Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The paper by Eichengreen and Tong (2006) is successful in identifying the effects of China on its neighboring countries’ patterns of trade, foreign direct investment (FDI) and economic growth. The gravity equation model is skillfully utilized to examine how trade and FDI in China affects trade and FDI in other countries, and the use of the gravity model allows the authors to rely on the instrument variable technique to estimate these effects. Two crucial features of this paper are that the authors disaggregate trade patterns into several sectors such as capital goods, consumer goods, intermediate goods and raw materials, and disaggregate FDI into vertical FDI and horizontal FDI. Differences in the responses among these sectors and the two types of FDI imply the presence of interactive supply chain networks in this region. There are many interesting insights that can be gained from the results of this paper. I think the paper a good one, but there are some minor points on which I must comment. It is important to note that the authors only identify the presence of China factors in other countries’ trade and investment patterns, and did not analyze the nature of Chinese trade and investment themselves. One can run similar regressions with the China variables replaced by similar variables for other countries such as the USA or Japan. One may, for example, ask whether expanding investment flows into the USA or expanding US imports affected the trade and investment patterns of other countries. I know that this kind of exercise is very different from the one conducted in this paper, as China is special. The special features of China should be analyzed more in detail. Perhaps one may look more directly into the pattern of China's trade and investment rather than just examining only the effect on other countries’ trade. Table 1 exhibits some of the unique features of China's trade and investment in the period 1990–2002. One may find that the structure of China's trade and investment changed dynamically in this period, and these changes must include not only the quantitative elements captured by the paper, but also various kinds of qualitative elements that also changed the trade and investment in neighboring countries. For example, the shares of foreign owned companies in China's trade increased rapidly both on the export and import sides. This reflects the fact that China's trade has had a dual structure; a very open export-processing regime and a very closed ordinary trade regime. The big gap between the statutory import tariff rate (average tariff rates) and the tariff burden rate (the ratio of tariff revenue to total imports) implies the existence of large amount of imports being used for export processing. China's trade data include these two types of dual trade structures, and one can find a gradual shift from export processing to ordinary trade since the latter half of the 1990s. I speculate that this changing nature of China's trade should affect the supply chain networks in this region, for example, much of the consumer electronics trade involving China was for export processing, while those of motor vehicles were for ordinary trade. So, it is easy to see why consumer electronics had much more intensive cross-border supply chain networks including China than motor vehicles. There is only one foreign-owned automobile producer in China, Honda, which exports automobiles abroad, while there are many foreign owned electronics producers in China exporting their products. In relation to FDI, the authors are also successful in identifying interesting influences on other countries’ FDI. The authors explain the identified interactive effects by the presence of supply chain networks. Although this is an important finding, one can imagine that there are some other critical elements in FDI in this region that may show some interactive patterns. The Asian currency crisis in the later half of the 1990s was an important shock affecting the pattern of FDI in this region. The so called “contagion effect” is a typical neighborhood effect, which may be captured by the distance factor in a gravity equation model, but the mechanism behind it is certainly quite different from the ordinary distance effect of gravity trade models. If one can identify some interactive effects on FDI through this kind of international transmission of macro-shocks, it should be separated from the supply chain network effects as suggested in this paper. However, to separate other interactive effects from supply chain channels is not easy in this simple gravity model. As a final remark, I want to emphasize again that the kind of analysis conducted in this paper is very useful to examine the interactive effects of supply chain networks, and the paper was successful in skillfully analyzing these complicated issues.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Motoshige Itoh (2006) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: