Why the study?
Do different classes of antihypertensive agents improve blood pressure lowering in adult patients with salt-sensitive hypertension?
Do different classes of antihypertensive agents improve blood pressure lowering in adult patients with salt-sensitive hypertension?
Customized antihypertensive therapy, such as calcium antagonist-diuretic combinations, may be beneficial for salt-sensitive hypertension, but high-quality standardized studies are still needed.
The salt-sensitivity of blood pressure (BP) refers to the interindividual difference in the BP response to a given change in salt intake. The majority of individuals have a decrease in BP with reduction in dietary salt intake, with a small proportion of subjects showing no response or even some increase in BP. In fact, the BP response to changes in salt intake behaves as a continuous variable with a simil-Gaussian distribution,1,2 not allowing to detect any distinct subpopulation.3 This notwithstanding, based on these responses, individuals are often defined either salt-sensitive or salt-resistant using particular maneuvers and “arbitrary” cut-offs.4 Noteworthy, salt- sensitivity of BP was associated with several cardio- metabolic risk factors, among which excess body weight, diabetes and metabolic syndrome,5,6 and even with a high rates of organ damage and cardiovascular events.7–9 Qi and collaborators,10 in an article recently published in this journal, reported the results of a network meta-analysis, which compared the efficacy of different classes of antihypertensive agents in adult patients with salt-sensitive hypertension and without concomitant diseases. The main findings indicated a greater BP effect of the calcium antagonist- diuretic (hydrochlorothiazide) combination, while the calcium antagonist-metformin association was most effective in obese patients. The results also showed that clonidine was more effective during low salt intake, although only one study explored the effect of this particular antihypertensive agent. A limitation of this study was given by the different methods used to evaluate the BP salt-sensitivity. Another limitation was the inclusion in the analysis of both randomized and nonrandomized controlled trials, the majority of which were based on the use of calcium antagonists. Finally, there was a large heterogeneity in the characteristics of the different studies with respect to length of follow-up, sample size, and different dosage and form of the antihypertensive agents under investigation. An interesting finding of the study was the apparent sodium-induced attenuation of BP lowering during high salt intake. This trend seems to be opposite to the positive relationship between salt intake and BP levels, and to the results of the beneficial effect of the reduction in salt intake on organ damage in patients with concomitant antihypertensive treatment.11,12 Indeed, this effect may be explained by a natriuretic effect of the treatment, not only of the diuretic, but also of the calcium antagonist13,14 and ACE-inhibitor15 administration. In particular, there were abnormal dihydropyridine binding sites on calcium channels13 and higher intracellular calcium levels in salt-sensitive hypertensive patients during high salt intake than low salt intake.14 On the other hand, other studies showed that the increased urinary sodium excretion after calcium antagonists administration was independent of salt-sensitivity of BP.16 Moreover, in a study on multiracial salt-sensitive subjects, the BP reduction was achieved both for an ACE-inhibitor and a calcium channel antagonist, and it was consistently greater on a low salt diet in all three races.17 Regarding the higher effect of the calcium antagonist and metformin association, this could be expected because of the clear evidence of the positive association between excess body weight and insulin resistance and its role on BP salt-sensitivity,18 and also for the favorable effect of metformin on insulin sensitivity and body weight.19 In line with the current era of therapy customization and in consideration of the high cardiovascular risk of the salt-sensitive individuals, this study highlights a primary topic. Of course, conceivably the first line of hypertension treatment in salt-sensitive individuals is to reduce dietary salt intake to less than 5 g per day, also in consideration that in most countries worldwide the habitual average sodium intake largely exceeds the recommended adequate intake determined on the basis of scientific evidence.20 However, since the mechanisms responsible for the salt-sensitive of BP are not completely established, there is no specific treatment forsalt-sensitive patients yet. Given these results, it would be hazardous to try to reach any definitive conclusion. High-quality investigations are needed regarding the effect of different classes and dosage of antihypertensive therapy, in terms of changes in BP, organ damage, and risk of cardiovascular events, in relation to salt-sensitivity. To this end, the adoption of appropriate and standardized tests for the assessment of BP salt-sensitivity is recommended when designing future studies. The study was not supported by external funding. The author declared no conflict of interest.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Lanfranco D’Elia (2018) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 5 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: