Design
Editorial
This is the authors' abstract. We don't add key points for this paper.
In 2001, the Joint Commission for Accreditation of Healthcare Organizations (JCAHO) introduced a series of compliance guidelines designed to improve pain care. JCAHO acknowledged that freedom from pain is a patient right, and proposed specific requirements to improve pain assessment, and to monitor treatment. A major requirement for conformity to these guidelines was the need for health care institutions to establish a monitoring system to assess pain at appropriate intervals, and to document the effectiveness of treatment. To adhere to the guidelines, most health care organizations have adopted the use of one or more pain scales to be included along with the standard patient vital signs, hence, the concept of pain as the 5th vital sign. Like most pain specialists, I welcomed the much needed attention being directed at improving the recognition and treatment of our patient's pain. In the perioperative pain patient, this effort has proven advantageous by insuring that pain complaints will be taken more seriously, and has resulted in standards that require a patient's pain be controlled prior to discharge from the postanesthesia care unit, as documented by specific pain scale values. Unfortunately, the value of pain scales may vary considerably in their meaning and value in different patients, and in different care settings. For example, in the postanesthesia care unit, a location where pain may be attributed to a clear inciting factor, surgery, and an area with one-to-one nursing care, analgesic titration can be carefully monitored resulting in considerable patient satisfaction and benefit [1]. However, recent reports suggest that aggressive pain treatment may be potentially hazardous, when delivered on the routine hospital ward [2]. One report has shown that since the introduction of the JCAHO pain standards, the incidence of opioid-related respiratory depression has doubled [2]. This probably reflects the variability in the response of individual patients to opioids and their side effects. Aggressive pain treatment requires frequent assessment, dose adjustments based on a variety of factors including patient age, and underlying medical illness, and prior history of opioid exposure. In some individuals, significant pain reduction may occur only at dosages producing significant side effects. This does not imply that satisfactory pain control is unattainable, but implies that a more careful plan must be created. All too often, analgesia is equated with administering more opioid. However, with careful assessment and planning, a combination of nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs, local anesthetic infiltration or nerve blocks, and other adjuvant medications may be combined with opioids to provide the best combination of pain relief and symptom management. Sole reliance on pain scores can also be problematic in the management of patients suffering from chronic pain conditions. Pain scales in chronic pain patients are often confusing at best. Most patients will report consistently elevated pain scores, reflecting the chronic nature of their disease. Even with liberal opioid administration, many patients will continue to rate their pain at a numeric score of greater than 4. For this reason, most pain specialists choose to use a range of measures to assess pain, such as functional improvement, reduction in suffering, and overall improvements in quality of life. Chronic pain patients undergoing acute surgical procedures generally report elevated pain scores compared with matched controls. They consistently require two- to threefold more opioid, and often experience greater anxiety reduction with opioid use [3]. Thus, efforts to achieve arbitrary guidelines, such as a numeric pain score of less than 4, may not be universally applicable to all patients. Recently, Mularski et al. published their findings on a retrospective analysis of pain scores recorded from patients attending several primary care clinics at a Veterans Administration Medical Center, which showed little impact of documented pain scores on their physician's evaluation and treatment of the patient's pain complaints before and after the introduction of the “Pain as a Fifth Vital Sign” initiative [4]. This was interpreted to suggest that documentation of pain scores was not useful in directing more attention to patient's pain problem. At first look, this would suggest that pain scores are not a useful tool and offer no benefit to the patient. On the contrary, what their data likely represent is a lack of attention on the part of physicians to pain problems and, in all likelihood, a knowledge deficit as to how to evaluate treat patients with chronic pain problems. It could also be argued that many of their patients fall into the chronic pain category; hence, the interpretation of pain scores becomes more difficult. This, however, seems unlikely, as the researchers were unable to identify evidence of a treatment plan specific to evaluating and treating the patient's pain complaints. There simply was a failure to address the pain problem. What I take from all of this is that the Veteran's Administration and JCAHO initiatives have further identified one of the critical problems in the delivery of pain care within the United States, and that is the physician. Doctors consistently prefer to ignore pain issues, whether through lack of concern, or a lack of knowledge on how to manage pain. Recognizing that pain scores in the chronic pain setting may not be dramatically impacted does not relieve the physician from the responsibility to evaluate, devise a treatment plan, and to develop a method of assessing patient response. Taking the time to document a treatment plan and to identify the parameters that will be used in measuring patient progress must be included in any patient identifying ongoing pain. Currently, it appears that the medical profession is only doing a good job at identifying what poor-quality pain care they are delivering. In this age of legal liability and patient rights, we are only digging a deeper hole. Where do we go from here? The most obvious solution would seem to be improved physician and medical student education on pain topics. Unfortunately, education often does not dramatically influence physician practice. The adoption of best practice patterns typically requires the adoption of a monitoring system with structured incentives, usually negative. At the very least, it will be necessary to construct a system to monitor, not just the documentation of pain scales, but a system to address the response to these scales. As alluded to above, simply looking for cut-off numbers will not be an adequate measure of efficacy, pain is a complex sensory and emotional response, thus indicators of suffering and patient satisfaction with their care will likely be more sensitive at detecting improvement. We have taken the first step in documenting pain; it appears that we are ready for the next step, treating pain!
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Documenting pain scores as a fifth vital sign is insufficient to improve pain management without comprehensive physician education and treatment plans.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Frederick W. Burgess (2006) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: