Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
THE FALL OF ECE?Kirsty Johnston's week-long New Zealand Herald feature on early childhood education (ECE) fits within wider debates about education and the role of teachers.Johnston's (2015) reports indicated 'sector-wide concerns about quality' in which children might experience some kind of 'developmental damage' because of caring and teaching practices, learning conditions, and management.Opposition members of parliament, the union, and teacher educators are very concerned about levels of funding needed in order to get back on track with the strategic plan for fully qualified teaching teams (Ministry of Education, 2002).However the Minister and corporate spokespeople regard quality provision failures to be largely isolated and treated appropriately through existing governance mechanisms.The Early Childhood Council (ECC), in addition, argues that the ways in which Government intervenes in the targeting of funding impacts negatively on quality.I think that the task is not to increase regulation and surveillance but rather to increase support.In terms of purposefully not creating more surveillance and regulation, I presume that the ECC will be happy.The purpose of the Council is to lobby government for less intervention in order to let the market generate and ensure quality ECE via the consumer (ECC, 2013).However in the current debate, are parents hearing that the market is sorry for failing to provide a satisfactory service?In terms of support I think there is a need to explore how the very debate tends to proceed.The public have been presented with regular revelations about similar concerns, accusations, and recommendations.The debates do not go away, but they certainly fade from public awareness.During the periods of faded attention there are still many advocates and advocacy groups, and more importantly there are the many teachers and student teachers standing up for the things that they are concerned about, standing up for themselves and standing up for others.So for sure people are doing something-without much support until for a brief period media exposure suggests change is vital.If something is going to change, something quite big needs to change in terms of the way the sector supports itself.It needs a big, mobilised, inclusive campaign.Teacher qualifications are one example in which some new thinking about how to be inclusive and supportive might be generated.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Andrew Gibbons (2015) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: