Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Background and Purpose. Educators assess outcomes throughout a student's academic experience. Abstract constructs such as professional behaviors, are difficult to fully assess; yet are considered integral to practice. Qualitative research methods are designed to explore complex phenomena and make the breadth and depth of such phenomena explicit. Yet little has been written about the use of qualitative data analysis (QDA) as a means of assessment in the academic setting. This study presents a model to assess professional behaviors in the physical therapy classroom using QDA. The model is presented both in theory and in practice. Model Description and Evaluation. At the conclusion of a 1-credit integrative problem-based learning (PBL) course within a professional physical therapy program students generated summative reflective products (ie, essays and metaphors). These reflective essays and graphic metaphors were analyzed using QDA methods to assess achievement of course outcomes. Analysis began with open coding, which led to axial coding and theme generation. A conceptual framework was developed and refined throughout the QDA process to reflect the students' perspective of this experience as evidenced by the products they created. Results of this analysis were then compared to the original course objectives for course review and revision. Scientific rigor was ensured through triangulation (methods, sources, and researchers), as well as the use of interrater reliability, member checks, and a “devil's advocate.” Outcomes. Five themes emerged from the analysis of 25 reflective essays and 6 graphic metaphors: critical thinking, commitment to learning, interaction skills, stress management, and professional identity. These findings revealed evidence of outcomes outside the originally stated course objectives and led to the development of 2 curricular threads, one of which was consistent with the expressed goals of the course while the other was consistent with the program's mission and hidden curriculum. Discussion and Conclusion. This study demonstrates how QDA, when linked with products of reflection, can be used to elucidate the breadth and depth of course outcomes achieved by students. Rich low-inference data collected in the process provided the essential detail needed for effective assessment and student feedback. Results of this study confirm the use of QDA as an assessment tool for complex phenomena such as professional behaviors. This method is of benefit to faculty, students, program directors, and the educational community at large.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Santasier et al. (2007) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: