Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
This paper forms part of a wider campaign: to deny pointillisme, the doctrine that a physical theory's fundamental quantities are defined at points of space or of spacetime, and represent intrinsic properties of such points or point-sized objects located there; so that properties of spatial or spatiotemporal regions and their material contents are determined by the point-by-point facts. More specifically, this paper argues against pointillisme about the concept of velocity in classical mechanics; especially against proposals by Tooley, Robinson and Lewis. A companion paper argues against pointillisme about (chrono)-geometry, as proposed by Bricker. To avoid technicalities, I conduct the argument almost entirely in the context of “Newtonian” ideas about space and time, and the classical mechanics of point-particles, i.e. extensionless particles moving in a void. But both the debate and my arguments carry over to relativistic physics. 1. Introduction 2. The wider campaign 2.1Connecting physics and metaphysics 2.1.1Avoiding controversy about the intrinsic–extrinsic distinction 2.1.2Distinction from three mathematical distinctions 2.2Classical mechanics is not pointilliste, and can be perdurantist 2.2.1Two versions of pointillisme 2.2.2Two common claims 2.2.3My contrary claims 2.3In more detail… 2.3.1Four violations of pointillisme 2.3.2For perdurantism 3. Velocity as intrinsic? 3.1Can properties represented by vectors be intrinsic to a point? 3.2Orthodox velocity is extrinsic but local 3.2.1A question and a debate 3.2.2The verdict 3.3Against intrinsic velocity 3.3.1A common view—and a common problem 3.3.2Tooley's proposal and his arguments 3.3.3Tooley's further discussion 4. “Shadow velocities”: Lewis and Robinson 4.1The proposal 4.2Criticism: the vector field remains unspecified 4.3Avoiding the presupposition of persistence, using Hilbert's ε symbol 4.4Comparison with Robinson and Lewis
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Jeremy Butterfield (2006) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: