Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The propagation of hydromagnetic waves in a horizontally stratified atmosphere is of interest in connection with theories of sunspot magnetic fields and coronal heating. The problem was briefly discussed by Ferraro (1954), who assumed that both the particle velocity and the magnetic field variations were perpendicular to the magnetic field. The resulting motion is a simple Mfve'n or A-wave, in which there is equipartition of kinetic and magnetic energy. In this paper we consider the more general case taking account of the compressibility of the gas. The associated waves, which may be termed "S-waves," are such that the particle velocity and magnetic-field variations have both horizontal and vertical components. They are of two main types, and, if the frequency is large, one of them is similar to an A-wave and the other behaves effectively as a sound wave. The A-type wave is characterized by the fact that the vertical components of the velocity and magnetic field variations are negligible. (These S-waves and A-waves are the analogues of the modified sound and Mfve'n waves first discussed by van de Hulst, 1951.) This corroborates Cowling's conclusion that gravity will tend to inhibit vertical motions in a hydromagnetic wave and, ipso facto, lends support to Cowling's criticism of Alfven's theory of sunspots. The bearing of the result on the propagation of hydromagnetic waves in the solar chromosphere and corona is discussed, and it is tentatively suggested that the solar spicules may be explained on the basis of the sonic type of S-waves.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Ferraro et al. (1958) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: