Why the study?
Does social support improve psychological well-being and recovery in patients post-CABS?
Does social support improve psychological well-being and recovery in patients post-CABS?
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
This commentary emphasizes the critical role of perceived social support, particularly from spouses, in the psychological recovery and well-being of patients following coronary artery bypass surgery.
Coronary artery bypass surgery (CABS) remains the primary method of revascularization and aims to prevent myocardial infarction (MI) and reduce or eliminate symptoms such as angina or breathlessness. Initially reported studies concentrated on clinical measurements such as mortality, morbidity and graft patency. The emphasis has now shifted to include patients’ perceptions on their quality of life and the role of social support post-CABS. Functional ability after CABS takes some time to return to normal so patients may be more dependent on their spouses and family until their normal functional capacity returns. The fate of patients undergoing CABS and their quality of life following surgery is becoming an area of increased interest. In this paper by Rantanen et al. (2004), the role of social support is examined in relation to the patients’ significant others. The aim of this paper is to provide a critical commentary on the paper of Rantanen et al. There are various relevant aspects that will be described and these are: actual and perceived social support, lack of social support and coronary artery disease (CHD) and mortality risk, psychological well-being of patients post-CABS, neuropsychological deficits post-CABS and the role of the spouse in the patient's recovery. Within the last 20 years there has been much interest on the role of social support and its role in health. Social support can often be misinterpreted as formal help from social services but here, it refers to support from family, friends, spouse or partner (as appropriate). Social support with three elements is outlined by the authors: affect, affirmation and aid. Social support is seen as a positive effect and the presence of significant others is associated with recovery. There are many definitions of what characterizes social support. Two separate but important aspects of social support have been studied: actual and perceived social support. Of importance is the fact that social support levels will differ between people and therefore subjective opinions need to be examined. An individual can have many social contacts but it is the frequency and type of contact that is relevant. However from objective measures that examine the number of social contacts per week or per month, this may be giving us an accurate picture of actual or perceived social support. A difference between actual and perceived support has been observed (Health Education Authority 1992). The HEA survey found a diminished actual amount of social contact (with friends) in those older than 55 years but no difference was found in actual contact with relatives. The conclusion is that if a high level of social support is perceived, there are less psychological stressors. Holahan et al. (1996) reported more depression in those with chronic illness when followed up and found social support and adaptive coping mechanisms to predict fewer depressive symptoms. Lack of social support has been identified as a risk factor for CHD in a Swedish study (Orth-Gomer et al. 1993). One controversial paper (Vaillant et al. 1998) stated that confounders such as alcohol abuse, smoking and a premorbid psychopathology have not been included in studies thus not permitting to consider the deleterious effects of these variables on social relationships and physical health. Their findings were that when these confounders were included in the analyses, much of the association between social support and mortality were mediated by these variables. This highlights the difficulties in establishing a direct path between social support and mortality. A study by Brummett et al. (2001) raised the issues of social isolation and CHD mortality. Higher mortality rates were found in those who were socially isolated but the reasons for this were not associated with more severe CHD, more reported depression or stress in comparison with those non-isolated patients. What was interesting was no difference reported in the index of social satisfaction between socially isolated and non-isolated patients showing that perception is all-important and may not reflect actual social support. Social support, physical symptoms and mood are also linked. Some studies have highlighted a direct association between social support and depression, anxiety, physical symptoms and self-reported use of health services (Holahan et al. 1996). Those with a high level of social support from family and friends had less symptoms of anxiety and depression and the severity of physical and psychological symptoms were less than those with little or no social support (Sarason et al. 1985). One of the most important variables when examining patients post-CABS is psychological well-being and whether anxiety or depression are present. One of the areas that Rantanen et al. were examining was affect which refers to appreciation, admiration, respect or love and also affirmation which includes influencing the individual's way of thinking. Both of these aspects, aid and affirmation, can be affected by the patient's psychological well-being, namely the presence of anxiety or depression. Rantanen et al. make no mention of the patients’ psychological well-being and some studies have shown that patients report changes in their subjective cognition in the presence of depression (Newman et al. 1988). Anxiety prior to surgery has been reported along with depression in the recovery period among men and women (Barefoot et al. 1996, Duits et al. 1997). Roebuck's (1999) study of telephone support following CABS reported that patients found these follow-up calls postdischarge beneficial but did not reduce their anxiety and depression. The effects of psychological well-being, in particular those of anxiety and depression in the long-term have not been reported. It is possible that they recede over time following surgery but there may be other emotional changes in patients after surgery which will affect their recovery and their perceived social support. What is interesting in the paper of Rantanen et al. is that the patient chose the significant other that they wanted to participate in the study. As 70% of patients were male and 70% of respondents were female, it may be that the patients felt obliged to name their spouses as the significant other. One query would be of the 146 questionnaires sent, how many of those who did not return the questionnaire were divorced, single or widowed? Do those who do not have a spouse demonstrate a significant difference in social support? As regards the demographics, half the cohort was retired and this would mean a change in social support and social functioning. A comparison of the social support of those still working and those retired would be interesting in terms of differences of affect, affirmation and aid. With respect to the age of patients, over 70% were 60 years or older. Higher affirmation was reported in those greater than 69 years and this may be a reflection of nurses caring for older patients. The age of a person will influence social support. Older people tend to be more socially isolated due to change in circumstances (i.e. retirement and death of spouse) and even financial insecurity. The other issue is the availability of social support through local resources. In areas of extreme poverty or geographical remoteness, there may be a lack of community services leading to poor social integration. In the results of Rantanen et al., the majority of patients completed only secondary school education (62%) and 55% were retired. Social support can affect the individual positively or negatively. Social support from a spouse has a crucial role in the postoperative period following bypass surgery (Radley et al. 1987). At a one-year follow-up, he found that those who ‘returned to normal’ had the least change in their relationships and those who complained of pain had marked decline in their social contacts. The couples who were most prepared for surgery actually increased their social contacts and their own relationship was better. However he did find some patients who kept things to themselves and did not wish to discuss issues with their families in order to get back to normal as quickly by avoiding discussion. Unfortunately there were no anxiety and depression measurements pre- or postoperatively. Yates (1995) reported beneficial psychological recovery post-MI from spousal support and health care providers. This highlights that the social support does not necessarily have to come from the spouse to aid recovery in cardiac illness. Kulik and Mahler (1989) examined levels of spouse support after heart surgery. They found that men who had many visits from their wives in hospital and perceived a high level of social support made a speedy recovery and were discharged 1.26 days earlier than those with lower levels of social support. Cohen and Willis (1985) established the importance of a ‘significant other’ and the ability of being able to confide in them playing a role in reducing the adverse effects of stress. The actual physical presence of a ‘significant other’ may help regulate the emotional state of an individual (Cohen & Williamson 1991). In their paper, Rantanen et al. identified the spouses as the major source of support to the patient (87%) and to a lesser degree their children (60%). Spouses have an important role to play in their partner's life in terms of emotional and psychological support but it must be acknowledged that having a spouse does not always have a positive effect on health. Some studies show the negative correlation between the level of social support and CHD mortality and morbidity (Chandra et al. 1983, Reifman 1995, Martikainen & Valkonen 1996). One study suggested a dominant partner could affect blood pressure reactivity with the study positively correlating high levels of perceived spouse dominance and cardiovascular reactivity (Brown et al. 1998). It has been established the negative effect the death of a spouse can have and the importance of perceived emotional support from a spouse, but in this paper the patients state that their spouses is their major support (87%) so therefore we presume the spouses are playing a positive supportive role. It is important to distinguish what the nurses’ primary objective is; is it to care for the patient post-CABS or to ensure that the spouse or significant other can cope and provide the social support to the patient to aid their recovery? Although relatives have commented on insufficient information post-CABS, the nurse is primarily concerned with the patient. Patients reported higher levels of social support from significant others and nurses than the family did, this is not surprising. There may be an element of the Hawthorne effect. One of the findings of Rantanen et al. was that significant others reported lower levels of social support than the patient. The reason for this could be quite simple; the expectations of patient and significant other post-CABS may be very different. Radley et al. (1987) conducted a study of men and their wives in the pre- and postbypass surgery stages. When interviewed at one year postoperatively, the couples reported different expectations regarding recovery from surgery. The spouse may hold more information on their partner's quality of life than is currently reported or the spouses’ perception of their partner's health may confuse the issue even more. The spouse however, is not the only form of social support. Other forms of social support have been demonstrated (Seeman et al. 1987), these authors reported that in those over 60 years, close friends and/or relatives are of greater importance than spouses. When perceived social support was measured in another study, it was reported higher (with friends and relatives) in older patients (Health Education Authority 1992). In the majority of coronary bypass operations, the cardiopulmonary bypass machine (CPB) is used. The CPB is not without its problems and these range from cerebrovascular accidents to transient syndromes (delayed awakening, delirium and impaired memory for example). Cerebral micro-emboli can be detected occurring during cardiac surgery via Doppler monitoring of the middle cerebral artery (Pugsley 1989). Patients undergoing bypass surgery suffer a decline in intellectual functioning (Newman & Stygall 1997) and have been measured at various time intervals postoperatively, for example eight days to six weeks after surgery (Savageau et al. 1982, Newman et al. 1987, Pugsley et al. 1994). Neuropsychological tests are used in this way to study the short- and long-term impact of cardiac surgery on the brain. The measures used include tests for attention, memory and concentration, motor and psychomotor speed. Some studies have demonstrated worse cognitive outcomes for patients with greater number of emboli (Pugsley et al. 1994, Barbut et al. 1997). Early assessment in the postoperative period have revealed a deficit of between 17 and 30% of patients and had lower scores at one month post-CABS (Savageau et al. 1982, Sellman et al. 1992). At six months, the reported rates were 5–6%. The majority of studies demonstrate a decline in cognitive functioning at discharge from hospital and improvement between six and eight weeks. There is a strong possibility that if the patients’ in the study of Rantanen et al. were tested preoperatively and at 4 weeks postoperatively a percentage would demonstrate neuropsychological deficit and this may explain why the patients are happy with the level of information given to them but the relatives are not. The patient has problems with memory and concentration and is unlikely to retain much of what he/she is told prior to discharge. This would partly explain the patients reporting high levels of all types of social support. The needs of the patient and their relatives are quite different but this has not been investigated. Interestingly the neuropsychological decline although reported to decrease over time has been reported five years after surgery in our five-year follow-up study of 107 patients (Stygall et al. 2003). To complicate the issue further, patients are now undergoing bypass grafting without cardiopulmonary bypass. One study examined the two significant differences between the scores in their neuropsychological tests. This suggests that cardiopulmonary bypass may not be solely responsible for the neuropsychological impairment associated with open-heart surgery (Taggart et al. 1999). One useful questionnaire is The Multidimensional Scale of Perceived Social Support, developed by Zimet et al. (1988). There are three subscales each addressing a different source of support: family, friends and ‘significant other’ (their spouse for example). The scale is easily completed and examines the whole social network. In my study of quality of life five years post-CABS (Lee 2004), perceived social support was examined from the patients’ perspective. No differences were found in perceived social support of those with a spouse compared with those without a spouse (i.e. unmarried, widowed or divorced). Perceived social support from spouse, family and friends shows high levels in the majority of patients. A very small group of patients reported very little perceived social support. No differentiation has been made between actual and perceived social support. The perceived support from friends was not significantly different between the two groups (P = 0.258). Thus, there are potentially many issues affecting the patients recovery post-CABS; the presence of anxiety and depression, age, marital status, employment status and neuropsychological problems involving memory, concentration and attention. These factors cannot be overlooked when determining patients’ social support. One key element is social support to patients and significant others post-CABS is whether we are measuring actual or perceived social support and whether social support has been clearly defined. Rantanen et al. did not address these issues. The authors do not demonstrate what difference social support (and involving the family more) would make to the patients recovery. Variables that affect social support are multifactorial and the importance of such confounding variables like alcohol consumption, smoking and premorbid psychopathology need to be taken into consideration when predicting the effect of social support on mortality. Thus, to what extent social support actually affects overall mortality is unclear although it would appear to play an important role. There is no harm in providing nursing support for the whole family but it must be borne in mind that patients and their social network may have very different requirements in terms of information about issues relating to hospital treatment, home-care, help with specific postoperative problems and decision-making. A further study examining these issues is recommended.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Geraldine Lee (2005) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: