Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Education for nurses on the provision of oral care has remained for the most part unchanged for the past 120 years.1 When we do have evidence, research shows that we have not embraced these findings and changed our practice. For example, evidence demonstrates that tooth brushing is superior to foam swabbing; however, studies indicate that nurses continue to prefer the use of foam swabs to provide oral care in intensive care units.2 The Clinical Resources Task Force for the American Association of Critical-Care Nurses is currently reviewing all of the available practice alerts. The review for the practice alert related to oral care for patients at risk for ventilator-associated pneumonia affirmed that there is little evidence upon which to base practice recommendations for oral hygiene. There is even less evidence available for children. Much of the information is consensus level, and there remains little evidence to guide decision-making for practitioners. This column addresses what is currently known regarding recommended oral care hygiene for acutely and critically ill children.There are many reasons why a child may exhibit poor oral status. Insufficient intake of vitamins and minerals can make patients susceptible to infection and malnutrition. Medical conditions such as anemia, Crohn disease, and immunosuppression related to leukemia, diabetes, cancer, or associated treatments may affect hydration and the natural oral flora, also increasing risk for poor nutrition and infection.3,4 Dehydration, poor diet, or absent oral intake reduces production and function of saliva, leading to xerostomia. Many medications and infusions alter the oral cavity’s normal flora, pH, or salivary gland activity, reducing saliva’s protective effects3–5 (see Table). Antibiotics increase the risk of Candida infection or herpes developing. Medications given in a syrup form can result in dental caries and xerostomia. Mouth breathing and the presence of a nasogastric or orogastric tube can contribute to xerostomia as the mouth is continuously open.6 Oxygen administration also has a drying effect on oral mucosa. Intubation can cause xerostomia, a bacterial shift from mainly gram-positive to gram-negative bacteria, impaired access for oral care, and the potential development of pressure areas.4 These factors should lead to an increased frequency of oral care.7,8 It is important to remember that patients can become colonized with pathogens within 48 hours of admission to the hospital.6,9A thorough oral assessment should be performed and documented upon admission or initial contact.3,10 Thereafter, regular assessments should be carried out, with increased frequency if potential problems are identified or with changes in condition or medications.3–5,7,11–14 An oral care procedure that outlines the frequency of oral assessments, need for suctioning, and moisturization of the oral mucosa and lips is recommended.4,15 The head of bed should be elevated to 30°, if appropriate, to prevent aspiration of oral secretions during oral care.5 Caregivers’ hands should be washed with an antibacterial skin cleanser, and disposable gloves donned before care is provided to minimize the risk of cross-infection.5 A variety of equipment and supplies may be needed for effective cleaning. Nurses should evaluate their patients for factors that place the patient at risk for oral health concerns. For example, age or a learning and/or physical disability may cause patients to have difficulty managing their own oral care or expressing their needs. Biting may also make oral hygiene difficult to perform.14,15Use of an assessment tool is suggested in many protocols, but evidence is limited on the effect and frequency.3,11,12,15–17 Decisions regarding what equipment to use for oral care should be driven by assessment and appropriate evidence-based tools. Inadequate understanding of how to assess the oral cavity leads to uninformed choices for equipment selection and oral care technique.18 Incorrect use of equipment will not clean teeth effectively. The patient’s needs and underlying condition should be considered.Tooth brushing should be implemented by the time the first primary tooth erupts.11,19 It takes up to 2 years after eruption for sufficient surface minerals to protect against tooth decay to be present. Newly erupted teeth are therefore more susceptible to decay.20 Children with teeth are recommended to have their teeth brushed twice a day with an age-appropriately sized, soft toothbrush and the correct amount of fluoridated toothpaste.3,4,6,11,19–23 A pea-sized amount of toothpaste is recommended for children ages 3 to 6 years.22–24 A smear (or rice-sized amount) of toothpaste is recommended for children less than 3 years old.11,19,24 The recommended technique for brushing teeth effectively is brushing up and down in parallel with teeth, as well as brushing over the grinding surfaces.22 Excess toothpaste should be suctioned or spit out instead of rinsed. Rinsing decreases fluoride absorption and caries prevention.9,25–28 After brushing, the mouth should be moistened with sterile water on a toothbrush or foam swab. Toothbrushes should be rinsed after each use and kept clean. Brushes should be replaced as needed.25 Some electric toothbrushes remove plaque better than standard toothbrushes do.14Strong evidence to support tooth brushing for intubated patients is lacking.12,29 Some professional groups advocate tooth brushing for intubated patients to prevent pneumonia, particularly ventilator-associated pneumonia.13,14,27,30 Tooth brushing is considered a risk as bacteria can enter the bloodstream through abrasions and openings in the mucosal and gingival tissue.10,28,30,31 Thus critically ill or immunocompromised patients may be exposed to risk without benefit.12,15 A toothbrush is considered more effective than foam swabs for removing plaque; however, the effectiveness depends upon the duration and frequency of use.10,20Use of sponge swabs is considered to be ineffective for removing plaque on and between teeth.2,4,12,20,23,25 Swabs also present a significant choking risk when moistened before use. Use may be indicated if gingival bleeding or damage is evident or likely, or if the patient is unable to tolerate a toothbrush and paste.25 When used, the foam sticks should be used in a rotating fashion.25Flossing is recommended if assessment indicates this is safe to do.3 Caution is needed for patients with bleeding tendencies (such as oncology patients), as the risk of hemorrhage is increased. Flossing removes debris, reduces plaque buildup, and decreases the likelihood of gingivitis.22Chlorhexidine gluconate (CHG) is a broad-spectrum antibacterial rinse8,13,14,31,32 active against gram-positive and gram-negative organisms. Once applied to oral surfaces, it is released over the next 8 to 24 hours, so every-12-hour use is recommended.13,14 CHG has been recommended as an oral rinse for children with cancer as it alleviates discomfort and reduces the severity of mucositis.3,33–35 CHG should be applied with a foam swab to the teeth and gums a minimum of 30 minutes after teeth are brushed. A waiting period is important as the sodium monophosphate and sodium lauryl phosphate present in toothpastes interacts with and inactivates CHG.4,14,36 Excess CHG solution or gel should be suctioned. It is recommended that teeth not be brushed or rinsed with water after application of CHG, as this will remove the product. It remains unclear what ages and diagnoses of patients benefit from the use of CHG. No evidence indicates that oral care with CHG and tooth brushing is different from oral care with CHG alone.37 Further research is needed to determine whether use of CHG mouth rinse is beneficial for children younger than 6 years of age.13An antiseptic mouthwash is recommended between brushings.3 This antibacterial agent is effective, but prolonged use may cause reversible tooth staining. The natural microorganisms of the oral cavity may also be adversely affected.37 Mouthwashes are most effective when used twice daily.37 A water-based mouthwash should be used after oral intake.3,6 Water-based mouthwashes are effective for debris removal. Mouthwashes are not effective however, for plaque removal.Oral cavity moisturizers should be considered for dry mouth. Moisturizers may include sucking ice chips or a saliva substitute.3 These products replace moisture, but are not antibacterial like natural saliva.3 Ensuring frequent oral intake, if appropriate, is helpful. Lips should also be kept moist with moisturizers.3Other agents have been used over the years for oral care. Sodium bicarbonate, hydrogen peroxide, and glycerin and lemon swabs should not be used for routine oral care as they are considered harmful.3,5,6,12,14,37–39 Adverse effects include increased alkalinity, decalcification of teeth, alterations of the oral microbiome, and loss of saliva. Hydrogen peroxide has been used to remove crust on the lips and oral mucosa; however, it can cause superficial burns if not diluted correctly.12–14,39 Sodium bicarbonate has been recommended to break down tenacious saliva, but it too can cause superficial burns if not diluted sufficiently.6,14,40 Lemon and glycerin swabs are considered moistening agents; however, they cause a rebound xerostomia after initially stimulating saliva production. They are acidic, can be irritating, and may cause demineralization of the enamel.6,12–14,39,40Sterile water and normal saline are appropriate for oral care.14 They are widely available, inexpensive, and have minimal side effects. Tap water can be a source of nosocomial infection and therefore should be avoided as an oral rinse for critically ill patients.41–43Guidelines for gums of infants whose teeth have not yet erupted are less clear. One guideline recommends cleaning and moistening the gums with a small, soft toothbrush or gauze swab moistened with clean water or saline; however, the scrubbing action with gauze can be traumatic to oral tissues.32 Cleaning the mouth in this manner is not considered to be effective.41 Foam swabs are recommended to moisten or apply mouth rinse.31Oral care with fresh (never frozen) colostrum provides neonates with the same benefits as infants who are feeding directly from the breast. Oligosaccharides present in human milk destroy bacteria, viruses, and fungi.38,44–46 Expressed human milk that has been frozen then defrosted should not be used for oral care as freezing and thawing can decrease the cellular and host defense properties of the milk, thus negating its beneficial effects.46 Refrigerating expressed human milk can also reduce some of the anti-infective properties, but not as markedly as freezing. The priority should be given to fresh expressed milk for mouth care; however, refrigerated expressed milk is considered a suitable and effective alternative.46 Colostrum and mature milk can be stored up to 48 hours in the refrigerator. Using expressed breast milk supports the early sensory development of taste and smell for neonates who are unable to feed orally.46,47 It also creates a positive sensation in the mouth.47Oral care should be performed for infants who are receiving nothing by mouth or infants who require ventilator support. Optimally, oral care is introduced within 48 hours of birth. Minimally, oral care should be provided once daily.47 Some protocols suggest more frequent performance such as every 6 hours, if the neonate is unable to take oral feedings, is intubated, or is receiving supplemental oxygen. Evidence and consensus are lacking regarding the recommended frequency to provide benefit.18Oral care should be performed with nasogastric tube feedings, as coordination with the start of a tube feeding promotes the association of tasting milk at the time of the feeding.18 If the mother is pumping at the bedside, it is ideal to perform oral care after a pumping session.18,47 Physiological stability and the adverse risk of overstimulation must be considered. Oral care can be provided by dipping a pacifier in human milk.18,47 Nurses should consider the potential benefits and disadvantages of using a pacifier and parental preference before initiating this method. Oral care with milk should continue until the neonate is feeding orally.18,47To perform oral care, hands should be washed and gloves donned to prevent cross-infection. Before oral care, the patient should be suctioned, if needed, to remove secretions. A cotton-tipped applicator is then moistened with a small amount (approximately 0.2 mL) of sterile water, fresh colostrum, or fresh expressed human milk to clean the mouth and tongue. Colostrum is preferred as its constituents can be systemically absorbed.46 Additives such as fortifiers should not be used in milk for oral care.18 If there is too little expressed human milk available, sterile water should be used or mixed into the expressed milk available.18 The cotton-tipped applicator should be gently rolled along the lips, and around the gumline and tongue, if the oral cavity is large enough. The entire buccal mucosa should also be coated. A fresh applicator should be used to moisten the lips. Moisturizer should be applied if the lips are particularly dry. Once the mother is providing larger volumes of milk, decant a small volume of milk in a separately labelled bottle for refrigeration. This volume should be used exclusively for oral care. Use of expressed milk and teaching parents how to perform oral care reaffirms to mothers the importance of their milk and incorporates them in their neonates’ care.Many questions related to oral care in children still need to be answered by research. An oral assessment tool that is appropriate for critically ill children and easy to use must be developed and tested. Data are needed to demonstrate that tooth brushing is safe in intubated children. Does tooth brushing affect the incidence of ventilator-associated pneumonia? Does oral hygiene change the composition of the oral microbiome in hospitalized children? The safety of different types of oral interventions must be determined. The method of providing oral care remains controversial. What is the best method? What is the optimal frequency? What are the benefits and outcomes of providing oral care?Standardizing the practice of oral care has the potential to improve the health of acute and critically ill children.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Lori Williams (2016) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: