Key result
Total player-to-player contacts were 264% higher in small-sided games than simulated match-play, while no player-to-player touches were registered for COVID-19-modified training.
Why the study?
The study aimed to determine player-to-player distance, body-to-ball contact, and exercise intensity during three training modalities across various football populations during the COVID-19 pandemic.
Does COVID-19-modified football training reduce player-to-player contacts and exercise intensity compared to small-sided games and simulated match-play in football players?
RCT (n=213)
Randomised order
Does COVID-19-modified football training reduce player-to-player contacts and exercise intensity compared to small-sided games and simulated match-play in football players?
COVID-19-modified football training reduces player-to-player contacts and potential infection risk compared to normal match-play, but at the cost of lower exercise intensity.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
May inform lower-contact training protocols; hypothesis-generating for pandemic-era guidelines, needs prospective trials.
We determined player‐to‐player distance, body‐to‐ball contact, and exercise intensity during three training modalities in various football populations. 213 participants were recruited, ranging from 9‐year‐old boys to young men and 11‐year‐old girls to middle‐aged women. All groups were analysed with video‐filming and GPS‐based Polar Pro monitors during three types of football training for 20 min, i.e., COVID‐19‐modified training (CMT) with >2‐metre player‐to‐player distance, small‐sided games (SSG), and simulated match‐play with normal rules (SMP), in randomised order. Time spent in a danger zone (1.5 m) per‐percent‐infected‐player (DZ PPIP) ranged from 0.015 to 0.279% of playing time. DZ PPIP for SSG was higher ( P < 0.05) than CMT and SMP. The average number of contacts (within 1.5 m) with a potentially infected player ranged from 12 to 73 contacts/hour. SSG had more ( P < 0.05) contacts than CMT and SMP, with SMP having a higher ( P < 0.05) number of contacts than CMT. Time/contact ranged from 0.87 to 3.00 seconds for the groups. No player‐to‐player and body‐to‐ball touches were registered for CMT. Total player‐to‐player contacts were 264% higher ( P < 0.05) in SSG than SMP, ranging from 80 to 170 and 25 to 56 touches, respectively. In all groups, a greater total distance was covered during SMP compared to CMT (38–114%; P < 0.05). All groups performed more high‐intensity running (33–54%; P < 0.05) and had higher heart rates during SMP compared to CMT. Different types of football training all appear to exert a minor COVID‐19 infection risk; however, COVID‐19‐modified training may be safer than small‐sided game training, but also match‐play. In contrast, exercise intensity is lower during COVID‐19‐modified training than match‐play.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Sjúrðarson et al. (2022) conducted an RCT in COVID-19 infection risk during football training (n=213). COVID-19-modified training (CMT) vs. Small-sided games (SSG) and simulated match-play (SMP) was evaluated on Time spent in a danger zone (1.5 m) per-percent-infected-player (DZ PPIP) (p=< 0.05). Total player-to-player contacts were 264% higher in small-sided games than simulated match-play, while no player-to-player touches were registered for COVID-19-modified training.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: