Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Phase diagrams with newly discovered supercritical (SC) solid-like state, liquid/liquid-like boundary, and Dwij point, beyond which only gas and solid exist (V. Prasad et al.), can provide new insights into many terrestrial and extraterrestrial phenomena. This is demonstrated here for Earth’s interior and for five other planets. For example: (a) Pure water would transition from liquid to an SC liquid-like state within ∼15 km, to solid-like in the upper mantle (∼60 km) continuing to the lower mantle, and finally, as fcc-solid at ∼1000 km. (b) SC water for heat recovery may be available within 2–5 km depths. (c) Methane/natural gas becomes SC gas-like at ∼0.16 km, remains SC liquid-like up to ∼7 km (12 times higher density), and becomes SC solid-like below, indicating more reservoir gas than previously known. (d) Regarding CO 2 sequestration at the ocean bottom, its density being only 4% higher than water at 3700 m presents major challenges. (e) If SC CO 2 is injected for enhanced natural gas recovery, it would go down as SC liquid-like to ∼8.6 km, and then, become solid-like: a better condition for storage. (f) It is impossible for pure hydrogen to exist inside the Earth. (g) Only gaseous and solid CO 2 can exist on Venus. (h) Helium in the shallow layer of the Moon may exist in its SC state. (i) On Jupiter and Saturn, hydrogen and helium are mostly in an SC gas-like state. (j) If water exists on Mars, it would transition from compressed liquid on the surface to SC solid-like at 310 km.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Haque et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: