Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
"Anomalous" absorption by formaldehyde in diffuse dust clouds-6-cm line absorption in the absence of a continuum source-is generally conceded to result from a pump which maintains the 6-cm excitation temperature below 2 K, producing thereby absorption of the microwave background. A quantum- mechanical treatment is given here of the collisional-pumping process which Townes and Cheung suggest will cool the 6-cm levels by the required amount. It is shown that quantum effects probably limit the proposed process to regions where the kinetic temperature Tk > 45 K, and may even suppress it altogether. (Hydrogen molecules are taken for the colliding neutral particles, but essentially the same results are expected from H or He collisions.) Electron impact, moreover, is shown to heat the 6-cm transition at essentially all Tk, and would suppress the proposed collisional cooling in regions having n /na2 even if it were to occur in less ionized regions. Since radio observations of OH, H I, and CO Tk to be well below 45 K in a typical dark nebula where anomalous absorption is observed (Heiles's Cloud 2), and since the required combination of high Tk and low n /na2 is difficult to reconcile with thermal and ionization equilibrium, it is concluded that collisions are probably not the cause of anomalous absorption.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
P. Thaddeus (1972) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: