Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
In this lecture I use an international human rights law lens through which to look at some of the key trends in current Australian welfare law and policy. In contrast to the focus in the mid-1970s on social protection as a right and as part of a broader notion of social citizenship, today’s conception of welfare is coming closer to what might be termed a right to social insecurity. I note the striking similarity between current Australian policy and the approaches advocated by conservative policy-makers and governments in both the United States and the United Kingdom, although a systematic comparative approach is beyond the scope of the lecture. I then consider the failure of the human rights community to respond adequately to a situation in which inequality is growing rapidly and those living in extreme poverty are able to realise fewer and fewer of their human rights, and I reflect on what steps should be taken to bring these issues into the mainstream of human rights analysis and advocacy. While much has been said and written recently about the challenges associated with extreme inequality and extreme poverty, and both issues clearly have major ramifications for the enjoyment of human rights, the ways in which these three issues interact with and affect one another have been given all too little attention, either in theory or in practice. Economists and development specialists often exclude human rights concerns altogether, even when their focus is explicitly on poverty elimination and inequality reduction. For example, the World Bank, the International Monetary Fund, and the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) together represent the key drivers of international-level research on development issues and together wield immense influence over the policies and programmes adopted by both developed and developing countries alike. Yet while they have each roundly condemned extreme inequality as a significant drag on, and distortion of, economic growth, all three of them treat human rights considerations as lying outside their mandated areas of competence and thus exclude them from their policies and programmes vis-à-vis specific governments (Alston 2018a). Perhaps even more surprisingly, what might be thought of as the reverse is also true. Most mainstream human rights groups consider inequality – especially in terms of income and wealth – to be beyond their principal concerns, and many pay very little specific attention to the rights of those living in extreme poverty. For that reason, I begin
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Philip Alston (2018) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: