Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Proper ECG lead placement and provocative testing are crucial to differentiate early repolarization syndrome from Brugada syndrome in patients with recovered sudden cardiac death, as misclassification is common and carries prognostic implications.
This editorial refers to ‘Significance of electrocardiogram recording in high intercostal spaces in patients with early repolarization syndrome’†, by T. Kamakura et al., on page 630. Electrophysiologists and cardiologists interested in sudden cardiac death have been very lucky over the past decades. Many improvements in our knowledge about the causes of cardiac death have allowed better recognition and proper protection of patients at risk. Until the 1980s, a significant number of patients were left undiagnosed after a documented episode of sudden cardiac death. We used to use the term ‘idiopathic ventricular fibrillation’ to classify these patients. It was a clear recognition of our inability to understand why these patients presented with malignant arrhythmias. However, the effort, curiosity and perseverance of many investigators led to the description of new, unsuspected causes of arrhythmic death. Genetics knowledge and the development of powerful tools to study human DNA variability opened a completely new era in the investigation of sudden cardiac death in the structurally normal heart. Long QT, Brugada,1 short QT or early repolarization syndromes are some examples of newly described diseases that have benefited from advances in basic genetics research. Progress in our understanding of these monogenic diseases has allowed the description of rather novel pathogenic mechanisms and dissemination of the knowledge to increase awareness in the medical community to identify possible patients at risk. Despite the potent tools available to clinicians, the electrocardiogram (ECG) still plays a major role in the diagnosis and recognition of patients suffering from these diseases. In fact, in the majority of these diseases, the ECG continues to be the main clue for their diagnosis. Thanks to improved awareness, and the fact that ECG recordings are inexpensive, non-invasive and widely used, there has been an increase in the identification of these diseases. However, reading an ECG has a personal, subjective aspect. Recognition of an abnormal ECG depends on the characteristics of the ECG itself (more or less abnormal), on the ability of the reader to recognise it (previous experience, training) and on the circumstances and how the ECG is recorded. We know that in some patients an abnormal ECG will be recorded during exercise or at rest, immediately before or after an episode of arrhythmia or after provocative tests. To better transmit the information there has been a tendency to simplify the message towards one specific ECG (i.e. one disease). Long QT syndrome is recognised because of the prolongation of the QT interval while short QT syndrome is exactly the contrary. It looks simple and clear, however, we know how difficult it is to set up a limit for normal vs. abnormal in borderline cases and to classify mixed phenotypes. A Brugada syndrome patient may have an accompanying short or long QT interval. A long QT patient may have a Brugada ST segment elevation. Conduction abnormalities may be present in any specific mutation, but we also know that they are much more frequent in sodium channel defects and are a landmark in females with Brugada syndrome. The study by Kamakura et al.2 analyses the presence of an early repolarization and Brugada ST segment elevation patterns in a population of patients recovered from sudden cardiac arrest. The study reinforces the value of the proper analysis of the clinical picture, including ECG scrutiny, to avoid mistakes. In Brugada syndrome, the ECG can change dramatically from non-diagnostic to clear diagnostic at different moments of the day or even using different precordial lead locations. If the diagnostic ECG (coved-type ST segment elevation in right precordial leads) occurs because of the recording of electrical imbalances in the right ventricular epicardium, proper location of the precordial leads is mandatory to obtain the ECG with the clearest abnormality. In some patients this might represent the second, third or fourth intercostal space.3 Similar considerations should be accounted for with early repolarization syndrome. The early repolarization pattern has been considered benign for many years. When Aizawa et al.,4 in a single case, and Haissaguerre et al.5, in a series of patients, described the possibility that early repolarization pattern could be at the origin of ventricular fibrillation, the question was raised regarding how to identify patients at risk for developing the malignant arrhythmias and how to make the correct ECG interpretation. Early repolarization has been recognized in a number of patients with malignant arrhythmias, some of them recovered from sudden cardiac death, but it is also recognized in a very large proportion of normal young adult athletes.4–9 If ∼20% of normal young individuals do have the classical aspect of early repolarization, it does not make any sense to consider all them at risk for sudden cardiac death. However, some of them do die suddenly, and identification of those few at risk is essential. In this issue, Kamakura et al.2 investigate 56 patients with recovered sudden cardiac death and early repolarization pattern in the inferior and lateral leads and raise the issue of whether the early repolarization syndrome should be considered a disease of exclusion until the clinical diagnostic criteria of this syndrome are more accurate. It seems that this should be the case, based on the prevalence of this sign in the general population, and also based on the data provided. Careful evaluation after ECG analysis and provocative drug testing showed that a large number of patients were in fact misclassified. They show that one-third was directly diagnosed as Brugada syndrome after standard ECG at follow-up, questioning the original diagnosis. In addition, in a significant percentage of the rest of the patients, a diagnostic mistake was made: some had a non-diagnostic but abnormal Brugada ECG pattern after drug challenge and only a minority remained exclusively with a classical early repolarization pattern. It is surprising that despite the large volume of information concerning Brugada syndrome and the use of higher location ECG leads and pharmacological tests to unmask it, some patients were simply misclassified as having early repolarization and not Brugada syndrome. This coincides with the later recognition of the use of different ECG leads to unmask an abnormal ECG.10 Most interesting, the follow-up showed that the recurrence rate was very high in all groups except the one having solely abnormalities related to an early repolarization syndrome. Some reports have already attracted the attention about the worst prognosis in patients who combine Brugada ECG pattern with early repolarization pattern in the inferior leads. It is still unknown whether this worse prognosis arises from structural defects, combined genetic defects or possible environmental or modifying factors,7 but all options are possible and probably true. Certainly, as we said in the introduction, we can be very happy about what we have learned over the past decades about sudden death in the structurally normal heart, but we still have a lot to learn about how the different abnormalities combine with each other, modulate each other, protect or increase the danger for the occurrence of malignant arrhythmias and, finally, increase or decrease the risk for suffering an episode of sudden cardiac death. Conflicts of interest: The authors have no conflicts of interest to declare.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Brugada et al. (2015) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: