Why the study?
Do indirect methods accurately estimate true arterial PCO2 in men at rest and during exercise?
Do indirect methods accurately estimate true arterial PCO2 in men at rest and during exercise?
While all indirect methods underestimate arterial PCO2 at rest, PACO2, PADCO2, and PJCO2 provide unbiased estimates during exercise, unlike PETCO2 which overestimates it.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Caution advised with indirect PaCO2 estimates at rest or PETCO2 during exercise; hypothesis-generating for unbiased alternatives in men.
Four different measures (PETCO2, PACO2, PADCO2, and PJCO2) for indirectly estimating arterial PCO2 (PaCO2) from respired gas at the mouth have been investigated. PETCO2 was the end-tidal PCO2. PACO2 was calculated using a reconstruction of the alveolar oscillation of PCO2 obtained from the end-tidal "plateau" in PCO2. PADCO2 was calculated as for PACO2 except that the effects of dead space were incorporated. PJCO2 was calculated from an empirical relationship involving PETCO2 and tidal volume. Six subjects were studied at rest and during cycle ergometry at 50 and 100 W while breathing a variety of gas mixtures. Arterial samples were drawn for determination of true PaCO2. The differences for each method between estimated and true PaCO2 at rest and at 50 and 100 W were as follows: PETCO2, -1.35 +/- 2.64, 1.67 +/- 2.31, and 2.67 +/- 2.02 (SD) Torr; PaCO2, -2.15 +/- 2.73, -0.80 +/- 2.18, and -0.35 +/- 2.31 (SD) Torr; PADCO2, -1.55 +/- 2.54, 0.25 +/- 2.16, and 0.63 +/- 2.26 (SD) Torr; and PJCO2, -1.41 +/- 2.30, 0.12 +/- 1.79, and 0.08 +/- 1.96 (SD) Torr. It is concluded that, at rest, all methods significantly underestimate true PaCO2 and during exercise PETCO2 significantly overestimates PaCO2, but no bias was detected for any of the other methods.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Robbins et al. (1990) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: