Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Teaching students to think both empathically and critically about contentious questions of national history while discussing differences respectfully is crucially important in diverse democracies. These goals are fundamental to the role of history/social studies educators. Yet there is insufficient guidance for teachers on how to formulate and facilitate instruction to accomplish these objectives when national narratives are contested and salient to teachers’ and students’ identities, and many potential pitfalls for them and their students. Consequently, worldwide, teachers report avoiding teaching controversial aspects of national history. This research addresses this breach. It is a critical case study of national history instruction in an integrated Jewish-Palestinian school in Jerusalem, Israel that has addressed these instructional aims head-on for many years under very challenging circumstances. Through extended interviews and classroom observations, this study examines how the school reconciles empathic, identity, and historical thinking instructional goals and describes obstacles they have faced and how they have addressed those. The pedagogical approaches, including “dual-narrative” instruction, and enabling instructional practices they have developed, and their rationales for them, extend current thinking on how memory/heritage and disciplinary objectives might productively be melded and can provide needed guidance for those endeavoring to teach hard history in other settings.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
A 2026 study studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: