Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Alongside the political ascendance of Donald Trump, something changed in the norms of mainstream racial discourse, especially on the right. Both Trump and those seeking to replicate his success traffic in racist provocations that defy previously settled egalitarian norms. Attempts to define these racist tropes within familiar analytic frameworks of Dog Whistle Politics or Old-Fashioned Racism fail to capture the particularities of these new discursive practices. To account for this peculiar character of contemporary right-wing racial discourse, this paper offers a systematized description of a rhetorical strategy we call Reactionary Heel Politics. Reactionary Heel Politics is the deliberate use of explicit racial provocations to performatively defy mainstream norms of racial discourse, goad antiracist opponents, and gain reactionary support, all while ostentatiously denying charges of racism. Reactionary Heel Politics emerged in response to the perceived failures of both Dog Whistle Politics and Old-Fashioned Racism, incorporating tropes of each while it strategically rebuffs them both. This article revisits the rise of Dog Whistle Politics and offers an account of Reactionary Heel Politics as an emergent rhetorical mode. Through conceptual analysis and rhetorical case study of three key instances, it demonstrates how this novel mode of racist discourse emerged and proliferated in contemporary U.S. politics.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Gooding et al. (2025) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: