Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Background Primary health care (PHC) policy is strongly shaped by multiple valued policy objectives, such as reducing access barriers, or improving the sustainability of PHC services. Within policy studies research, the role of value agreement and disagreement, and its consequences for policy, are conceptualised in diverse ways. In the context of PHC policy in Aotearoa|New Zealand, we analyse whether agreement or disagreement regarding PHC policy values matters, and if so, how. Methods To assess value agreement and disagreement, 55 key informants in senior PHC roles were asked to select which valued policy objectives had witnessed most progress in the 2010s, and which were most important going forward. We analysed the distribution of responses, levels of agreement and disagreement, and interviewee reasoning for these judgements. Results Judgements of progress towards quality improvement and multi-professional care were generally positive, and reasons for progress were agreed. Conversely, despite widespread agreement regarding importance, reduction of inequities between Indigenous and non-Indigenous populations was judged overwhelmingly as the area of least progress. However, there was little common understanding of why progress was lacking. Where respondents disagreed about progress towards valued objectives, this was due to differing local experiences, differing interpretations of valued policy objectives, or differing horizons of progress. Conclusions The PHC policy subsystem in Aotearoa | New Zealand was not characterised by value conflict. However, agreement about the importance of valued objectives is only weakly linked to progress towards them. Such agreement has little consequence in a policy environment strongly shaped by material interests and institutional legacies.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Tenbensel et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: