A comparison of agricultural practices, with a specific focus on pesticide use, between rice and rice-fish farmers in the Cần Thơ and Tiền Giang provinces of the Mekong Delta in 2007, shows that integrated rice-fish farming can provide a competitive alternative to intensive rice mono-cropping, if the farmer restricts the use of pesticides and takes full advantage of the ecosystem services provided by the rice-field ecosystem. In Cần Thơ, rice-fish farmers had significantly higher income (43.6 million dong ha−1 year−1) than other farmer groups, while this was not seen among rice-fish famers in Tiền Giang (32.4 million dong ha−1 year−1), which partly could be due to a high use of insecticides (0.9 kg active ingredient ha−1 crop−1) and comparatively low fish yield among these farmers. The study emphasizes the need to rethink current agricultural systems and to provide opportunities for more diverse systems that maintain and enhance a range of ecosystem services and protect human health. Future production systems should not be optimized to only provide a single ecosystem service, such as rice, but designed to deliver a variety of interlinked ecosystem service such as rice, fish, pest control, and nutrient recycling.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Berg et al. (2012) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 5 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: