Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Fast neutrons are at present being considered as a possible alternative to more conventional radiotherapy in the treatment of cancer. The relative biological effectiveness (R.B.E.) of this high linear energy transfer (L.E.T.) radiation is known to depend on the size of the dose (1,2). It is also of considerable importance to the therapist to know whether the R.B.E changes markedly with the particular tissue being irradiated. Basic Differences Between Survival Curves Produced by X Rays and Fast Neutrons: There are three basic differences between the survival curves produced by exposing mammalian cells to low- and high-L.E.T. radiations, e.g., x rays and fast neutrons: (a) At all dose levels, the R.B.E.3 for fast neutrons relative to x rays remains greater than unity (Fig. 1). (b) The shoulder of the survival curve for cells irradiated with x rays is normally larger than that for irradiation with fast neutrons, i.e., the extrapolation number is larger with x rays than with neutrons. A consequence of this difference is that the R.B.E. for fast neutrons is highest at small doses and decreases with increasing level of injury (Fig. 1) (1, 2). (c) To produce the same level of injury in anoxic cells as in well oxygenated cells, the dose of x rays must be increased by a factor of 2 to 3. This factor is the oxygen enhancement ratio (O.E.R.). For fast neutrons, the O.E.R. is less than for x rays, so that the R.B.E. for anoxic cells is greater than that for well oxygenated cells in the ratio of the O.E.R. for x rays to that for neutrons. This ratio is termed the “gain factor” (3). If a population of cells is mainly well oxygenated with a small proportion of anoxic cells, the resulting survival curve will be biphasic, as was first shown with x rays by Powers and Tolmach (4), and is illustrated for both x rays and fast neutrons in Figure 2. Because the O.E.R. for neutrons is less than that for x rays, the “break-away” point for neutrons occurs at a lower level of survival than for x rays, and the change in slope from the aerobic to the anoxic component is less. The Gain Factor: It has been demonstrated that for a variety of bacterial and cell lines, the gain factor for fast neutrons, for each strain, was proportional to its O.E.R. for x rays (5). In the same way, all the gain factors for mammalian cells and tissues known to the author have been plotted as a function of their O.E.R. for x rays (Fig. 3). The relationship between the gain factor and the O.E.R. for x rays appears to be the same for cells and tissues irradiated with cyclotron-produced neutrons with a mean energy of 6 MeV. The relationship also appears to be very similar for irradiation with cyclotron-produced and 14 MeV neutrons, but for neutrons of lower energy, the gain factors appear to be larger. This is contrary to the suggestion by Broerse et al. (20) from their own observations with one cell line, that the gain factor is independent of neutron energy between 1 and 15 MeV.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
S. B. Field (1969) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: