Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
OME OVERLY cautious pathologists call all S rectal polyps that show atypia, adenocarcinoma, Grade I.This attitude is a great injustice to the patient and is misleading to the surgeon.More than 150 cases reported in the literature had such atypical changes and were cured by simple polypectomy ( S ~i n t o n , ~ Mc-Lanahan et a1.,6Fisher and Turnbull,* Lockhart-Mummery and Dukes,6 Castro et aL,l and Welch et al.11).We believe with Swintone that it may require the highest degree of skill and experience to determine the presence, degree, and extent of malignant changes in a clinically benign polyp, and to advise the type of treatment.T h e purpose of the present paper is to determine how reliable biopsy of rectal polyps is in helping the surgeon decide between abdominoperineal resection and polypectomy, without minimizing the chances of a cancer cure.T h e gross and microscopic findings for all rectal polyps that had been examined in our laboratory from 1951 to 1957 were reviewed and co-ordinated with the clinical findings, including follow-up observation.There were 142 polyps removed from 107 patients.Eightyseven adenomatous polyps were regarded as benign, 28 as malignant, and 12 as invasive carcinomas.In addition, there were 15 biopsy specimens that were diagnosed as villous papillomas, 5 of them as cancerous.In classifying our material, we made the same subdivisions as Lockhart-Mummery and Dukes;: ( I ) benign (with goblet cells), 97 cases; (2) active proliferation (with slight atypia and without secretion of mucus), 11 cases; (3) carcinoma in situ, 3 cases; (4) focal intramucosal carcinoma, 19 cases; and (5) invasive carcinoma (spreading to submucosa), 12 cases.In invasivc carcinomas, we determined the grades of malignancy as low (1 case), average (8 cases), and high (3 cases).
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Hellwig et al. (1959) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: