This is the authors' abstract. We don't add key points for this paper.
There is robust evidence that air pollutants can exacerbate response to allergens to which persons already sensitized 1. However, it remains unclear whether exposure to ambient air pollutants can promote primary development of atopy. Studies supporting a role for pollutant exposure in developing atopy include studies from New York, Cincinnati and California. In New York, exposure to PAHs in the perinatal period in conjunction with second-hand tobacco smoke or cockroach allergen has been linked to asthma symptoms and cockroach sensitization 2. Residential location near heavily trafficked intersections was also associated with increased IgE levels in children 3. In Cincinnati, Ryan et al. 4 reported that exposure to traffic-related particles was associated with persistent wheeze by 36 months of age. Tobacco smoke exposure, especially perinatal smoke exposure, has also been shown to be a risk factor for development of asthma 5, 6. Though the data are mixed regarding the relationship between pollutant exposure and allergen sensitization, the case can be made that early life exposure to traffic-related air particulates, tobacco smoke and other pollutants enhance risk for allergen sensitization 2, 7-9. Less clear are the potential mechanisms by which pollutants may impact development of atopy. A number of potential mechanisms may exist. We have shown that endotoxin and ozone can enhance expression of antigen presentation markers on airway macrophages and monocytes 10-12. Such observations suggest that cells with antigen-presenting function may be recruited to the airway with acute inflammation promoting development of an new immune response. However, the role this process plays in development of new allergic disease remains to be seen. Exposure to diesel exhaust particles (DEPs) has been shown to promote IgE responses to neoantigens. In both animal and human challenge studies, exposure to DEPs has been shown to activate IL-4 production, promote production of IgE and skew immune response to a neoantigen (keyhole limpet haemocyanin) to a mixed KLH IgE and IgG response instead of an exclusive KLH IgG response (observed when KLH is given without DEP co-challenge) 13-17. Oxidative stress induced by diesel exhaust particles has been linked to the ability of these agents to induce a primary IgE response to subsequently encountered allergen which is inhibited by thiol antioxidants 18 and induction of phase II antioxidant enzymes by consumption of sulforaphane-rich preparations 19. Consistent with an oxidative stress hypothesis, genetic variants of the antioxidant genes GSTM1, GSST1 and NQO1 that are linked with decreased expression of these antioxidant proteins have been associated with pollutant-induced exacerbation of disease in both epidemiological and human challenge studies 20, 21. Nasal challenge with diesel exhaust particles and tobacco smoke has been shown to enhance TH2 responses (IgE, histamine) to subsequent allergen challenge 22, 23. In a New York urban population, risk of sensitization to cockroach allergen is augmented by exposure to PAHs in persons with the GSTM1 null genotype 2. Kabesh and colleagues also reported increased occurrence of asthma and wheeze in GSTM1 null children subjected to exposure to second-hand tobacco smoke 24. Consistent with this observation, Rogers et al. 25 reported that that the GSTM1-null genetic variant is associated with occurrence of asthma, younger age of onset of asthma and greater airflow obstruction in children who had intrauterine exposure to tobacco smoke. Likewise, Gillliland et al. 26 reported that children with the GSTM1 null genotype born to mothers who smoked during pregnancy had a greatly enhanced risk of wheeze and emergency room treatment for asthma than children born to non-smoking mothers or children who were GSTM1 sufficient. However, it is not clear if single gene variants alone explain the increased risk for development or exacerbation of allergic diseases associated by pollutant exposure. Other processes, including epigenetic regulation of atopy by exogenous factors, may play a key role in mediating environmental risks for atopy 27. Perhaps the most compelling observation that an environmental agent could induce epigenetic changes that result in atopy was presented by Hollingsworth et al. 28. This team reported that a methyl-rich diet enhanced methylation of various gene loci and increased development of atopy. In humans, folic acid is a commonly used nutritional supplement to prevent neural tube defects. Some, but not all, investigators who have examined the effect of prenatal folic acid supplementation on development of atopy have reported a link between that folic acid supplementation and increased atopy 29-32. While the human epidemiological data are mixed, the mechanistic animal data do highlight the potential for exogenous agents to exert effects on atopy development via epigenetic modulation. Other environmental contaminants have been shown to exert changes in DNA methylation, histone acetylation or microRNA expression. Fry et al. have reported that contamination of water with arsenic and other metals is associated with DNA methylation 33 and that acute challenge with ozone causes an increase in microRNA 34. Exposure to ambient particulate air pollutants have been shown to increase both methylation and microRNA expression in human populations 35, 36. Several studies of smokers suggest that epigenetic changes are associated with COPD 37. In utero exposure to tobacco, smoke has been linked to increased expression of mi-223 in both maternal monocytes and infant cord blood monocytes associated with lower T regulatory cell numbers 38. Second-hand tobacco smoke exposure has been reported to cause hypermethylation of CpG motifs with associated decrease in γ-interferon production in exposed children 39. Recently in Clinical and Experimental Allergy, Hew and colleagues extended the observations of this research group showing the effect of tobacco smoke on T regulatory cell biology 39 to show that increased exposure to ambient air polyaromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) is associated with modified T regulatory cell function in cells recovered from exposed children with allergic asthma and allergic rhinitis 40. The cellular effects associated with PAH exposure were decreased production of IL-10 and increased production of gamma interferon, which was linked to increased methylation of FOX P3, a key regulator of atopy. While it has been previously reported that oxidative stress induced by PAHs exerts effects on immune cells, this study shows that PAHs are specifically associated with epigenetic changes that modify expression of genes in T regulatory cells, allowing TH2 responses to be expressed. This study extends the body of work showing that environmental pollutants impact human biology, specifically showing that pollutants impact DNA methylation of genes central to development of atopy. Such epigenetic changes are a very plausible explanation for the effect of environmental agents on molecular modification of atopy, and perhaps more plausible than environmentally induced changes in DNA sequence, or the impact of a relatively small number of single nucleotide polymorphisms on gene–environment interactions relevant to atopy. While it is likely that multiple factors such as exposure pattern and duration, exposure during specific windows of susceptibility and non-inheritance of biological responses and genetic risk factors simultaneously impact development of atopy, epigenetic modulation of gene/environment interactions will prove to be a central mechanism enhancing environmental modulation of atopy. The authors declare no conflict of interest.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
David B. Peden (2014) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: