Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
It may seem inconceivable that the basic epidemiology of HIV infection remains undocumented in many parts of the world at the close of 2004. Indeed, while descriptions of HIV prevalence and associated risk factors may not be readily available for low-risk, possibly obscure settings, noticeable gaps today of basic information in societies with well-documented high prevalence epidemics strains credulity. Yet, that is exactly the case of HIV epidemiology among men who have sex with men (MSM) in Thailand [1]. This is particularly ironic since the first case of AIDS reported in Thailand in 1984 occurred in a Thai male with a male partner [2]. The voluminous Thai record of its explosive and high prevalence HIV epidemic has been extremely well documented and published widely in international scientific journals [3–6]. However, the focus was primarily centered on demonstrating the escalating rates of HIV/AIDS among heterosexuals and, more recently, injection drug user populations. How is it that the MSM epidemic was ignored in Thailand? In two words – stigma and discrimination! van Griensven and colleagues in Thailand [1], who attended locations where significant numbers of Thai MSM were found, report on the first, large-scale epidemiologic study of HIV prevalence and associated risk behaviours in MSM in the capital city of Bangkok in 2003. Although the reported HIV prevalence of 17.3% may be considered to be relatively low or high in relation to other settings, what is of greatest importance is that a figure now exists that allows for domestic and international comparison. Because homosexuality is widely stigmatized in Thailand, as in most of the world, little local political or social movement exists to advocate for the health and human rights of MSM. Without empirical data to suggest the presence of a widespread epidemic, MSM were not included in the Thai national HIV sentinel surveillance system that has been underway since 1989 [7], despite the fact that MSM comprised the majority of HIV/AIDS cases in many other parts of the world. Without systematic data collection, ignorance continued. Data from the Bangkok report [1] demonstrate that without active surveillance, an ‘unknown’ epidemic may flourish. Indeed, of the 491 men who reported having received an HIV test before participating in this survey, none reported themselves to be HIV infected; the data presented strongly suggests otherwise. The behavioural risk factors identified by van Griesven et al. [1] are all well known: low education, high-risk anonymous partners of unknown HIV status, larger number of male sex partners, and duration (years) of anal intercourse (both receptive and insertive). The epidemiology is not new, but its lack of existence in the literature and to the Thai public health community is significant. The finding that 22.3% of MSM reported a female sex partner in the past 6 months should be a major alarm. Thailand has rightfully been proud of its internationally renowned prevention campaign (‘100 Percent Condom Use in Commercial Sex’) [8,9], which focused on condom promotion in brothels to reduce HIV acquisition among men in the general population. This intervention has been documented to have reduced both brothel visits and to have led to a dramatic decline in prevalent infection among young men [9] and pregnant women [7]; it is further substantiated by a seven-fold decline in the estimated number of new infections nationally over the past decade [10]. Nevertheless, the gains from this exemplary public health program may be undermined by a lack of attention to the HIV problem faced by MSM, many of whom have female partners with no awareness of their partners’ sexual practices. Data on male sex workers in Thailand have shown HIV prevalence rates similar to those reported in the Bangkok MSM study, and the majority of those men self-identified as heterosexual, as did young men in the military who reported MSM [11,12]. One surprising finding of the Bangkok study of MSM was the very low rate of illicit drug use reported by participants (3.6%) and only one of 1121 participants reported ever having injected drugs. The validity of these self-reports is indeed questionable, as the authors admit [1], since this investigation was conducted in the second wave of the Thai ‘War On Drugs’ of 2003, just after a bloody first wave in January to March of 2003 in which over 2000 suspected drug users and dealers were extra-judicially murdered. Thus, failure to respond honestly to the drug use questions must be interpreted in this context. The importance of confidential or anonymous HIV voluntary counseling and testing (VCT) is underscored by the findings reported by van Griesven et al. [1]. Of the 1121 enrolled participants, only 60 (5.4%) returned for test results, of whom 13.3% were HIV infected, a prevalence only slightly lower than the entire sample of men tested. Thus, the vast majority of men in this study who were HIV infected failed to return for their test results, and of those who reported prior testing, none thought they were HIV positive. Confidential HIV VCT now exists in all districts in Thailand, and the literature is replete with evidence of the importance of receiving test results to reduce behavioural risks [13,14]. In Thailand [15], as in much of the developing world [16,17], a woman's primary risk comes from the behaviour of her primary (and often only) male sex partner. Preventive interventions must continue to focus on behavioral change for HIV risk reduction, especially in cases where a partner's HIV serostatus or behaviour (be it drug use or extra-primary partners) may unwittingly be the source of infection [18,19]. One conclusion to be drawn from the important findings of the Bangkok MSM study is that ignoring a potential problem does not absolve a public health authority from responsibility. The stigma and discrimination faced by MSM and injection drug users in Thailand cannot be underestimated. However, public health officials must continuously deal with unpopular causes. With these new findings, hopefully preventive interventions will now begin to address the lingering HIV/AIDS problem among MSM in Thailand.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
David D. Celentano (2005) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: