This is the authors' abstract. We don't add key points for this paper.
Britain has recently undergone the first review of its system of nurse and midwifery education for over a decade. The Statutory Body, the United Central Council set up a Commission in which has made an exhaustive investigation into current training and education arrangements (2). The Commission began its work against a background of considerable discontent from employers about the present system in Britain. This is predicated on the principles enshrined in Project 2000, which first saw light in the mid-1980s and has been introduced incrementally throughout the four countries since then. Essentially this was based on a concept of producing ‘knowledgeable doers’ (1). Midwifery has a separate set of arrangements but the criticism of both it and nursing is that the system is failing to produce practitioners who are fit for practice at the point of qualification. Feeling was such that Government Ministers called for a more practically orientated training that took students back to the bedside. It was also timely to examine the education system because of the many changes in health policy that have occurred. The pace of change in health care delivery has intensified. Additionally a newer context exists that has seen education become a part of the tertiary education system rather than a function of hospital-based training schools. The Commission was therefore charged to prepare a way forward for preregistration nursing and midwifery education that enables fitness for practice based on health care need. It employed a mixed methodology in its collection of the data that underpin its findings. It consulted widely with the professions, employers, pressure groups, professional organizations and health departments through surveys, oral and written evidence. It commissioned reports and conducted rigorous literature reviews. Importantly it also sought opinion from 84 000 existing students and registered practitioners. There was much evidence of good practice with the delivery of flexible, innovative programmes based on close collaboration between health services and higher education institutions. Despite these significant strengths, and with an acceptance that the expectations of employers might be unrealistic, there was also clear evidence that there are problems associated with current programmes that impact on fitness for practice at the point of registration. Although there were differences between nursing and midwifery and between the four countries of the United Kingdom a number of issues emerged consistently that shaped the Commissions recommendations. The Commission identified the wide variability in careers advice available to potential recruits to nursing and midwifery. It was surprised also at the lack of employer participation in selection procedures. It proposes a raft of mechanisms to widen the entry gate making full use of credit accumulation to ease access for non-standard entrants. The Commission urges the expansion of graduate preparation to meet the demands for workforce flexibility and role diversity as well as to meet the career expectations of young people. The Commission received no evidence that it should put back the clock and return to an apprenticeship system. It nevertheless calls for more transparency concerning the practice component of programmes which it believes should be spelled out clearly in terms of the outcome standards which students are expected to achieve. It explicitly states that a competency based approach should be introduced so that all those involved can see precisely what students are capable of doing. It is equally emphatic that the assessment of practice should be treated with equal importance to the assessment of practice. Clearly this will lead to the use of portfolios of practice experience and a better balance between university and practice-based study. There is wide agreement that modern day students possess many positive qualities such as a good theory base, research awareness, good communication skills and insight into their personal limitations. But there has been disturbing anecdotal evidence that newly qualified nurses and midwives have a need for constant for support and have practical skills deficiencies. Consequently the quality of the student practice-learning experience received much attention. Since the health service does not employ the students during their preparation the interest taken in them by service providers varied considerably. Although there were examples of thorough clinical supervision of students, there was also ample evidence that students are seen as an inconvenience in busy clinical environments. A vicious circle emerges. Students lack practice skills and confidence. This in turn is interpreted by permanent staff as lack of motivation who then fail to offer students the support needed for them to practice competently. The Commission sees the solution to this in longer placements that enable students to be a more consistent part of clinical teams. It also prescribes a period of three months’ supervised practice towards the end of programmes. A call is made for closer working relationships between health service providers and universities with a clear statement of their respective commitments to students. At the heart of this is the joint monitoring of the quality of practice placements. It is acknowledged that no one individual can provide the full range of expertise required by students so the recommendation is that diverse teams of academic and practice staff should work together to provide the necessary mentorship for students. New roles such as lecturer-practitioners are also advocated with identified funding to support learning in practice. The Commission largely produced recommendations which can be implemented in the next two to three years. In some respects therefore it lacks the radicalism that many would have wished of it. Its report nevertheless identifies those things that will need more thought. In particular it gives strong hints that specialization during preregistration education, in which respect Britain is out of step with most the rest of the world, is something that warrants further consideration. The Commission was also under pressure from some quarters to identify a date for the introduction of an all-graduate profession. Although this could happen quickly in Scotland, Northern Ireland and Wales there remain the recruitment problems encountered in England. This led to the seemingly contradictory position where the report calls for more graduate programmes alongside a demand to admit those without formal qualifications. The UKCC Commission plainly did a useful job. Its findings are consistently diplomatic and despite its apparent modesty, it has managed to secure the wide political support necessary for more sustained and substantial change in the future.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
P. Bradshaw (2000) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: