Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Franklin and Johnson (2012) outlined elements of what they term an “ecological forestry” strategy for federal forests in the Pacific Northwest. They posit that their strategy will produce ecological and economic benefits from federal forests in Oregon and Washington and that economic returns are necessary for their widespread implementation. Thus, the strategy relies heavily on commercial thinning and an unknown amount of regeneration harvests to create economic returns. Many of their recommendations were recently incorporated into the final recovery plan and critical habitat ruling for the northern spotted owl (US Department of Interior [USDI] Fish & Wildlife Service 2012) over repeated objections raised by The Wildlife Society, American Ornithologists' Union, and Society for Conservation Biology concerning untested and risky active management proposals in owl habitat (USDI Fish & Wildlife Service Oregon Fish & Wildlife Office 2013). Franklin and Johnson's (2012) framework is based on managing forests under the premise that they will be “restored,” while producing timber from sustained yield, yet their recommendations do not adequately recognize fish and wildlife habitat needs, and they rest on inappropriate ecological baselines for judging efficacy of restoration activities. They do, however, acknowledge that their core strategies may face social opposition, insufficient funding for implementation, restrictions due to impacts to northern spotted owls (Strix occidentalis caurina), and policy conflicts with the sustained yield provisions of the National Forest Management Act. Here, we identify shortcomings of ecological forestry and how it is being implemented by managers based on our knowledge of the region's ecology, habitat needs of the northern spotted owl and other wildlife, and pertinent published literature related to conservation biology, restoration ecology, and management of wildlife and aquatic resources. Although we believe that some aspects of ecological forestry may improve with current management, the framework places economic and political interests above ecological concerns in ways likely to generate new controversies and unintended harmful ecological consequences for natural resources. The Pacific Northwest forests constitute some of the most important temperate forests on earth. They contain remaining concentrations of older forests that are currently well below historical levels due to logging (Strittholt et al. 2006). Federal forests in this region are known for exceptional biodiversity (DellaSala et al. 2011), carbon storage (Smithwick et al. 2002), late-successional habitat for >1,000 associated species (Forest Ecosystem Management Assessment Team [FEMAT] 1993), including spotted owls and marbled murrelets (Brachyramphus marmoratus), and relatively intact watersheds for numerous stocks of salmon (Oncorhynchus spp.). Because of the heated debate over what should be valued most in these “multiple use” public forests, management has been controversial and mistrust among stakeholders pervasive. The Northwest Forest Plan (NWFP) is the foundation for management of federal land across nearly 25 million acres (FEMAT 1993) and is considered a global model of ecosystem management and biodiversity conservation (DellaSala and Williams 2006). The NWFP eased controversy over logging of older forests on federal lands to some degree. However, the decline in timber receipts to local counties has resulted in considerable pressure from county commissioners, Oregon Governor John Kitzhaber, former Interior Secretary Ken Salazar, and most of the Oregon congressional delegation to increase logging. This political pressure is most apparent for the approximate 2.1 million acres of Oregon and California Revested Lands (O&C) managed by the Bureau of Land Management (BLM) in western Oregon, which has a contentious history (Blumm and Wigington 2013). In response to recent pressures, former Interior Secretary Salazar initiated a series of “pilot projects” to implement ecological forestry in 2009, which could become the foundation for resource management plans across all 2.5 million acres of BLM lands in western Oregon and legislative proposals to address the O&C counties' fiscal issues through increased timber harvests (Wyden 2012). Franklin and Johnson's (2012) framework recognizes the conservation importance of late-successional forests on federal lands under the NWFP, which was reaffirmed in the recovery plan and critical habitat rule for the spotted owl (e.g., USDI Fish & Wildlife Service 2012). The importance of older, fire-resistant tree species in dry forests and the need to protect older trees throughout the landscape is also recognized by them. They reaffirm the NWFP's emphasis on thinning dense, younger (<80 years) plantations to accelerate the acquisition of late-successional characteristics and increase the amount of forests under long rotations. Early seral forests are acknowledged by them as an important ecological stage, and a distinction is made between forests created by industrial-scale logging that are deficient in biological legacies and biodiversity versus those generated by natural disturbances that are structurally complex and rich in biodiversity (Swanson et al. 2011, DellaSala et al. 2013). Franklin and Johnson's (2012) also recommend a credible adaptive management strategy whereby integrated monitoring and research activities, regional analysis and planning, and systematic assessments of ecological and social outcomes by independent parties are key elements. We generally agree with these aspects of their framework but acknowledge that the details of some of this management are yet to be described. We identify seven major areas in which the framework of ecological forestry or its implementation by BLM may create adverse consequences to natural resources and conflicts over forest management. Franklin and Johnson (2012) stratify the landscape into moist forests (MFs) and dry forests (DFs). In MFs, older stands are reserved and previously logged plantations are logged again using variable retention regeneration harvests (VRHs). In DFs, silvicultural treatments retain and release older trees (>150 years old), reduce stand densities, shift composition toward fire- and drought-tolerant species, and incorporate multiscaled heterogeneity. Unfortunately, the moist/dry classification and associated fire regimes are much too coarse and will create on-the-ground uncertainties where forest communities are highly complex (i.e., fine-grained heterogeneity). For example, inclusion of mixed-conifer forests in the DF type within the Klamath Province of southern Oregon and northern California will subject these forests to inappropriate commercial thinning based on false notions that these forests were historically more open (see below). Plant communities and fire regimes in this region vary widely across moisture gradients, soil types, microclimates, slope exposure, elevation, and bedrock geology with different forest patches grading into one another over short distances (i.e., high beta diversity) (Odion et al. 2004). Mixed-severity fires historically created landscape mosaics in this province that included a portion of high-severity burn patches (DellaSala 2006, Donato et al. 2009, Halofsky et al. 2011) as well as those in the DF of the eastern Cascades (Hessburg et al. 2007, Baker 2012). These forests do not lend themselves to simplistic binary classifications. We disagree with the generalization of Franklin and Johnson (2012) that climate change is increasingly likely to shift plant associations toward the dry end of the moisture spectrum where plant associations straddle gradients because this assumption is not well supported and discounts considerable regional climatic variation. For example, Mote (2003) projected increased precipitation in some regions, including summer precipitation, and uncertainties in climate change modeling. Franklin and Johnson (2012) recognize the importance of both mature (>80–159 years) and old-growth (≥160 years) MFs but state that the age at which forests are “deemed older is a social decision influenced but not defined by scientific input.” The goal of the NWFP is to restore a functional, interconnected late-successional (both mature and old-growth) forest ecosystem and to produce timber. This means building on the NWFP through additional protections for old forests as recommended in critical habitat designations for the spotted owl and marbled murrelet. It also requires clear tree protection standards for older forests with greater recognition of mature forests (>80 years), given their rarity and ecological importance (FEMAT 1993, Strittholt et al. 2006). Instead, Johnson and Franklin (2009) analyzed various tradeoffs of setting tree protection thresholds at 80 to 160 years in MFs and >150 years in DFs, creating uncertainties in what to protect that have resulted in implementation controversies and poor policy choices. Such lack of clear tree protection standards has generated considerable mistrust among stakeholders who monitor the management practices of BLM pilots in southwest Oregon (Reilly 2013, Wheeler 2013) (Figure 1A−D). For instance, of seven recent timber sales monitored on BLM pilot sites (MFs) by conservation groups, there were portions of mature forests and owl critical habitat included in logging proposals, and one logging site was adjacent to a 450-year-old forest occupied by nesting murrelets that will probably create edge effects (Table 1). The net result of these sales was the incidental “take” of four spotted owls, triggering project-level appeals. These are examples of how immediate economic and political pressures have trumped older forest protections because mature forest protections were not clearly defined by the guidelines of ecological forestry. Without clear and ecologically appropriate age class restrictions, unintended ecological consequences will occur in project implementation. Ecoforestry applications on BLM pilots in southwest Oregon as documented by independent project monitoring.2 Many large (24- to 36-in. dbh) fire-resistant Douglas-firs are being removed under the guise of restoration. Clusters of large trees are marked for removal to “accelerate development of old-growth characteristics,” and new permanent roads are built for site access (BLM pilot Environmental Assessments). A. A 32-in. dbh Douglas-fir marked for removal in BLM ecoforestry Pilot Thompson unit 19-4. (Photo credit: Luke Ruediger.) B. In Pilot Thompson unit 20-1, a large 27-in. dbh Douglas-fir marked for removal and a 14-in. dbh ponderosa pine marked for retention. (Photo credit: Luke Ruediger.) C. BLM Pilot implementation. to tree The is the is (Photo credit: BLM Pilot Thompson unit of Douglas-firs dbh marked for (Photo credit: Luke Ruediger.) BLM ecological forestry pilots in MFs of western Oregon using commercial and management. were by commercial management. BLM ecological forestry pilots in MFs of western Oregon using commercial and management. were by commercial management. is the O&C legislative by Oregon which Franklin and Johnson's (2012) and tree protection at an important of the mature forest The ecological consequences of this are not and the to be and not For instance, mature forests years), which are well below historical a critical as and habitat for spotted owls et al. Without protection of these forests, a will on federal lands over that will reduce ecosystem and habitat for of associated The from the BLM Forest for all western Oregon BLM lands public and O&C is a of how from not older forests in policy For instance, these that the of forests on the BLM lands are years mature forests years) for forests of years for and old-growth forests (>150 years) for of BLM lands (Figure ecological forestry provisions as (Wyden 2012) to protect the mature forest years) Thus, of the acres in this age and be to increased logging. the age for logging was at as by Franklin and Johnson to acres of years) be at (Figure both the critical habitat rule and recovery plan for the spotted owl recommended structurally complex older mature forests with important habitat could be by logging under both the amount of mature forest acres open to logging on how spotted owl and other NWFP and are and mature forests for logging that federal lands habitat levels for numerous species associated with late-successional A. and Northwest Forest Plan in for BLM lands in western Oregon based on BLM Oregon Forest for The BLM are most in forests years by >150 years with levels of for age in southwest Oregon are not as as those in other due to the and of the BLM also acres of These are areas as and A of these stands should have been stand age because they are BLM stand age our and into the Klamath distinction is made between DF versus forest because do not these forest B. for DF on western Oregon BLM The The acres of forests years acres of stands by the BLM as a age years but with a of trees years Oregon Land for Oregon was as the to versus DF and to the moist/dry in Franklin and Johnson The should not be considered an given that the are a of plant that we as moist or This was not an for our given the classification is that the a of as lands in the Franklin and Johnson's (2012) to restoration on commercial thinning to however, for restoration to be ecologically need an appropriate from which to the efficacy of For instance, under ecological forestry what a site not with an appropriate (e.g., of high ecological (DellaSala et al. or historical will managers a site is given the long necessary to restore In in the have dry that are being to and thinning in BLM For example, fire regimes in this region are of (DellaSala 2006, Halofsky et al. 2011) and are within historical and and open plant communities were of importance historically et al. 2012). et al. and Baker (2012) also that dbh) trees were historically and in forests of the Cascades in Oregon and Washington and that open stands were Thus, this lack of an appropriate may result in that because they are based on historical but that a forest stand a that from an state not considered et al. and that could to (Figure that have been in and most by species and ecosystem to et al. The state may not be to climate change because of from stand that the effects of ecological et al. for forest based on of versus sites with to forest and species restoration a site from to high ecological based on to a or a of high ecological (DellaSala et al. Franklin and Johnson (2012) and managers that the of fire at the stand or landscape an a due to a of in However, have not this to be the in the (Odion et al. Halofsky et al. 2011) where fire as the between fire increased (Odion et al. Thus, the more complex and at in of fires that and baselines on what should the necessary to them. Franklin and Johnson (2012) acknowledged that they not adequately address aquatic and and this be to aquatic in implementation. and forest the Because and habitat for fish and wildlife are in by the of and across the forest management plan or framework should for these a For instance, and a critical across a core in which logging over the have the to fires and climate of the timber of Franklin and Johnson (2012) create a need to or the However, roads and associated are the of and of to and et al. and that may slope and Forest roads and to are currently high on previously logged lands in western Oregon et al. 2011), and resources are insufficient to the to to have where large in roads have under the NWFP et al. 2006). change on that will additional on in the et al. the silvicultural management reduce the forest and its on of and result from thinning in and areas et al. and more from logging in and areas will probably increase to et al. 2006). commercial thinning regeneration in stands years will spotted owl habitat with consequences on their and habitat et al. et al. et al. owls and in forests with high large large and and in stand et al. all characteristics that thinning and logging will Franklin and Johnson (2012) that and in thinning and retention of patches in places will for spotted owls, but there is to this They also that to of on public lands in forest is for spotted however, the forest landscape is in the BLM lands of western Because are managed under short of this amount of public lands as forests to of the forest this of owls decline late-successional forest et al. et al. et al. Unfortunately, the DF provisions for thinning in the Klamath Province where spotted owl are most numerous and currently most et al. Pilot on BLM lands also have controversial and thinning in critical habitat in mature MFs (>80 years), to incidental of owls (Table 1). in mature forests (>80 years) also has been to have effects on the of the species, including northern and et al. et al. and and and tree and 2009, and 2013). thinning the composition and of et al. an important for and other The of owls is an important ecosystem et al. and it should more forest restoration is the Franklin and Johnson (2012) one of the above but acknowledge restrictions, given the effects of thinning on as spotted owl created by commercial thinning of mature MFs and thinning to as by ecological in will have a on (e.g., northern for both spotted owls and owls (Strix who this 2012). in will likely increase the pressures on spotted owls that to be to owls et al. 2011, 2012). It is not known there are thinning that will not have these effects on of or both species, or there will be research to address this This needs to be in more commercial thinning is implemented the pilot on BLM at for California spotted owls, they high-severity fire areas for et al. and have in fire areas in forests et al. in fire logging not reduce et al. 2012) it change et al. 2013). Thus, active management is in owl habitat for fire concerns of forest by fire versus natural in DF within the region an amount of older, forests at the landscape with fire et al. 2009, et al. in the of stand fire to forest is do forests over Thus, fire have to increase the current in dry this to a state (Odion and 2013, et al. in the of high fire to forests and fire as a to spotted owls that are to ecological forestry to be and lack important of ecological forestry is that are to produce timber while creating seral habitat for be an over on but they untested benefits to seral Franklin and Johnson (2012) natural to complex seral forests, and this to generate seral forests is from the BLM Instead, the of seral forests generated by commercial logging has resulted in widespread of more simplistic forests across large (e.g., BLM in southern and a lack of complex seral forests generated by natural (Swanson et al. 2011, DellaSala et al. 2013). some wildlife species as the to complex seral habitat created by natural but to seral habitat created by logging The to be for spotted owls et al. 2012). seral forests created by high-severity fire also species to that of old-growth forests, but this is years) as development et al. 2009, et al. 2011, Donato et al. DellaSala et al. 2013). the known to complex seral forests is to them to through natural (Swanson et al. 2011, DellaSala et al. 2013). logging regeneration et al. wildlife habitat and 2006, (DellaSala et al. and of spotted owls et al. 2011, 2013, et al. and aquatic et al. development of complex seral logging timber on BLM lands with some BLM of from (e.g., BLM Bureau of Land Management 2013). of this from forests likely to have complex seral as those in key and areas with old trees by fire or are the places to complex seral forests (Swanson et al. of logging for the likely of complex seral forests across the landscape and the need to create them it to managers need to the forest not for the trees but for the landscape (Figure on For instance, BLM pilots are in a landscape highly by roads and and creating seral forests through at the stand is not given that it is not in short is a for natural harvests in remaining older forests to create seral forests also result in impacts to late-successional species and to the of older A more where the remaining mature forest are into and structurally simplistic patches (Figure may of marbled sites by and of BLM pilots in southwest Oregon a highly landscape with BLM in variable retention harvests and in within a landscape of seral forest created by logging. Northwest are the other are in the Bureau of Land Department of Franklin and Johnson (2012) ecological forestry as a new for federal lands in the Pacific key elements of their and the it is being implemented by managers with conservation biology, ecological and management of aquatic and wildlife resources. The most shortcomings of their are that it is by economic returns and political pressures, an inappropriate for will habitat for spotted owls and other seral species, will increase aquatic impacts from thinning and and may create that ecosystem to with consequences to biological with the pilot how in tree age create a greater need for and scientific from forest and wildlife We recommendations to improve the framework and its to the NWFP standards and the and and conservation in the Conservation because there have been to watersheds under this strategy et al. 2006). In MFs and areas with thinning in forests years and in spotted owl and marbled critical is scientific for this age (FEMAT mature forests are in short (Strittholt et al. are the to old-growth forests, and are habitat for these and other seral species as on of mature forests, we over ecological forestry as by the BLM with are they should be to previously managed stands years critical habitat for species or species of The effects on seral species should be In DFs, thinning is in a due to land an years or trees in (US Department of to protect large trees that are et al. and to trees for fire concerns and not the composition of stands with large trees or stands with large below their natural of (e.g., as in the ecosystem strategy guidelines in Department of et al. of to shift species composition in managed fire and fire for ecological restoration. at in (USDI Fish & Wildlife Service 2012) and late-successional forests at the et al. et al. et al. for spotted owls and other species associated with older high of large and trees for seral wildlife as Pacific et al. and spotted owls et al. and high for of by using both (e.g., stand age and (e.g., climate change to restoration We are not that to some however, clearly defined baselines with historical or areas of high ecological should be a restoration to of the impacts of “ecological forestry” and that forest restoration the of ecological including in carbon by and thinning et al. 2011), soil and of species, and forest to areas by roads through and of the and logging in and key and to conflicts over thinning to spotted owls, species, and owl a classification moist/dry to uncertainties and forests with in the to inappropriate Forest need to more with plant groups, and historical fire regimes be on appropriate management, in et al. 2011, et al. This should be given the of climate research to historical and of complex seral forests versus current of and complex seral forests to current and in forest (Odion and 2013). logging and to and composition of complex seral landscape in assessments to the effects of thinning and logging on seral species and of complex seral Franklin and Johnson (2012) state that stakeholders have created for federal managing them for or for spotted However, the NWFP was to the of >1,000 late-successional species, not owls, and is a between these Many and conservation have ways to restore forests thinning (DellaSala et al. have thinning with and other active management that constitute more restoration et al. forestry as currently will create more over management of federal forests it its as an ecologically credible we have ecological have controversy in that to increase timber by protections (Blumm and Wigington 2013). This is the for BLM lands in western Oregon because these lands have a history of and recent proposals to the increased logging at a to important ecological in short and to the public We A. B. and for of this and and for project to in of this
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
DellaSala et al. (2013) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: