Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Kohei Saito’s Capital in the Anthropocene (2020) was an unexpected hit in Japan, selling over half a million copies. The work’s English translation (retitled Slow Down: The Degrowth Manifesto) was published in early 2024. Despite its name closely resembling the original Japanese title of Saito’s best-known work, Marx in the Anthropocene: Towards the Idea of Degrowth Communism is, in Saito’s words, “a more rigorous and academic version of the Japanese book” that “builds on wholly new arguments with a more careful reading of materials” (x). For those interested in the academic debates surrounding the purported incompatibility of Marxism and environmentalism (two sides Saito calls “Red and Green,” respectively), Marx in the Anthropocene is a good entry point into Saito’s overall project. It combines the intellectual rigor of his Karl Marx’s Ecosocialism: Capital, Nature, and the Unfinished Critique of Political Ecology (2017) and the more public-facing advocacy for degrowth communism at the heart of Slow Down, albeit in unequal doses. The side that wants to recuperate Marx as an environmentalist is more prevalent than the side that advocates for real world change.While Saito’s intention is to bridge the gap between Red and Green, he has himself proven to be a polarizing thinker in both academic and activist circles. Saito is not radical enough for some, and his reading of Marx is too unorthodox for others. For readers on the Green side of things (like myself), he offers a welcomed counterargument to persistent claims in the environmental humanities of Marx’s anthropocentrism (e.g., see Timothy Morton’s Dark Ecology). Readers from the Red side, however, may find Saito’s characterization of thinkers like Jason W. Moore inaccurate. Saito critiques contemporary eco-Marxists like Moore, Noel Castree, and Neil Smith for clinging to an “ontological monism” that has led to a misunderstanding of Marx’s theory of the metabolic rift and to a misguided faith that technological innovation can solve the climate crisis. Saito rejects such Promethean thinking, arguing instead (in dualist fashion) that degrowth is the best hope for a postcapital world without “the ceaseless exploitation of humanity and the robbery of nature” (216).Saito claims that, late in life, Marx himself advocated for degrowth communism. To prove this, he provocatively decenters the Marxist canon, save for when he wishes to demonstrate that others have misinterpreted works like Capital. Instead, Saito bases his arguments largely on late period ephemera. Marx undertook research in the natural and social sciences after he wrote much of his canonical work, and Saito claims this occasioned a “theoretical breakthrough” that can only be glimpsed in his late notebooks and letters (6). Saito believes that to read Marx differently, one must read different Marx, i.e., late texts that present the final form of Marxism in Saito’s estimation.For Saito, conventional Marxism is not compatible with a transition to a sustainable postcapitalist society: “(If) there is a slight hope of a revival of Marxism in this historical conjuncture, its essential precondition is the radical reformulation of its infamous grand scheme of ‘historical materialism’” (2). Saito has far more conviction than a “slight hope” that Marx has relevance in the Anthropocene, but there is a patient and exacting quality to the unfolding of his argument that keeps the book from feeling overly polemical, at least in its call to action. Saito may begin the book by declaring that the “world is on fire,” but more than half of the work traces a genealogy of thinkers who Saito believes have not properly understood the ecological relevance of Marxism (1). Readers looking for activism may be left with the question Andrew Ahern poses in the Los Angeles Review of Books: “Why should we even care if Marx was a precocious degrowther? The philosophers may interpret Marx, but the point is to change the world.” Indeed, Marx in the Anthropocene seems more concerned with surveying how “philosophers interpret Marx” than providing a clear blueprint for the transition to degrowth.The first section of the book demonstrates this. Chapter 1, “Marx’s Theory of Metabolism in the Age of Global Ecological Crisis,” maps the historical suppression and rediscovery of Marx’s ecology over the past two decades. Central here is the metabolic rift, a term Saito admits only appears sporadically in Marx’s corpus. Nevertheless, Saito stresses that the concept is “actually profound and solid” (23). Saito’s methodology can veer toward speculation throughout, such as when he argues that “there are good reasons to assume that he would have elaborated on the concept of the metabolic rift in more detail if Marx were able to finish Capital” (Ibid). Such conjecture may appear unorthodox, but this is precisely the point. Saito resists orthodoxy in order to envision a new Marxist canon and reception, one based on the Marx-Engels-Gesamtausgabe (MEGA) project that has made available previously unpublished writings. Through the MEGA, Saito convincingly claims (to this Green reader, at least) that Marx was not, as critics have repeatedly argued, Promethean or Eurocentric—at least not at the end of his life.Saito uses the MEGA, in Chapter 2, to distinguish between Marx and Engels’ respective critiques of capitalism as related to ecology. “The Intellectual Relationship Between Marx and Engels Revisited from an Ecological Perspective” details how the development of Western Marxism “expelled Engels and his mechanistic dialectic of nature from their analysis, but at the same time . . . completely excluded the sphere of nature and natural science from Marx’s social philosophy” (48). The chapter demonstrates Saito’s fundamental disagreement with Western Marxists, insofar as Lukács “regarded natural science as Engels’ area of expertise” and Adorno, in turn, claimed that Marx’s “concept of nature” “remains underdeveloped” (44). In Saito’s mind, the “broad category” of “heterogenous” thinkers that fall under the umbrella of Western Marxism all “attempted to save Marx’s social philosophy by criticizing Engels’ dialectics of nature and strictly limiting dialectics to society” (47). Chapter 3, “Lukács’s Theory of Metabolism as the Foundation of Ecosocialist Realism” then targets the “ontological monists,” who, in Saito’s reckoning, collapse distinctions between subject and object, and society and nature. Through his reading of Lukács, Saito arrives at a defense of Marx’s own “methodological dualism,” with the belief that it, rather than the monism of approaches like Latour’s Actor-Network-Theory, “provides a more powerful tool not only to analyse the ecological crisis but also to envision a post-capitalist future beyond the crisis of the Anthropocene” (96).Chapter 4, “Monism and the Non-Identity of Nature,” begins the second part of the book and develops Saito’s critique of monism by focusing on Neil Smith’s theory of the “production of nature” and Moore’s “world-ecology,” both of which Saito claims appear “quite radical” but ultimately present a “series of theoretical difficulties” (103). Rejecting both, Saito instead holds fast to Marx’s methodological dualism, stressing that “Methodological or analytical dualism is indispensable in order to critically investigate the capitalist way of organizing production and constituting various unjust hierarchies” (124). Chapter 5, “The Revival of Utopian Socialism and the Productive Forces of Capital,” then identifies a strain in contemporary Marxism that imagines automation and technologies such as AI can be liberatory. While Saito welcomes a certain degree of postcapitalist utopian thinking, he does not share in the belief that “the productive forces of capital” can ever bring us to a postcapital, “clear bright future” (150). Such claims are antithetical to degrowth communism, as “technology suppresses and eliminates the possibilities of imagining a completely different lifestyle and a safe and just society in the face of economic and ecological crisis” (162).The book’s third section, “Toward Degrowth Communism,” marks a shift away from intellectual debates. The work Saito has spent over the past 160 odd pages to deconstruct conventional understandings of Marx allows him, in this section, to build something new. Here, perhaps more than anywhere else in the book, Saito relies on speculation (particularly in Chapter 6, “Marx as a Degrowth Communist”), but it is a strength of his scholarship that these efforts feel revelatory. As Saito puts forward his vision of degrowth communism, the book takes on a hopeful tone that stands in contrast to much writing on the Anthropocene. By Chapter 7, “The Abundance of Wealth in Degrowth Communism,” readers may see promising resonances between Saito’s notion of “abundance” and the one outlined in Candice Fujikane’s Mapping Abundance for a Planetary Future (Durham: Duke University Press, 2021). Saito’s call for cooperation, care work, and de-enclosing and expanding the commons all portray degrowth as an attractive and potentially viable means of transition to a more just and sustainable society. Ultimately, Marx in the Anthropocene is a valuable (if uneven) work that will be of interest to both sides of the Green and Red divide. While it may not reconcile their respective differences, it can hopefully bring both sides together in productive conversation.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Jon L. Pitt (2025) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: