Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
When historians write about historical issues associated with the American Constitution, what is their goal?What are they trying to do?At one stage the answer was simple: Offer an accurate description of the facts.If it turns out that the Framers were good democrats attempting to discipline potentially evil representatives by reference to the will of the assembled people, the historian should simply announce that (happy) fact.If, on the other hand, the facts show that the Framers were manipulative, self-interested aristocrats seeking to limit the power of the public, the historian's job is to say so.It is now much disputed whether and to what extent this conception of the historian's role can be sustained. 1Of course there is no view from nowhere; of course we all stand somewhere.Perhaps any historical account, offered by someone in a particular time and place, will reflect current preoccupations and potentially controversial assumptions.To say the least, it is hard to avoid forms of selectivity in dealing with the past.This possibility should certainly not be read for more than it is worth. 2 No one ought to doubt that nations, including the United States, have had a past; no one should doubt that there are really facts to which any historical account must attempt to conform.But human beings see history through their own filters, including their own assumptions, and the result is, inevitably, something other than unmediated access to what happened before.Whether this is a serious obstacle to the traditional understanding of the historian's task is a large and disputed question.The traditional constitutional lawyer 3 tends to view the historian's role in pretty conventional terms, as a search for "the facts." 4 Often historians have been sharply critical of constitutional history as done by constitutional lawyers; when they are, they tend to see the constitutional lawyer as an advocate, or as a debased historian, mining the past for insights
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Cass R. Sunstein (1995) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: