Why the study?
The superiority of high-intensity interval training over moderate-intensity continuous training remains questioned due to conflicting results across studies that may stem from protocol standardization and comparison methods.
Does matching the number of heartbeats per training session provide a more appropriate way to compare the cardiovascular benefits of HIIT and MICT?
Does matching the number of heartbeats per training session provide a more appropriate way to compare the cardiovascular benefits of HIIT and MICT?
When comparing the cardiovascular benefits of HIIT and MICT, matching the number of heartbeats per training session may be a more appropriate methodological approach to account for training volume.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Optimal exercise parameters for CV/metabolic disease remain unclear; leaves open whether heartbeats per session meaningfully refines individualized prescriptions.
The prescription of physical training as a therapeutic measure in the treatment and control of chronic degenerative diseases, mainly cardiovascular disease and metabolic disease, is an increasingly used clinical approach, often preceding the pharmacological prescription. Despite the advances in exercise physiology and cardio functional performance in recent decades, the main challenge is to identify the most appropriate modality, intensity, and training volume for each pathophysiological situation. In this case, the superiority of high-intensity interval training (HIIT) over moderate-intensity continuous training (MICT) has been questioned, since many studies have shown similar results in the different physiological parameters evaluated, especially regarding cardiorespiratory fitness, cardiovascular autonomic control, and cardiac morpho functionality. The cause of conflicting results observed by different studies may be related to standardization, application, and comparison of the two protocols. HIIT would have a higher number of heartbeats compared to MICT, when maintaining high heart rate is disregarded. In this since, our hypothesis for the greatest gains in cardiorespiratory fitness and in the autonomic and cardiovascular adaptations promoted by HIIT is based on the higher volume of training performed as a function of the higher number of heartbeats per unit of time, since the intermittence was calculated based on a percentage of maximum heart rate or reserve heart rate. Nevertheless, the intermittency between the established heart rate percentages is not necessarily accompanied by the intermittent heart rate. Therefore, considering and matching the number of heartbeats performed per training session in both models seems to be a more appropriate way to compare the two training protocols.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Rodrigues et al. (2020) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: