Why the study?
Is the hyperventilation test valid for assessing the severity of autonomic failure in patients with MSA and PD?
Is the hyperventilation test valid for assessing the severity of autonomic failure in patients with MSA and PD?
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Hyperventilation tests for autonomic failure must standardize and record CO2 levels to accurately assess cardiovascular changes.
Hyperventilation (HV) can induce hypotension or even syncope in patients with autonomic failure (AF) (1-3). Deguchi et al. (4) investigated the validity of a HV test in patients with multiple system atrophy (MSA) and Parkinson's disease (PD). The authors aimed to assess whether cardiovascular changes during HV were compatible with the degree of autonomic dysfunction. Patients with probable MSA had a significantly larger fall of blood pressure (BP) upon standing compared with patients with possible MSA, but the BP fall caused by HV did not differ between the groups. The PD group showed a subtle reduction of standing systolic blood pressure compared with controls, but no significant BP changes during HV. The HV test was performed without feedback of the actual carbon dioxide (CO2) levels. This may present a problem, as even small changes of CO2 levels can affect BP in AF considerably (e.g. lowering PaCO2 by 5 mmHg may decrease mean arterial pressure by 6 mmHg) (2). It is well known that non-standardised HV tests result in considerable variation in the degree of hypocapnia (5). Furthermore, MSA may manifest with wide range of respiratory abnormalities including periodic irregular breathing, and thus more variation of hypocapnia may be expected (6). Therefore, the conclusion that the HV test is inappropriate to detect the severity of AF should be interpreted with much caution, as the main determinant of HV-induced hypotension in AF, i.e. the CO2 level, was not recorded. The authors stated that they have no interests which might be perceived as posing a conflict or bias.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Thijs et al. (2007) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: