Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The field of nutritional sciences has gone through metamorphoses during the past 80 years since Nutrition Reviews was first published. During this time, we have seen the transition from conducting proximate analyses for determining the macronutrient content of food to identifying the essential vitamins and minerals,1,2 using foodomics and biomarkers to help us estimate what type of food and nutrients we are consuming, and determining the impact dietary patterns have on health.3–6 As such, we have borne witness to the evolution of nutritional sciences from the golden age of the discovery of the essential nutrients required to prevent the certainty of deficiency diseases to the current age of optimizing nutrition to reduce the risk of communicable and non-communicable diseases in both populations and individuals. In the United States, the first dietary guidelines were published by Caroline Hunt and Helen Atwater in 1917 and titled “How to Select Foods.”7 These guidelines identified 5 food groups to provide 8 dietary substances. The food groups were fruits and vegetables, meats and other protein-rich foods, cereals and other starchy foods, sweets, and fatty foods. The dietary substances needed for health were identified as mineral substances, protein, starch, sugar, fat, cellulose, certain newly discovered substances in very small amounts, and flavorings and condiments. These original guidelines are separate from the Dietary Guidelines for Americans, which were first launched in 1980, included 7 Dietary Guidelines Statements,8 and were based on a 1977 report by the Senate Select Committee on Nutrition called “Dietary Goals for Americans.”9 Since that time, dietary guidelines have been regularly updated and are now the foundation of national nutrition programs and international food assistance.10–12 Over the past 80 years, studies on the impact of diet and nutrition have become more complex for animal studies, for studies with human subjects (including clinical trials), and for community-based interventions. We now use measures of nutritional status as both dependent and independent variables, as they can be outcome measures for interventions and predictors of health outcomes. Summarizing the evidence from these studies and incorporating the results into policies and programs have also evolved. Literature reviews support the development of nutrition recommendations for policies and programs. At the same time, the methods for reviewing the scientific literature have expanded and now include narrative reviews and standardized methods such as systematic reviews and meta-analyses to identify and analyze the aggregate results of research studies.13 As a journal dedicated to reviewing the past and current literature to reconcile discrepancies by weighing quality and biases, and quantitively summarizing results, the editorial team for Nutrition Reviews recognizes that scientists constructively review published research papers using a variety of methods, depending on the aim, content, and scope of the review. Nutrition Reviews is implementing a new typology for identifying the articles published by the journal that acknowledges the value of various approaches to reviewing the scientific literature. (See our instructions to authors.) We encourage these diverse review approaches, given the field of publishing nutritional science research is evolving in the quickly advancing technological and economic global landscape. There are now more journals and papers to review, which makes it more complex to capture the totality of the literature. Nutrition and other sciences are now integrating multiple disciplines when studying and answering research questions. In turn, this requires reviewers with a variety of expertise to evaluate the scientific rigor and quality of papers. There is also a more rapid turnaround of papers that allows science to advance more quickly, with the presence of pre-publication of papers and the advance publishing of online open access peer-reviewed papers. However, there is also the threat of poor scientific evaluations of papers with the surge of predatory journals and the for-profit nature of many scientific journals that accept manuscripts without adequate peer review.14–17 On this 80th anniversary, the combined expertise of the editorial team at Nutrition Reviews has identified numerous areas that we believe will be prioritized for nutrition research over the next 10 years. Importantly, these areas are not siloes of investigation, and their overlap further highlights the need for team research to allow new knowledge to have a positive societal impact. The listing of the 10 areas below does not imply that other areas will not evolve over the next decade; rather, this is a call for literature reviews in these areas that are critical for the advancement of the nutritional sciences, and which ultimately will make the world a healthier planet for its inhabitants. Our top 10 important topics for the next 10 years of nutritional sciences and for Nutrition Reviews are presented next. Personalized and precision nutrition are advancing at a rapid rate due to an increase in information technology and the refinement and increased rapidity of biological assays. The application of more individualized nutrition is supporting our knowledge about how nutrition impacts life along the lifespan. The integration of epigenetics, genomic nutrition, biochemistry, the microbiome, and studies on the food we eat will become more critical in the next decade. The United States National Institutes of Health have identified precision nutrition as a framework canvassing a wide array of features, including genetics, dietary habits and eating patterns, circadian rhythms, health status, socioeconomic and psychosocial characteristics, food environments, physical activity, and the microbiome. On the other hand, personalized nutrition or nutrigenomics consider genetic and genomic contributions to an individual’s diet and metabolism that are mainly fixed, and thus don’t change much across time. Conversely, precision nutrition recognizes that humans are inherently different from one another, so when, why, and how we eat are likely as important as what and how much we eat.18,19 Nutrition and infections are intimately linked. The 2-way interaction between nutrition and infection was eloquently highlighted by Nevin Scrimshaw and colleagues in 1968.20 Research on nutrition and infections has continued to be elucidated beyond the presence of risk for disease to the sequela of diseases that can occur even after recovery from an initial infection. Studies on parasitic diseases have reported their effect on consumption, digestion, absorption, metabolism, and the loss of nutrients.21 The COVID-19 pandemic has been a powerful illustration of how nutrition and infections impact not only a person’s resistance to disease, but also the body’s response to different stages of infection based on the body’s inflammatory response.22 Additionally, obtaining a better understanding about the role that nutritional status has in post-COVID conditions may serve as an important illustration for how nutrition can impact the long-lasting effects of infections on organs even after recovery. Food and nutrition equity studies focus on the social determinants affecting the food security and nutritional status of individuals and communities. These essential studies are even more important today as the world becomes more connected and diverse, and has growing economic and social disparities.23,24 Evaluating the evidence regarding access to healthy food across populations within and across countries needs be done so nutritional interventions are implemented without leaving out vulnerable and underrepresented populations, while also respecting the rights, values, and autonomy of indigenous peoples.25–27 Reviewing economic studies related to nutritional status can provide an important underpinning on how to get food to those most in need.28 Furthermore, as food processing methods become less costly, it is important that low-cost-low-nutritional-value foods do not have a detrimental impact on the nutritional status of low-income populations. Further reviews are needed on how government and institutional decisions that impact food access, food availability, food safety, and nutritional status can have profound effects on decreasing health inequities, improving population health, and reducing healthcare costs.29,30 The food system and environment provides the foundation for getting healthy food to people. The food system depends fundamentally on ecosystems services, ie, the benefits people get from nature, including food, fresh water, nutrient regulation, pest control, and pollination.26,31,32 Evaluation of how these systems affect the initial nutritional value of food is essential to preserving a healthy supply of food. Furthermore, each step that food takes from farm to table can affect the nutritional value of food and the availability of healthy food.33,34 As the world has moved to consuming more processed food, it is essential that food processing is done in such a way that it preserves and even enhances the availability of nutrients and does not increase the risk for malnutrition.35,36 Consolidating data on how the nutritional value of food is changed when it is transported, processed, packaged, stored, and cooked will help identify methods to improve the nutritional composition of food and transfer this information to consumers.37 Climate change has far-reaching effects on planetary health, the food supply, and the nutritional content of crops.38,39 The increasing frequency and intensity of natural disasters due to climate change can severely devastate crop yields and livestock productivity, including fisheries, in areas where food insecurity is already high.40 At the same time, more gradual and insidious changes in climate (such as increases in global temperatures and increases in atmospheric carbon dioxide) can increase carbohydrates and decrease protein, iron, and zinc in plants, thus affecting the nutrient content of consumable plants.41–43 As more studies are conducted on these effects, there is a need to better describe and communicate how climate can affect nutritional status and what steps can be done to mitigate its dangerous effects, and on how crops and diets can adapt to these changes to enhance nutritional status.44 Reviews on what nutrients are most affected by climate change and how these changes may be related to the prevention and management of nutrition-related diseases will help advance the development of interventions and provide for better nutrition, agriculture, and environmental policies, and high-impact interventions. Special populations as defined by the Perkins Act 1990 in the USA45 includes vulnerable population groups such as but not limited to individuals with disabilities, individuals from economically disadvantaged families, single parents, including single pregnant women, homeless individuals, and youth who do have the support of family care. The nutritional needs of these individuals and their access to food is influenced by many factors, such as where they are within their lifespan and their geographic location worldwide.46 Reviewing studies that are specific to these populations are essential for providing appropriate interventions that meet their nutritional needs and the United Nations Sustainable Development Goals.47 Nutrition insecurity and undernutrition, including food insecurity, protein-energy malnutrition, and micronutrient deficiencies, continue to decrease the quality of life and lead to death in the world. Children, women, and especially pregnant women have remained at significant risk for undernutrition. Although there has been a decrease in the prevalence of undernutrition, the United Nation’s agencies estimate that there are still 768 million people undernourished in the world and 45 million children under 5 years of age who are affected by wasting.48 It is also now recognized that undernutrition is not restricted to children, and with an aging population in the world there is a great need to address how to maintain the nutritional status of older individuals during this current 2020–2030 Decade of Healthy Aging.49,50 Research is now finding that the effects of undernutrition are more nuanced and go beyond traditional clinical deficiency signs.51 Summarizing ongoing research on the role nutritional deficiencies have on quality of life remains important to guide future recommendations. Nutrition interventions are sponsored by public and private organizations, and in clinical and public settings, to ensure that all people can obtain their optimal nutritional status and quality of life. The categories of direct and indirect health and nutrition interventions are commonly used to describe different interventions.52 Each intervention must be culturally appropriate and cost effective.53,54 Many of the interventions are also predicated on supporting behavioral change by individuals (as may be the case with a clinical intervention) and the larger population (for a community-based approach).55 Some of the interventions may be stealthier and more unbeknown to the consumer. Summarizing the collective impact of the individual and collective components of these interventions will lead to their appropriate implementation and dissemination.56 Chronic diseases include those diseases that affect both physical and mental health. Research studying the effect of nutritional status, especially obesity, on the development and management of chronic diseases continues to identify new associations that can improve health and manage healthcare costs.57 As with infectious diseases, there is a 2-way relationship between chronic diseases and nutritional status, in that physical and mental health can directly affect nutritional status through biological mechanisms, and dietary practices can exacerbate the impact of chronic disease.58–62 Reviewing the strengths and weaknesses of the evidence for relationships between nutritional status and chronic diseases is continually needed to support clinical interventions and public health policies and programs, including the creation of dietary and biochemical standards and references. Nutrition metabolism studies include the elucidation of the biochemical pathways of the required nutrients to prevent deficiencies and other bioactive substances found in food and their metabolites. Many of these substances from food and supplements can help prevent disease and enhance health, but also have the potential to cause harm if consumed in inappropriate amounts or combinations.63 Targeted and non-targeted omics methods are also helping elucidate the impact of diet on health.64,65 Summarizing current knowledge on the foundational mechanisms will help create targeted interventions. Additionally, obtaining a comprehensive understanding on how to match these metabolic studies with food intake will provide needed evidence for dietary recommendations. In the first issue of Nutrition Reviews, Charles King, the Executive Director of the Nutrition Foundation, wrote that the journal was started “to provide an authoritative, unbiased, editorially interpreted review of the world’s current research progress in the science of nutrition.”66 With this 80th anniversary issue, the editorial team will continue to support this purpose and provide reviews that are relevant to the breadth of nutritional sciences from bench science to community-based science to meet the needs of the journal’s global audience. All authors contributed to the development and writing of this editorial. Declaration of interest. The authors have no relevant interests to declare.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Taren et al. (2021) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: