Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
A wet digestion colorimetric method for the determination of chromic oxide marker in faeces is described. In comparison with other methods examined it has the following advantages: 1. Less critical conditions. ## 2. Higher reproducibility. ## 3. Higher recovery. ## 4. Higher daily output. ## Introduction Increasing use cf chromic oxide as a faeces reference substance in herbage intake measurements has made it necessary to investigate a more rapid and reliable routine procedure for estimating chromic oxide than the wet digestion method of Christian and Coup (1954), reported in Part VI of this series. Methods of several different authors have been examined and assessed as a routine analysis on accuracy, speed, and lack of critical conditions. A rapid and accurate wet digestion colorimetric method is pre sented in this paper. ## Discussion OF METHODS Fusion Methods The alkaline-oxidation fusion methods of Barnicoat (1945), Kane et at. (1950), Schurch et at. (1950), Raymond and Minson (1955), and Kameoka et' at. (1957) were examined. In fusing with sodium peroxide the loss in weight of the nickel crucible (25 ml) was found to be 2-5 mg per assay. The crucible became pitted and eventually holed in the base and the retention of chromate in the nickel oxide precipitate was appreciable. Both these disadvantages increased with rise in temperature. Temperature devia tions of -+- 10°0 in the muffle furnace produced differences in results of 5% and more. Fusing over gas burners at low temperature (Kameoka et at. 1957) resulted in loss of chromate up to 20% after two minutes melting. At no time was it found that the loss of chromate in the nickel oxide precipitate was a standard one of 2% as described by Barnicoat (1945) . N.Z.J. agric. Res. 3: 314-319 1960) STEVENSON AND DE LANGEN-FEED INTAKE 315 The methods of Kane et al. (1950), and Raymond and Minson ( 1955) developed from that of Edin et at. (1945), showed less loss in weight of the nickei crucible. In fusing with a mixture of sodium and potassium hydroxides, together with their carbonates and nitrates in 1 : 2 molecular ratio (Kane et at. 1950) the mixture tended to foam and creep over the edge of the crucible and the blank readings were high and variable, giving low results and poor reproducibility. Changing the carbonate: nitrate ratio to 10 : 1 (Sandell 1950) lowered the blank reading, but foaming over still occurred and was found to be due to the nitrates. Maunsell (1944) stated that fusion with sodium carbonate alone does not bring all the chromic oxide into solution and that a small amount of an oxidising substance must be added to the fusion mixture to convert all the chromium to chromate. It has been found, however, that fusion with sodium carbonate with air oxidation converts all the Cr203 to the soluble chromite, and partially further to chromate. Hydrogen peroxide readily completes the oxidation. Thus the large expenditure of nickel crucibles and the retention of chromate in the nickel oxide precipitate can be avoided if the oxidising substance is added to the crucible after fusing. The ashed sample is fused with sodium carbonate over a ga~ burner, then the crucible is placed in a conical beaker and sufficient hydrogen peroxide solution to cover the melt is added to it and allowed to react. Water is then added to the beaker and the solution boiled to ensure that the chromate is completely dissolved, and to remove excess hydrogen peroxide. After cooling and making up to the mark, the solution is filtered, and read at 400 mp.. Using 25 ml crucibles of United States origin (weight approx. 20 g, base diameter 2.4 cm) recoveries were high and reproducibility good when care was taken to mix the ash well with the sodium carbonate before fusing, and the method was made routine on a small scale pending a large delivery of crucibles. When the English-manufactured crucibles arrived they were found to be of a thinner mould, weighed approximately 15 g, and had a base diameter of 3 cm. Reproducibility dropped considerably with these and it was thought that the thinner mould was too readily overheated using bunsen burners, with the possi bility of chromium silicates being formed. The muffie furnace was· then tried, and to overcome the high melting point of sodium carbonate a molecular ratio of 1 : 1 sodium and potassium carbonates was used. Reproducibility seemed to depend essentially on sufficient mixing of the ash containing Cr203 with the carbonates. A glass rod was used to grind the lumps of ash against the side of the crucible. This time consuming mixing and the critical heating conditions dependent on the type of nickel crucible available, made it necessary to discard this method for large-scale routine work. Wet Digestion Methods The wet digestion method of Christian and Coup (1954), has been in use at this Station since 1954. Reproducibility is high when time and temperature of the digestion are kept uniform, but with excess 316 NEW ZEALAND JOURNAL OF AGRICULTURAL RESEARCH (APRIL heating the oxidising power of the solution is lost and reversion of the reaction takes place. Any effort to increase the daily output of deter minations lowered reproducibility and increased between-operator variability, again mainly because of the critical heating conditions (see Table 3). The wet-digestion method of Coup and Lancaster (1952), described in Part II of this series, was modified by Christian and Coup (1954), mainly because of its low daily output. This was due to the long boiling period necessary because the Cr203 was not readily attacked by oxidising agents at the temperature of the diluted acid mixture, and also to ensure at a later stage that all the excess bromate was removed for the back-titration. Coup (1952) and Maunsell (1944) stated that it was necessary to keep the volume of the boiling solution constant. It has been found, however, that by digesting with half quantity of the acid mixture of Coup (1952) and one-fifth the amount of bromate solution, and by boiling until the water has evaporated and the sulphuric acid started to fume, the Cr20J is brought into solution, but not all as dichromate. A further boiling with a small amount of KBr03 in a diluted solution is sufficient to oxidise all the chromic compounds to dichromate. The presence of sulphuric acid in the acid mixture keeps the temperature below the critical point where dichromate is reduced to insoluble chromic compounds. Thus the critical heating conditions of Christian's modification can be avoided and the long boiling time of Coup's method is redllced to 10-15 minutes. Excess bromate does not interfere when the sdlution is made alkaline and the chromate estimated colorimetrically. Chromate solutions obey Beer's law at low concentrations with maximum absorption at wavelength 370 mfL. To cover a wider range of concentrations without dilution, solutions can be measured at wave length 400 mfL with sufficient accuracy (see Fig. 1). 04 >- offi c 0,3, Q) 0 0 0'2 () '"5, 0 0,1 I / / / 1 I 1/ / 1 l 1/ / I.. o 2 ----370mj.J ---400mj.J 3 4 5 mg Cr2 0 3 6 Fig. 1.-0ptical density of chromate solutions expressed as Cr203. 1960) STEVENSON AND DE LANGEN-FEED INTAKE DETERMINATION OF CHROMIUM SESQUIOXIDE IN FAECES Procedure The ashed sample containing 1 to 5 mg CrZ03 is quantitatively brushed into a dry 100 ml wide-necked Erlenmeyer flask which is graduated at 100 ml, and 6 ml of acid mixture is added. After bringing to the boil, 3 ml of 4.5% KBr03 solution is added and boiling con tinued until i-I minute after fumes of SO:l appear. The flask is re moved from the hotplate, allowed to cool, then 20 ml of diluted KBrOs solution added and the mixture boiled for 3-4 minutes, cooled, made up to the 100 ml mark and mixed. With a pipette, 10 ml is transferred into a 25 ml graduated boiling tube, 5 ml 10% NaOH solution added and heated in a boiling water bath for a few minutes to allow the Mn02 precipitate to settle. The solution is cooled, brought to volume, and inverted gently once (see Note 4). Sufficient is filtered through a No. 40 Whatman filter paper and the absorption is read at wavelength 400 mf.t. A blank is run on Cr203 free faeces and reagents. For the standard curve a solution of 2.555 g K2Cr01/litre is used. (1 ml = 1 mg Cr203)' Reagents Acid Mixture: 250 ml conc. H 2S04 250 ml H 3P04 (sp. gr. 1.75) 500 ml distille
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Stevenson et al. (1960) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: