This is the authors' abstract. We don't add key points for this paper.
Bertolotti syndrome, defined as the association of back pain with lumbosacral transitional vertebrae (LSTV), was first described in 1917 by Mario Bertolotti [1]. LSTV, which are caused by congenital factors, are estimated to be present in 12.3% of the general population [2]. The actual relationship between the presence of LSTV and low back pain is highly debated, with several studies that claim little or no significant correlation [3-5], and other studies that conclude that transitional vertebrae result in a predisposition to low back pain [6-9]. The latter of these studies hypothesize that the transitional vertebrae at the L5-S1 level cause hypermobility and abnormal torque at the adjacent vertebral segment that leads to increased disk and/or zygapophyseal joint (z-joint) degeneration. Low back pain is clearly exhibited among golfers, with 22%-36% of male golfers and 22%-27% of female golfers reporting back pain [10]. Investigators in several studies assert that the general shift from the “classic swing” to the “modern swing,” which places more rotational stress and hyperextension on the lumbar spine, is behind the increased occurrence of back pain in golfers [10-12]. The biomechanics of the “modern swing” expose the spine to increased spinal loading, which may elevate the risk for myofascial, diskogenic, spondylolitic, and/or z-joint injuries, and the subsequent development of low back pain [11, 12]. Our review of the literature regarding Bertolotti syndrome in athletes revealed only one article, which briefly describes the condition in a 20-year-old baseball player [13]. The present article reports the cases of 2 golfers with chronic low back pain, whose source of pain was identified to be the LSTV through diagnostic imaging and fluoroscopic injections. These cases highlight how, in many sports, and golf in particular, the lumbar spine is placed under significant repetitive loads that could potentially lead to the uncommon expression of Bertolotti syndrome from LSTV, which normally exists as asymptomatic anatomic anomalies. As a result, physicians should consider Bertolotti syndrome in their differential diagnosis when examining athletes who present with idiopathic low back pain. A 30-year-old avid amateur male golfer in otherwise excellent health presented with right-sided axial low back pain. The symptoms, for which there was no known cause of injury, had persisted for 1 year and were easily aggravated by mild lifting and golf. The patient previously had been treated with physical therapy, oral medication, one sacroiliac joint injection, and 2 epidural steroid injections, with no sustained relief of symptoms. Results of a physical examination found reproduction of some discomfort with extension and lateral bending to the right but not to the left. Lumbar flexion and hip range of motion were full and pain free. Dural tension signs were negative. Stance, posture, and gait were normal. Neurologic examination results revealed no strength, sensory, or reflex deficits. Neither palpation nor passive stretching of the piriformis muscle reproduced the patient's symptoms. Results of provocative tests of the sacroiliac joint, including flexion abduction and external rotation (FABER), Gaenslen, and joint compression tests were all negative. A lumbar magnetic resonance image (MRI) revealed bilateral incomplete sacralization of the L5 transverse processes with the sacral ala, greater on the right, with a small central disk protrusion and mild z-joint degeneration at L4-L5 (the level just rostral to the LSTV). Initially, we postulated that the back pain was from the z-joint above the LSTV. Medial branch blocks of the dorsal rami (MBDR) did provide more than 80% pain relief for 2 hours; however, a radiofrequency denervation procedure of the L3, L4 MBDRs resulted in no sustained clinical improvement. Lumbar diskography then was performed to determine whether the small central disk protrusion at the L4-L5 level was acting as a pain generator. Had the diskogram been positive, an intradiskal source of pain would have been considered. However, the diskogram demonstrated no concordant pain at the L4-L5 level. A diagnostic sacrotransverse joint injection of the LSTV with anesthetic and steroid provided significant short-term relief (Figure 1). The patient then underwent a radiofrequency denervation procedure that covered the length of the lumbosacral pseudoarticulation [14] (Figure 2A, B), which resulted in sustained improvement of his symptoms and his ability to return to golf without pain. After a little more than 3 months, the patient returned and explained that the pain had gradually returned to the same area. The patient then received a second radiofrequency denervation procedure of the LSTV. At a 3.5-month follow-up after this last procedure, the patient reported a numeric pain score of 2.5 (a 64% improvement in pain from his initial visit to our practice). He is currently able to play golf and to engage in physical activity without limitations. Fluoroscopically guided diagnostic sacrotransverse joint injection of the lumbosacral transitional vertebrae (LSTV). (A, B) Radiofrequency denervation of the lumbosacral pseudoarticulation. Five lesions were created at 0.5-cm intervals to cover the length of the lumbosacral transitional vertebrae (LSTV). A 19-year-old female National Collegiate Athletic Association Division 1 golfer presented with a 6-month history of left-sided low back pain that radiated, with progressive parasthesia, down the left leg to the left foot and toes. The patient stated that the pain began while golfing and was worsened by athletic activity. She was initially treated at an outside facility for a hamstring strain, with no success, and presented for a second opinion. The patient had an unremarkable and noncontributory medical history. Results of a physical examination revealed that pain restricted her rotation of the spine to the left, more so than to the right. Lumbar flexion and hip range of motion were full and pain free. Dural tension signs were negative. Stance, posture, and gait were normal. Neurologic examination revealed no strength, sensory, or reflex deficits. Neither palpation nor passive stretching of the piriformis muscle reproduced her symptoms. Results of provocative tests of the sacroiliac joint, including FABER, Gaenslen, and joint compression tests, were all negative. A review of the MRI showed that the intervertebral disks and z-joints appeared normal at all lumbar levels. However, the MRI did reveal a left-sided LSTV with degenerative changes and bony edema (Figure 3A, B). (A, B) T2 coronal and axial magnetic resonance image, revealing left-sided lumbosacral transitional vertebrae (LSTV), with degenerative changes and bony edema (solid arrows) at the pseudoarticulation. Our initial impression was a symptomatic LSTV and associated L5 radiculitis, which we believe stemmed from chemical irritation of the L5 nerve as it passed medially and ventrally by the inflamed LSTV and into the hip region. The patient was treated with a fluoroscopically guided left sacrotransverse intra-articular joint injection and a left L5 transforaminal epidural steroid injection, with excellent relief of her pain. She then was placed in a comprehensive spine rehabilitation program and has been able to return to playing golf pain free for the past 6 months. The association of LSTV with low back pain, known as Bertolotti syndrome, has long been debated. As early as 1977, Tini et al [3] found no correlation between low back pain and transitional vertebrae in a study of more than 4000 patients. Luoma et al [4], when studying a population of middle aged men, also found no significant correlation between the presence of LSTV and low back pain. Although Elster [8] reported no overall difference in spinal pathology between patients with LSTV and those without, he did find that there was a significant difference in the distribution of spinal pathologies between the 2 groups. There were higher frequencies of foraminal, lateral recess, and central canal stenosis in the LSTV group, and disk protrusions were 9 times more likely at the level immediately above the transitional vertebrae [8]. Similarly, although Vergauwen et al [9] reported that there was no significant difference in overall degenerative spinal changes between patients with LSTV and those without, they also found that disk protrusions and extrusions, disk and facet degeneration, and nerve root canal stenosis were more likely to occur at the level suprajacent to the LSTV. Furthermore, in a study that investigated the impacts of congenital lumbosacral abnormalities in young men with prolonged back pain, Taskaynatan et al [15] concluded that, even if a causal relationship cannot be firmly established, the presence of LSTV increases the severity of patients' symptoms. Although there is little consensus regarding the causal relationship between LSTV and low back pain, there is evidence that the presence of LSTV alters the biomechanics and load bearing of the lumbar spine. Elster [8] first suggested that the reduced mobility at the interspace of the lumbosacral transition leads to hypermobility at the level above the transitional vertebrae. Furthermore, in an anatomical study of 70 cadavers, Aihara et al [6] found that the iliolumbar ligaments, which act to provide torsional stability to the lumbar spine, were significantly thinner and weaker at the level directly above the LSTV, and that there was significantly more disk degeneration at that level. It is possible that the hypermobility and altered load bearing that results from the presence of LSTV concentrate abnormal rotational and compressive forces on the adjacent vertebral level and place this level at higher risk for degenerative changes when exposed to significant stress [16, 17]. Participation in golf subjects the lumbar spine to repetitive abnormal and asymmetrical forces, and the relationship between low back pain and golf is well established in the medical literature. Back pain is the most commonly reported golf injury [18], being responsible for 18% of chronic golf injuries, and more than a quarter of all golfers have experienced golf-related low back pain [10]. Several studies have investigated the biomechanics of the golf swing, and the results of these studies indicate that the widespread adoption of the “modern” golf swing from the “classic” golf swing has contributed to the increase in back pain [10-12]. Although the modern swing does allow more power and control, it subjects the lumbar spine to significant abnormal stress [12]. In the classic golf swing, the pelvis rotates with the spine throughout the course of the swing, and the golfer finishes the swinging motion while standing up straight [18]. Alternatively, in the modern swing, the pelvic base remains stationary while the lumbar spine rotates around it, both in the back swing and during the follow through [10]. This independent twisting of the lumbar spine from the pelvic base places significant rotational forces on the lumbar spine. In addition, the modern swing finishes with a follow through that forces the back into a “reverse C” position and leads to hyperextension of the spine [10]. The mechanics of the modern swing expose the lumbar spine to significant rotational, compressive, and lateral bending forces [11], all of which, on a repetitive basis, can place excessive loads on the LSTV and lead to symptomatic changes. Hosea and Gatt [12] measured these forces at the L3-L4 motion segment in both amateur and professional golfers. They found that a golf swing generates compressive loads of up to 8 times a golfer's body weight (6100 ± 2413 N in amateurs and 7584 ± 2422 N in professionals) [12]. To place these values in context, an earlier cadaveric study demonstrated disk prolapse to occur with compressive loads of only 5448 N [19]. Most cases of LSTV are asymptomatic [20] and are often overlooked or ignored as sources of low back pain. However, transitional vertebrae could potentially alter the biomechanics of the lumbar spine, causing hypermobility at the suprajacent level and abnormal load bearing, which predispose patients to degenerative spinal changes at that level. Bertolotti syndrome should especially be evaluated in patients with low back pain who are too young to normally be considered at risk for disk or z-joint degeneration. Quinlan et al [7] found that, in patients with disk degeneration, the younger patients (those less than 30 years of age) were more than 3 times more likely to have LSTV [7]. In addition, participation in sports that emphasize rotational movements could place these younger athletes with LSTV at risk for degenerative changes at vertebral levels that experience hypermobility, which could result in the expression of Bertolotti syndrome. The patients presented in this article are both avid golfers who possess LSTV and had chronic low back pain on the side of their transitional vertebrae. Our practice, like many others, initially did not view LSTV as a likely source of low back pain, instead first suspecting injury to the z-joints or intervertebral disks, which can be seen from the early diagnostic workup and treatment in case 1. By drawing on our experience in diagnosing and successfully treating case 1, Bertolotti syndrome was more readily recognized and treated in case 2. Although Bertolotti syndrome remains a topic of much debate and has not been definitively proven to date, our experience with patients such as those presented in this case series has led us to see the importance of considering the syndrome as a potential pain generator in relatively young athletes who present with idiopathic low back pain. Our literature review revealed only one other article that mentioned Bertolotti syndrome in athletes, briefly discussing the condition in the case report of a 20-year-old baseball player [13]. Further research should be conducted to determine the validity of any causal relationship between LSTV and low back pain, and to find the mechanical pathway through which it acts. In addition, more research is needed to investigate the expression of Bertolotti syndrome in relatively young athletes, who seem to be at highest risk for the condition. Because most cases of LSTV exist as asymptomatic conditions, they often are overlooked as a source of pain during the clinical evaluation. The cases presented in this article highlight how, in many sports, and golf in particular, the lumbar spine is placed under significant unnatural stress that could potentially lead to the expression of Bertolotti syndrome in patients too young to normally be at risk for degenerative spinal changes. As a result, physicians should consider Bertolotti syndrome in their differential diagnosis when examining relatively young athletes who participate in rotational sports, such as golf, and present with idiopathic low back pain.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Back et al. (2011) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: