This is the authors' abstract. We don't add key points for this paper.
Methamphetamine use is a current focus point round the world, with the media labelling it as an epidemic or crisis that will have a lasting negative impact on our communities (Chalmers, Lancaster, & Hughes, 2016). In recent years however, the media has been challenged in regard to what has been termed crisis framing, or where the media seeks to sensationalize an issue such as the potential impact and use of methamphetamines (Usher, Clough, Woods, & Robertson, 2015). The media has been criticized for their sensationalism of methamphetamine use for a number of reasons including the sources they use to make their claims, including over-reliance on law enforcement officials that has the potential to reduce substance use to a narrow range of topics and interpretive frameworks rather than adopting a solution-focused approach (Taylor, 2008). Regardless of the sources they use, the media is a pervasive persuader of public opinion and attitudes and frequent referencing of a particular drug alongside harmful acts can cause a reader to associate the two (Roach, 2012). Crisis framing and the use of sensationalized headlines when reporting on methamphetamine use can have an impact on stigma, discrimination, and negative attitudes (Usher et al., 2015). Lancaster et al. (2011) reports the media as having four functions: to impact public opinion (media effect), agenda setting (select issues that believe are important while silencing others), framing the issue (impacts on what is said about the issues, so media can report about an epidemic of drug use crisis framing), and influencing attitudes, policy, and politic views. Media coverage can have a significant advantage to health issues, by highlighting areas of concern, drawing attention to issues that require policy change and government funding, and increasing public awareness. However, a disadvantage of media attention is that it can shape public opinion, increase public concern, and impact the development of stigma and negative attitudes (Hughes, Lancaster, & Spicer, 2011; Lancaster, Hughes, Spicer, Matthew-Simmons, & Dillon, 2011). In fact, the media plays an important role in highlighting deviance (Denham, 2010) and encouraging audiences to develop particular responses and cognitive frames through which to attribute blame (Gideonse, 2016). Previous research on the media's depiction of substance use confirms that media often presents their own agenda on law enforcement, and crime and punishment using alarmist or fear/crisis framing, and negative value judgements to sway public attitudes towards substance use and government opinions to affect policy change (Hughes et al., 2011). Research conducted by Fan (1996) reported substance use crisis framing presented in the media increased public concern by 55% in the USA in 1994. Similarly, Hughes et al. (2011) reviewed six years of media reports in six major Australian newspapers and found that amphetamines were more likely to be reported as crisis issues, reported in a negative light (bad moral evaluation), and reported as very costly to society. These media events are sometimes referred to as methamphetamine panics where media attention to the drug results in panic across the community, evidenced by the National Drug Strategy Household Survey which reported methamphetamine had overtaken alcohol as the substance of most concern, with rates reportedly doubling from 16% in 2013 to 40% in 2016 (Australian Institute of Health and Welfare, 2017). This is significant considering alcohol is linked to higher mortality rates and larger numbers of emergency department presentations (Australian Institute of Health and Welfare, 2020). What we know is panic results in stigma and negative attitudes towards methamphetamine users who then begin to perceive themselves as a deviant group (Gideonse, 2016). Stigma is defined as something that marks an individual as a disgrace (Shortis, 2011). Goffman takes this definition further and discusses stigma as something that detracts from an individual's value as a human being or their belief of being human; thus, they feel tainted (Goffman, 1963, p. 3 & 5). Extreme stigma is often associated with substance use, with individuals experiencing self-stigma (shame, fear, and low self-esteem) as a result of societal views of their substance use (Salamat, Hegarty, & Patton, 2019). Stigma often creates a negative attitude towards conditions, and previous research on stigma and health professionals' attitudes has shown that health professionals often develop negative attitudes towards substance users and experience dissatisfaction working with substance using consumers (van Boekel, Brouwers, van Weeghel, & Garretsen, 2013; Chalmers et al., 2016; Salamat et al., 2019; Takano, Kawakami, Miyamoto, & Matsumoto, 2015). For example, stigma has played a role in shaping health professionals' deservingness judgements (Skinner, Feather, Freeman, & Roche, 2007), that is, deservingness and entitlement to health care. All patients are entitled to and deserve the same level of care, which is the belief most healthcare systems are built upon. However, when health professionals' perceptions of deservingness are negative, these attitudes are often perceived by the individual, impacting therapeutic relationships and communication with health professionals. It also impacts how an individual interacts with medical treatment and services (van Boekel et al., 2013). The impact of this stigma can result in individuals feeling fear and shame about substance use resulting in failure to disclose the use, failure to seek or delay in seeking medical treatment, and mistrust towards healthcare professionals (Kelly & Westerhoff 2010; Salamat et al., 2019). This has a direct impact on the individual's willingness to seek assistance in managing their substance use. Current research and academic debate is attempting to challenge what the media is labelling as a methamphetamine epidemic in order to alleviate the stigmatization associated with use of the drug. Progress is however slow, and the pervasive role of the media is hard to overcome. Mental health nurses, drug and alcohol workers, and other health professionals who work alongside substance users must remain aware of the potential for stigmatizing attitudes portrayed by the media to impact their beliefs of deservingness and the quality of care they provide to substance users. It is also important to remain cognizant that the media's power to depict substance users negatively may result in unintended consequences that actually hinder recovery for individuals.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Jones et al. (2020) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: