles that cited Harris & Niesen-Vertommen case series.7 Systematic Reviews That Support the Safety of Resistance Exercise for Women Living With Breast Cancera BCRL = breast cancer-related lymphedema; CT = controlled trial; RCT = randomized controlled trial; RE = resistance exercise. Articles that cited Harris & Niesen-Vertommen case series.7 Systematic Reviews That Support the Safety of Resistance Exercise for Women Living With Breast Cancera BCRL = breast cancer-related lymphedema; CT = controlled trial; RCT = randomized controlled trial; RE = resistance exercise. Articles that cited Harris & Niesen-Vertommen case series.7 Furthermore, this case series was undertaken in a community setting at no cost. The investigators were directly involved in the dragon boat training and racing when they collected the UE circumferential data and assessed their interrater agreement for the measures. Although case reports/series have been criticized for their low level of impact and limited number of citations by others,4 this case series7 has been cited by others 89 times (Web of Science), including citations in a number of the subsequent RCTs and systematic reviews (see Tab. 1 and 2), with 8 of them published in high-impact journals such as the New England Journal of Medicine, CA–A Cancer Journal for Clinicians, and the Journal of Clinical Oncology. In addition to the citations in a number of higher evidence-level studies, this case series7 was cited also in several sets of clinical practice guidelines15–18 suggesting tentative support for the safety of vigorous UE exercises but also the need for RCTs to underscore those early findings. The 2003 American Cancer Society guide on nutrition and physical activity during and after cancer treatment stated that the results of this case series7 and a 2003 pilot clinical trial19 “suggest that resistance training does not increase the risk for new or worsening lymphedema.”15(p277) In a 2014 systematic review detailing 25 years of exercise research in survivors of breast cancer comparing the periods of 1989 to 1999, 2000 to 2006, and 2007 to 2013,20 the authors observed that the second time period (2000–2006) was noticeably different than the initial one by virtue of the addition of resistance training in two-thirds of the later studies. This observation dovetails chronologically with the 2000 publication of the case series7 that suggested that resistance training did not lead to lymphedema in women at risk. Clearly, not all case reports or case series will lead to studies with higher levels of research evidence or actually change clinical practice, as was true with the example presented here.7 Yet, as the editors of the Journal of Medical Case Reports stated, “We believe that it is time for case reports to be considered first class citizens in the medical literature,”21(p2) a statement that I would apply to the physical therapy literature and, in particular, to PTJ. As PTJ’s Editor-in-Chief, Dr Alan Jette, remarked in a 2016 editorial describing 95 years of progress in the journal, one of the “communities” served by the journal are physical therapist clinicians and other rehabilitation professionals who primarily provide patient care.22 Because a number of authors have identified the importance of case reports/case series to practicing clinicians,1,6,23,24 this lends further credence to the need for raising the profile of the call for case reports in PTJ, especially those that have the ability to generate further research and ultimately change clinical practice. In that revised (and heightened) call for case reports, the editorial board could consider that PTJ’s author guidelines now include the perspectives of the participants studied in the report21 as well as requiring that the checklist for the case report guidelines are followed in developing, conducting, and writing the case report, as has been endorsed by a number of other health science journals.25 My hope is that the 100-year progress report on PTJ will include an increased emphasis on the importance of case reports to its readers and a greater representation of published case reports and case series within the journal's pages! There are no funders to report. The author completed the ICJME Form for Disclosure of Potential Conflicts of Interest and reported no conflicts of interest.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Susan R. Harris (2019) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: