Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Is recruitment related to spawner abundance? was addressed by Myers and Barrowman (1996) using the largest data set ever compiled in fisheries (364 time-series). We posed three questions: (i) does the highest recruitment occur when spawner abundance is high? (ii) does the lowest recruitment occur when spawner abundance is low? and (iii) is the mean recruitment higher if spawner abundance is above the median rather than below? We found that when there is a sufficient range in spawner abundance the answer to all three questions is almost always yes. An important aspect of the analysis, and a point completely ignored by Gilbert (1997), is that not all spawner recruit time-series have the same information content. This point is essential in any meta-analysis and is one of several reasons why I cannot accept Gilberts analysis. Gilbert (1997) claims, using an earlier version of my data compilation and a method that is totally untested, that the conclusions of Myers and Barrowman (1996) are wrong. He implies that eggs are not in fact required to produce baby fish, and that there is absolutely no need to conserve spawners to ensure future recruits. This is Gilberts new paradigm; however, it is the most commonly used paradigm in what sometimes passes for fisheries management. The failure to recognize the need to conserve spawning biomass is a principal reason for the disasterous collapse of the formerly great cod fisheries in Eastern Canada (Hutchings and Myers 1994; Myers et al. 1996, 1997). These fisheries were managed using Gilberts so-called new paradigm, i.e., the assumption that recruitment was independent of spawner abundance. Those wishing to follow Gilberts advice have many precedents of failure to warn them of their folly. However, I believe that his advice is very popular because it gives an excuse to overexploit now with no concern for future recruitment (again there is hardly anything new about this idea; Huxley 1884). If Gilbert is correct, there should be lots of new recruits in these six cod populations that collapsed in Eastern Canada in spite of the fact of very low spawner abundance. Unfortunately, this is not the case.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
R. A. Myers (1997) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: