Key result
The TMC-PCR assay detected enterovirus in 63.29% of clinical specimens from suspected viral meningitis cases, compared to 37.97% detected by the TTN-PCR assay.
Why the study?
Does the TMC-PCR assay improve the detection rate of enterovirus compared to the TTN-PCR assay in clinical specimens from patients with suspected viral meningitis?
Observational (n=158)
Does the TMC-PCR assay improve the detection rate of enterovirus compared to the TTN-PCR assay in clinical specimens from patients with suspected viral meningitis?
The TMC-PCR assay demonstrates higher sensitivity for detecting enterovirus in clinical specimens compared to a standard TaqMan RT-PCR assay, making it suitable for routine diagnostic screening of viral meningitis.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
May support TMC-PCR for enterovirus detection in suspected meningitis; leaves open routine adoption pending outcome validation.
BACKGROUND: Enterovirus (EV) infections are commonly associated with encephalitis and meningitis. Detection of enteroviral RNA in clinical specimens has been demonstrated to improve the management of patients, by ruling out other causes of disease. METHOD: To develop a sensitive and reliable assay for routine laboratory diagnosis, we developed a real-time one step reverse transcription polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR) assay with minor groove binder probes and primers modified with complementary locked primer technology (TMC-PCR). We checked the sensitivity of the developed assay by comparing it to a previously published TaqMan probe real-time one-step RT-PCR (TTN-PCR) procedure using enteroviral isolates, Enterovirus Proficiency panels from Quality Control on Molecular Diagnostics (QCMD-2007), and clinical specimens from patients with suspected EV infections. RESULTS: One hundred clinical specimens from 158 suspected viral meningitis cases were determined to be positive by the TMC-PCR assay (63.29%), whereas only 60 were found to be positive by the TTN-PCR assay (37.97%). The positive and negative agreements between the TMC-PCR and TTN-PCR assays were 100% and 59.2%, respectively. CONCLUSION: This data suggest that the TMC-PCR assay may be suitable for routine diagnostic screening from patient suspected EV infection.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Hong et al. (2011) conducted an observational in Suspected viral meningitis (n=158). TMC-PCR assay vs. TTN-PCR assay was evaluated on Positive detection rate of enterovirus. The TMC-PCR assay detected enterovirus in 63.29% of clinical specimens from suspected viral meningitis cases, compared to 37.97% detected by the TTN-PCR assay.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: