Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Production of early maturing rather than traditionally maturing soybean [ Glycine max (L.) Merr.] varieties can benefit producers through crop diversification that spreads economic risk and through earlier harvest that allows timely fail planting of winter cereals. However, planting system can influence the success of early maturing soybean production. This study was conducted to determine the effect of ANH (April, narrow 7‐in. rows, high population—336 000 seeds/acre) and JWL (June, wide 30‐in. rows, low population—139 000 seeds/acre) planting systems on yield, plant and lowest pod heights, and visual grain quality of early maturing (Maturity Groups [MGs] 00, 0, and I) and traditionally! maturing (MGs III, IV, and V) soybean varieties. In 1987, early maturing soybean varieties yielded more than 30 bu/acre when planted in the ANH system, but yields of these varieties were approximately 50% lower in the JWL system. ‘Hodgson 78’ (MG I) yielded 41 bu/acre in the ANH system in 1987; this yield was higher than yields of all other varieties except ‘Bay’ (MG V) planted in the JWL system. From 1988 through 1990 in either system, Hodgson 78 yielded 20 to 30 bu/acre, which was equal to or greater than the yields of all other varieties except ‘Zane’ planted in the ANH system in 1990. Plant heights of early maturing varieties were generally shorter than those of the determinate varieties, ‘Crawford’ (MG IV) and Bay (MG V). Lowest pod height of early maturing soybean varieties ranged from 1 to 4 in. during all years, whereas later maturing varieties podded as high as 8 in. from ground level. Quality of grain varied by year, but in 1987, grain quality of the early maturing varieties was improved by the ANH planting system. These results show that early maturing soybean varieties from MG I offer a viable alternative to traditional MGs; however, additional research is needed to refine these new management systems. Research Question Production of early maturing soybean varieties can benefit producers through crop diversification and through early harvest that allows for timely fall planting of winter cereals. However, planting system decisions can influence the success of early maturing soybeans. This study was conducted to (i) compare yield, plant and lowest pod heights, and visual grain quality of early maturing soybean varieties from maturity groups (MGs) 00, 0, and I with traditionally adapted MGs 111, IV, and V varieties; and (ii) determine whether planting systems influence the response of early maturing and full‐season soybean varieties. Literature Summary Traditional MG III to V varieties for the mid‐latitude section of the eastern U.S. Great Plains often are planted in June, partially to delay reproductive growth beyond the hot and dry weather of late July and early August. Earlier plantings, however, may move much of the seed development period for early maturing soybeans (MG 00, 0, and 1) varieties ahead of this hot, dry period. April plantings have produced satisfactory yields in early maturing (MG III and IV) systems in southern states. Other research also has suggested that early MG, indeterminate varieties can benefit from higher populations. Narrow row spacings have been shown to increase yields in some cases; however, early maturing soybean varieties also can benefit from narrow rows, which decrease the competition from weeds that would not have senesced by soybean harvest in late August or early September. Study Description One representative variety from each of three early soybean maturity groups (MG 00, 0, and 1) and three traditional soybean maturity groups (MGs III, IV, and V) was evaluated in two planting systems from 1987 through 1990 on a Parsons silt loam soil in southeastern Kansas. The two planting systems were (i) ANH (April, narrow 7‐in. rows, high population—336 000 seedslacre) and (ii) JWL (June, wide 30‐in. rows, low population—139 000 seeddacre). The six varieties were McCall (00), Dawson (0), Hodgson 78 (I), Zane (III), Crawford (IV), and Bay (V). Applied Questions How do yields of early maturing soybean varieties from MG 00, 0, or I compare to those of traditionally adapted MGs III, IV, or V soybean varieties grown in mid‐latitude areas of the USA? Although yields varied with year, Hodgson 78 (MG I) frequently yielded as much or more than later soybean varieties. Averaged over 4 yr, Hodgson 78 yielded 26.1 bu/acre, which was 4.5 to 6.4 bu/acre more than either Crawford (MG IV) or Bay (MG V) and nearly equal to the 26.6 bu/acre yield of Zane (MG III). Does planting the early maturing soybean varieties in April in 7‐in. rows at 336 000 seeddacre result in more yield than planting in June in 30‐in. rows at 139 000 seedslacre? Planting early maturing varieties in the ANH system avoided placing much of the reproductive growth stages in the often hot and dry conditions of late July and early August. This may have contributed to greater yields of Hodgson 78 (MG I) in the ANH planting system in 2 of 4 yr. Weather patterns, however, were variable enough that early maturing soybean varieties did not always yield more in the ANH planting system. How do plant and pod heights and visual grain quality of early maturing soybean varieties compare with those of full‐season varieties? Early maturing soybean varieties are often shorter than full‐season varieties, especially when planted in the ANH system and in comparison with the MGs IV and V varieties. Height to lowest pod on early maturing soybean varieties can be low enough to cause combine losses regardless of planting system. Visual ratings of grain quality varied and did not indicate conclusively that early maturing soybean produce grain of lower quality than traditionally adapted varieties.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Sweeney et al. (1995) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: