Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
There is too much 'mountain timetable' these days . . .what I want is a paper-in which I can hear the roaring of the torrent, and see the snows and the brown heather and the clouds flying athwart the blue above the rocky peaks-something that will set my pulses beating; and conjure up dear old Scotland; and what is of no particular interest are some of these papers; all miles and fact and minutes, and endless dissection of the unhappy points of the compass.To me these are really little more interesting than an architect's specification for building a dry stane dyke. 1 While readers might not necessarily share these views, amid the elegant protestations an intriguing line of argument emerges: one that sets up the aesthetic and sensual qualities of mountain walking in direct opposition to reductive and numerical abstractions of those same experiences on foot.For Gibson Stott, the familiar conventions of the romantic landscape canon were routed through a personal, emotional connection with nature's sublime qualities.However masterful, his mountaineer was also embodied: a sensing traveller attentive to feelings of freedom, awe and longing inspired by natural surroundings.It was with considerable regret that he noted efforts increasingly skewed towards a quantification of outdoor practice.His problemperceived in bold relief-was a very different mode for registering outdoor experience: one based on objective measurement, cartographic knowledge and normative conduct.Numbers, facts and systems for order, it seems, were the province of an unpalatably rational frame of mind.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Lorimer et al. (2003) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: