Key result
The mean real-world cost of transvenous lead extraction was £9228 (£17,574 with reimplantation), substantially exceeding the UK NHS tariff of £2530 for elective and £4764 for non-elective procedures.
Why the study?
What are the real-world costs of transvenous lead extraction and device reimplantation compared to reimbursement tariffs?
Observational (n=74)
No
What are the real-world costs of transvenous lead extraction and device reimplantation compared to reimbursement tariffs?
The real-world cost of transvenous lead extraction significantly exceeds the UK NHS reimbursement tariff, highlighting a major funding shortfall for extracting centres.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Exceeds NHS tariffs, revealing major underfunding for extraction centres; leaves open effects on service sustainability and access.
AIMS: Transvenous lead extraction is challenging, often requiring specialist equipment and prolonged hospital admission. A single tariff or itemized costs may be available for reimbursement. Due to limited data relating to the costs of transvenous extraction, it is unclear whether either form of reimbursement is adequate. We aim to describe accurately the total real-world costs of managing patients undergoing transvenous extraction at a single, large centre. We further aim to consider the additional costs of device reimplantation. METHODS AND RESULTS: At a single UK extraction centre, a retrospective, patient level service line analysis was undertaken, during a complete financial year. Seventy-four patients required transvenous extraction (47 infected and 27 non-infected; 156 leads). Sixty-nine procedures (93%) were performed under general anaesthesia, with a median time in theatre of 95 min [interquartile range (IQR) 71-120]. Specialist extraction tools were required for 130 leads (83%). The median hospitalization duration was 3 days (IQR 1-8). The mean cost of extraction was £9228 (±4099); infected £10 727 (±4178) and non-infected £6619 (±2269). With the additional costs of device reimplantation, the overall mean cost rose to £17 574 (±12 882); infected £22 615 (±13 343) and non-infected £8801 (±5007). At the time of this study, the UK NHS tariff was £2530 for elective and £4764 for non-elective extraction, covering barely half of the real costs. CONCLUSION: We demonstrated a substantial difference between the real-world cost of extraction and the UK NHS tariff. Extracting centres should scrutinize their practice, including the timing of reimplantation.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Brough et al. (2018) conducted an observational in Patients requiring transvenous lead extraction (n=74). Transvenous lead extraction was evaluated on Total real-world costs of managing patients undergoing transvenous extraction. The mean real-world cost of transvenous lead extraction was £9228 (£17,574 with reimplantation), substantially exceeding the UK NHS tariff of £2530 for elective and £4764 for non-elective procedures.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: