Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Several recent papers have suggested that completeness of stratigraphic sections can be estimated by using the ratio of long-term sedimentation rates to short-term rates. We show that the median short-term sedimentation rates used in these papers are erroneous and are mostly an artifact arising from improper data manipulation. To demonstrate the artificial character of short-term median rates, we have generated a series of plots assuming a constant sedimentation rate with fixed variance and defined limits of measurement precision. These plots demonstrate that increasing variance in the time required to deposit sediments will result in spuriously high short-term median sedimentation rates. A new method for calculating median sedimentation rates, which eliminates the problem of spurious median rates, is then applied to make an improved estimate of expected completeness. Recalculated median values show that sedimentation rates for pelagic sediments are close to identical for both short-term and long-term time intervals. Applying this method to an expanded compilation of pelagic sedimentation rates confirms the near completeness of typical pelagic sequences. This undermines arguments for inherent temporal incompleteness as an explanation for the synchronous extinctions at the Cretaceous-Tertiary boundary. Finally, we suggest that median short-term sedimentation rates should not be used to assess completeness for individual sections. Problems with compaction, bioturbation, core smearing, uncertainties in radiometric age determinations, and the great variance inherent in sedimentation rates imply that median short-term sedimentation rates are suspect, however calculated. Sedimentation accumulation diagrams may find their greatest usefulness in estimating the completeness to be expected in a given depositional environment or in comparing completeness of one environment to another.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Anders et al. (1987) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: