Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Whenever irrigation fluid enters the intravascular space, dangerous complications can arise. This is best described as the transurethral resection of the prostate (TURP) syndrome. The syndrome has also been reported after endometrial ablation [1-5] and ureteroscopic procedures with irrigating solutions [6-8]. TURP syndrome may occur as quickly as 15 minutes after resection starts [9-11], or up to 24 hours postoperatively [12]. Of approximately 400,000 TURP procedures each year [13], 10% to 15% incur TURP syndrome [14,15] and the mortality is 0.2% to 0.8% [16,17]. TURP syndrome affects many systems and manifests itself mainly through acute changes in intravascular volume and plasma solute concentrations (Figure 1). Despite this seemingly consistent etiology, TURP syndrome lacks a stereotypical presentation; therefore, its diagnosis is difficult (Table 1) [14,18-23]. Further, recent work suggests that the conventional perioperative management of both TURP and the TURP syndrome may have to be revised.Figure 1: The variety of mechanisms and pathways that lead to transurethral resection of the prostate (TURP) syndrome. The triggering event is the entry of irrigation solution into the intravascular compartment (A), which increases intravascular volume (B) with its sequelae and decreases (C) and/or increases (D) solute concentration. The Figure showsthe complex interactions that need to be considered when the TURP syndrome unfolds. IV = intravenous.Table 1: Signs and Symptoms Attributed to Transurethral Resection of the Prostate Syndrome by Major Physiologic System and Increasing SeverityThe TURP Procedure Surgical features of TURP vary (Table 2) [17,18,24-31]. The irrigation used ranges from distilled water to a variety of nonhemolytic glycine, sorbitol, and mannitol solutions [17,32,33]. No consistent correlation has been found between the volume of fluid absorbed, the duration of TURP, and the weight of removed tissue [11,14,29,30]. The irrigation fluid either gains direct intravascular access (through the prostatic venous plexus), or is more slowly absorbed from the retroperitoneal and perivesical spaces [25,26,29] (Figure 2).Table 2: Surgical Features of Transurethral Resection of the Prostate by Patient AgeFigure 2: Anatomy of hypertrophic prostrate. The hypertrophic gland represents glandular and leiomyomatous hyperplasia of the submucosal glands and the smooth muscle of the prostatic urethra, which pushes the normal prostatic tissue to create a "surgical capsule." (Reproduced with permission from Wong KC, Liu W-S: Anesthesia for urologic surgery. In: Stoelting RK, Barash PG, Gallagher TJ, eds. Advances in anesthesia. Vol 3. Chicago: Year Book Medical, 1986:379).TURP Syndrome: Intravascular Volume Shifts Intravascular Volume Expansion Both hypertension and hypotension [14,34-36] occur during TURP syndrome. The rapid volume expansion [one patient gained 3.3 kg in 20 minutes [11]] from absorbed irrigant during TURP can explain hypertension with reflex bradycardia [19,37,38]. Absorption rates can reach 200 mL/min [29]. Patients with poor left ventricular function may develop pulmonary edema from acute circulatory volume overload [39]. A report of five patients with severe TURP syndrome (two deaths, two seizures, and one ventricular arrhythmia) found "no significant variations" in serum osmolalities before and after TURP [35], which suggests that intravascular volume changes independent of osmolality may play an important role in the morbidity and mortality associated with TURP syndrome. Several factors contribute to the volume gained, prominent among which are the intravesicular pressure (governed by the height of the irrigation bag above the prostatic sinuses) and the number of prostatic sinuses opened [37,39]. Antidiuretic hormone produced by the stress of surgery [40], increased renin, and aldosterone secretion [41] may also contribute to volume expansion by promoting water retention. Intravascular Volume Loss Perioperative hypotension during TURP is sometimes preceded by hypertension [37,38,42]. Profound hyponatremia by itself does not explain the hypotension [43]. However, hyponatremia with hypertension may lead to net water flux along osmotic and hydrostatic pressure gradients out of the intravascular space and into the lungs, which triggers pulmonary edema and hypovolemic shock [37,42]. This concept is consistent with the findings of Hahn [38], who reported that 12 patients absorbed more than 1 L of isotonic irrigant intravascularly during TURP. After the first 20 minutes of the procedure, the patients were hypervolemic and hypertensive and had increased central venous pressure (CVP). After 30 to 35 minutes, when the rate of irrigant absorption slowed, flow from the plasma to the interstitium increased to an average of 75 mL/min and CVP decreased. Three patients then became suddenly hypotensive (systolic blood pressure <or=to80 mm Hg), two of whom became hypotensive again after the procedure. Three other patients suddenly became hypotensive within the first postoperative hour. Such fluctuating intravascular fluid volume may explain the intraoperative hypervolemia and hypertension followed by postoperative hypovolemia and severe hypotension. Sympathetic blockade induced by regional anesthesia may compound TURP syndrome. Intraoperative endotoxemia can occur in up to 45% of patients with negative preoperative urine cultures despite routine antibiotic prophylaxis [44]. Absorption of distilled water during TURP can cause acute hypoosmolality with massive hemolysis [45]. Bleeding and red blood cell destruction are additional sources of volume and oxygen-carrying capacity losses. The hemoglobinemia that follows such hemolysis, coupled with hypotension, can cause acute renal failure and death [18,37,46]. Osmotically Active Solutes Glycine, sorbitol, and mannitol are electrically nonconducting, but osmotically active, solutes that are added to irrigation fluids to decrease the risk of massive intravascular hemolysis. Their use in irrigation solutions has reduced the occurrence of significant hemolysis and death by more than 50% [46]. Although distilled water may still be used by some clinicians [17,18,24,36], the irrigation solutions most often used now range in calculated osmolality from 178 mOsm/kg water for 3% sorbitol to 200 mOsm/kg for 1.5% glycine solutions or to isotonic sorbitol or glycine solutions. Osmolality calculations for irrigation solutions assume that there is no interaction between solute particles. Since these interactions do occur, calculated osmolality values are slightly greater (10-20 mOsm/kg) than the solution's measured osmolality. Treatment of Intravascular Fluid Volume Shift. Massive absorption is more likely if intravesicular pressure increases above 30 mm Hg. Limiting the height of the irrigation bag to 40 cm above the prostate [47] or using continuous irrigating resectoscopes or suprapubic trocar drainage [48] can minimize absorption. If intravesical pressure is kept below 15 cm H2 O, absorption virtually ceases [10]. Resection time under one hour and leaving a rim of tissue on the capsule until near the end of the procedure, where it can either be left (if signs of TURP syndrome are evident) or removed all at once, may reduce the time that a large number of prostatic sinuses are open and thus capable of absorbing fluid [14,37] (Figure 2). The most widely used indicator of volume gain is serum sodium dilution [14,31] or breath-alcohol level when ethanol is used as a tracer in the irrigation solution [1,30,49]. Other methods follow volumetric fluid balance [14,38,49], CVP trend [44], plasma electrolyte concentrations (e.g., magnesium and calcium) [50], irrigation solutes [glycine [31], sorbitol [33]], transthoracic impedance change [51], and the patient's weight gain [52]. No method guarantees that TURP syndrome will be avoided [36]. Before reflexively treating TURP syndrome with hypertonic saline, hypervolemia with near-normal osmolality must be excluded [39,53]. Symptomatic cardiovascular or pulmonary compromise requires aggressive intervention. After adequate pulmonary gas exchange and hemostasis are established, administration of blood, the positive inotropic agents calcium and magnesium [50], or diuretics or augmentation of intravascular volume may be needed. TURP Syndrome: Plasma Solute Effects Solute changes may alter neurologic function independent of volume-related effects (Table 3). Acute hyponatremia caused by the rapid absorption of a large volume of sodium-free irrigation fluid-one form of acute water intoxication-can trigger the central nervous system (CNS) complications but other factors may play a role [11,37,54]. Spinal anesthesia associated with hypotension can contribute to nausea and vomiting [20]. CNS symptoms may also be caused by the derangements of sodium, osmolality, ammonia, glycine, and also benzodiazepines and narcotics.Table 3: Factors That, Alone or in Combination, Can Affect the Central Nervous System During Transurethral Resection of the ProstrateHyponatremia Profound hyponatremia has been implicated as the cause of visual aberrations, encephalopathy, pulmonary edema, cardiovascular collapse, seizure, and death [54]. The incidence of serum sodium concentration less than 125 mmol/L after TURP may reach 15% [15] with a mortality of 40% when hyponatremia is symptomatic (headache, nausea, vomiting) [53,55]. Dilutional hyponatremia may be aggravated by electrolyte losses into accumulations of infused but extravasated nonelectrolyte fluid [43]. Hyponatremia is common, and serum sodium concentration decreases of 6 to 54 mmol/L have an incidence ranging from 7% to 26% [34,39]. Decreases from a normal preoperative level to 113 and 104 mmol/L after just 15 minutes of resection with isotonic irrigants have been reported [9,11]. Even markedly hyponatremic patients may show no signs of water intoxication [31,39]. Neither a decrease in serum sodium concentration from 34 to 54 mmol/L without TURP syndrome nor a significant change in serum osmolality has been reported [39]. When 3% mannitol irrigation was used on one TURP patient, serum sodium concentration decreased from 133 to 99 mmol/L [56]. Osmolality was measured postoperatively at 290 mOsm/kg but was calculated at 239 mOsm/kg. This difference was attributed to the osmotic effect of mannitol not accounted for by the calculation. Although severe hyponatremia has been associated with hemolysis and renal failure [36], cardiovascular and electrocardiogram changes [11,35,50], respiratory compromise [11,57], seizure [35,58,59], coma [11,58], and death [11,34,35,57,58], other hyponatremic patients did well. Hyponatremia may not be the sole or even the primary cause of the neurological manifestations of TURP syndrome. Hypoosmolality The crucial physiological derangement of CNS function is not hyponatremia per se, but acute hypoosmolality. This is to be expected because the blood-brain barrier, with an effective pore size of 8 Angstrom, is essentially impermeable to sodium but freely permeable to water [60]. In rabbits, signs of water intoxication induced by administration of vasopressin and 2.5% glucose solution were reversed by administration of osmotically active agents such as urea and mannitol without correcting the serum sodium concentration [61]. One method of determining the independent neurophysiological effects of serum sodium concentration and osmolality has been to measure field potentials from prepared brain slices. Field potentials can be triggered or arise spontaneously and represent the voltage generated by the synchronous discharge of many neurons aligned in parallel. Hypotonic saline (Na+ of 123 mmol/L and a tonicity of 245 mOsm/kg) as a brain slice superfusate increased the amplitude of field potentials in rat hippocampal slices. Correcting the osmolality with mannitol, while maintaining the low sodium concentration, returned field responses to near control levels. The increased field response, therefore, results from a decreased osmolality, and not a decreased sodium concentration, which is consistent with predictions based on the Nernst equation [61]. The Nernst Equation predictsthat the decrease in extracellular sodium concentration that accompanies the hypoosmolality seen with TURP only minimally alters neuronal excitability. Replacing a Na+ value of 140 mmol/L with 100 mmol/L in the Nernst Equation increasesthe calculated transmembrane resting potential of -60 mV by 9 mV. Thus, theoretically, serum sodium concentration should not substantially contribute to neuronal excitability independent of serum osmolality, even when these changes are of the magnitude typically associated with severe TURP syndrome. The brain reacts to a sustained hypoosmotic stress within seconds to minutes, with intracellular decreases in Na+, K+, Cl-, and in so-called "idiogenic osmoles," which act to decrease intracellular osmolality and prevent swelling [61]. However, with acute osmotic change (within hours or even minutes), such compensatory mechanisms may not work fast enough [61]. Cerebral edema caused by acute hypoosmolality can increase intracranial pressure, which results in bradycardia and hypertension by the Cushing reflex [62]. Furthermore, cerebral edema is not caused by decreased serum colloid oncotic pressure, but by decreased osmolality [63]. Only a few studies correlate a patient's fate after TURP with both serum sodium concentration and osmolality [14,39,46]. In a series of 72 patients undergoing TURP, serum sodium concentration decreased by 10 to 54 mmol/L in 19 (26%), while osmolality changed in only two (3%) [39]. The two patients who had both hyponatremia (serum sodium concentration decreases of 27 and 30 mmol/L) and hypoosmolality (serum osmolality of 260 and 256 mmol/L) developed pulmonary edema and encephalopathy. The five patients in this series with the largest decreases in serum sodium concentration (by 34 to 54 mmol/L) had no changes in serum osmolality and no signs of TURP syndrome. Treatment of Hyponatremia and Hypoosmolality. Precautions can be taken to avoid severe hyponatremia and hypoosmolality. Diuretics have been implicated in the rapid onset of hyponatremia [64]. When used routinely or to treat hypervolemia after TURP, they may worsen hyponatremia and hypoosmolality and, thus, lead to TURP syndrome. Furosemide and bumetanide act within minutes on the ascending loop of Henle where they inhibit chloride uptake, which causes urinary sodium loss and promote salt-wasting after TURP [41,50]. Mannitol also causes sodium losses during the first 12 hours after TURP but does not lower serum level during the first three to five postoperative hours [65]. A patient's serum sodium concentration and osmolality may continue to decrease for some time after the procedure because much irrigant is slowly absorbed from the perivesicular and retroperitoneal spaces [26]. The TURP syndrome can start 4 to 24 hours later [12,14,27,54] with coma, blindness, grand mal seizures, and hemiplegia [14,54]. Problems may be forestalled by using loop and other salt-wasting diuretics with a concomitant infusion of saline-even in the presence of near normal serum sodium concentration-during the first 12 postoperative hours [41,65]. Pretreatment with hypertonic saline may decrease the degree of dilutional hyponatremia [66]. This approach may decrease the incidence of TURP syndrome caused by hypoosmolality, but likely will exacerbate the incidence and severity of the syndrome's hypervolemia manifestations. Because the serum sodium concentration need not reflect serum osmolality [35,39,56], serum sodium concentration should be reported together with osmolality when the irrigant solution contains osmotically active solutes (such as glycine, mannitol, or sorbitol). If osmolality is near normal, no intervention to correct sodium is recommended for asymptomatic patients, even in the face of reduced serum sodium concentration. The most feared complication of correcting hyponatremia is central pontine myelinolysis (CPM). Because demyelination can occur in extrapontine areas, the disease is also referred to as "osmotic demyelination syndrome" [67]. Although is most often seen in to in capacity it has been reported after rapid as as of serum sodium concentration in TURP patients When is slowly for symptomatic hyponatremia it has been associated with a morbidity and mortality than has rapid [64]. that a to rate is have to changes in osmolality. Several have that osmotic stress is greater when correcting with acute hyponatremia changes in blood osmolality within minutes the blood-brain and brain cell [61]. stress affects intracellular and concentrations is of the for the of from the cell and of the of in to hypoosmotic stress [61]. induced by hypoosmolality, it is not fast the of these can be reversed by the of the hypoosmolality. If the is the rapid of acute asymptomatic hyponatremia or hypoosmolality may be from of hyponatremia and hypoosmolality. The presence of symptoms has been described as the most important determining morbidity and mortality from hyponatremia The of hyponatremia and hypoosmolality may be symptomatic in the of symptoms rapid a because the rate is difficult to control osmolality should be and only until symptoms substantially then should be slowly (Na+ The and can glycine that gains intravascular The primary used by the and is which to the of two and The brain also contains a glycine system that glycine into a and that an increase of serum during TURP is the of glycine absorption because patients undergoing without glycine do not develop The of CNS function caused by may be a in perioperative the role of in TURP syndrome In the of the methods for the increase of plasma concentration when glycine irrigants are used which in the by of and to The time to may be as as 12 which preoperative fast time administration of markedly the increase in blood concentration in patients of with or at the of glycine administration increases in blood concentration and its to normal between 4 infused three minutes and infused minutes have been recommended No was with either of these The of is approximately per of a 10% solution with a calculated osmolality of mOsm/kg water is a in the and and may have a significant role in role in and is by or glycine encephalopathy. This disease is a by a in the glycine seizures, and death within the first few of patients have a plasma glycine level up to 10 greater than that of normal normal may lead to and seizure an is markedly by glycine and, along with its role as an may in the brain through an of the A large concentration of glycine may be in plasma but can be in the brain Signs of glycine nausea, and at an infusion rate of in a represents an intravascular absorption of 1.5% glycine solution at the rate of 54 glycine after TURP has been reported at a level greater than This concentration is greater than that in from glycine and that in in TURP syndrome vary in severity from to Several have on the of patients to be an complication patients with or and and loss of or hyponatremia and cerebral edema from may contribute to these visual Patients with blindness, on the other all visual and the but the responses to and Although it is difficult to the effects of serum sodium concentration from of other sodium to play only a role in the visual is now as the most likely cause of visual during the TURP syndrome A range of serum glycine have been in patients with visual have to of a serum glycine concentration for symptomatic visual and is a in the is found in the and of the and causes of The of potentials of the and visual potentials to glycine in the of large osmolality changes has been glycine to the physiological independent of cerebral edema caused by hypoosmolality. may also effects on the A in found of glycine in hours after either or administration of large of 1.5% glycine No was found after of retroperitoneal water or This did not the from the from into and has also been as a glycine cause renal failure in patients In the of glycine may be with TURP and seizure through its positive on the as it is in glycine after TURP associated with hyponatremia and hypoosmolality are likely to be to and in such may a or glycine are a negative control on the A serum magnesium level by dilution may increase to may be after TURP in patients who have been with a loop a of magnesium for in patients in whom a glycine irrigant was used during TURP if measured osmolality is near to normal within 24 hours as glycine normal This is because the of glycine is approximately minutes that is expected to may be the best TURP Syndrome: Other are to act at the and may some compromise of through the of the increases the of visual potentials and decreases amplitude in both and can contribute to and When these are used effects must be considered in the diagnosis of the TURP syndrome. of the to the TURP syndrome has in recent changes in intravascular and function the TURP syndrome. The and of TURP syndrome is because of solute and volume can occur and may and (Figure 1). Although serum sodium concentration during TURP is and is effective for intravascular there may be a from serum osmolality as well. Hypoosmolality to be the to neurological and hypovolemic the of management for and cardiovascular complications of TURP syndrome. Several in a management for hypoosmolality, encephalopathy, and after TURP. is also likely that these and can be to a syndrome in undergoing endometrial ablation with saline, glycine, or solutions When irrigation is the to which may occur with absorbed of or more Hypoosmolality is not a has a calculated osmolality of mOsm/kg. is from the incidence of TURP syndrome the 40 that has been in its and Despite this many of and acute hyponatremia and osmolality The of the associated with TURP syndrome a of The of hyponatremia and hypoosmolality and to avoid when correcting are to be The of for the and management of prostatic may minimize of TURP syndrome in the The for in the of this
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Dietrich Gravenstein (1997) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: