Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
In this text, I explore to what degree non-dualistic theoretical frameworks, particularly assemblage theory, might challenge traditional archaeological methodologies. By questioning dualistic paradigms that separate subject and object, I assess the epistemological implications of post-humanist, non-dualistic perspectives on understanding material culture. Specifically, typology, a cornerstone of medieval ceramic studies, is re-examined as both a methodological tool and an intellectual construct. I investigate how assemblage theory facilitates an understanding of ceramic objects as dynamic participants in evolving social and material assemblages, rather than as static cultural markers. By unpacking the foundations of non-dualistic approaches, I examine what a shift from rigid classifications to relational interpretations fundamentally implies. I propose that such a shift undoubtedly offers new understandings of the interplay of materiality, social agency, and the epistemological foundations of archaeology. But is this shift truly compatible with the analytical needs of down-to-earth researchers working with medieval pottery? The long-standing debates within post-humanist archaeology have emphasised the situated and negotiated nature of past-making; this discussion builds on that foundation by extending the inquiry to an epistemological level, asking what it truly means to construct past realities through non-dualistic frameworks by attempting to move beyond relational metaphors.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Lars Morten Fuglevik (2025) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: