Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
ORE than once the student of literature is startled to discover how far from his own point of view is the reaction of some critic. When this happens the novice is apt to feel much chagrin and doubt his judgment. But before long he becomes cognizant of the wide variation that often exists between the pronouncements of equally eminent critics. This fact once familiar, the student, realizing that difference of opinion is both possible and legitimate, profits by these experiences and gains confidence in his own powers of analysis. This is said by way of apology for the presentation of what I like to think is the American point of view of the realism and naturalism of Daudet's novels, in contradistinction to the French and European estimate expressed by critics contemporary with the novelist. After having been both familiar with Daudet's short stories and an enthusiastic admirer of their delicate, fanciful charm, spontaneous humor, and fragrantly retrospective, idealized regionalism, it was a distinct surprise to take up the novels and learn what the critics said of this phase of his art. What a challenge to thought and analysis are such statements as those of Lemattre when he says: Si l'on compare M. Daudet avec M. Zola, on verra que c'est M. Daudet qui est le romancier naturaliste, non M. Zola . . and again ... Il est, je crois, l'ecrivain le plus sincerement realiste
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Cameron C. Gullette (1933) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: