Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
I nthe 2005 C lutageditionofA Treatise of Civil power, Geoffrey Hill included a belated elegy for John Berryman: And Berryman, how did he slip through this trawl of gratitude? The Dream Songs, then, with other things; their bone-yard vaudeville sparkish, morose, multi-voiced monologue, erratic tenderness to self and lovers. A gentle courteous man, no-nonsense scholar, badly-transmitted, blarneying on location, face-fungused wizard in a camp film. 1 The paean is a verse essay in miniature on Berryman’s body of work, evocatively characterised as ‘multi-voiced monologue’. The sense of the impromptu clownishness and makeshift bricolage of Berryman’s verse in ‘bone-yard vaudeville’ is further inflected by an allusion to ‘Mr. Bones’, the form of address for Henry adopted by his ‘end man’ interlocutor in the blackface minstrel patter of The Dream Songs . 2 The cluster of adjectives, including suggestive modulations that provide redress (‘tenderness to self and lovers’; emphasis added), capture the contradictions of the poet. Hill seems less enamoured of the celebrity involved in Berryman’s 1966/7 MacArthur fellowship in Dublin (‘blarneying on location’) and A. Alvarez’s contemporaneous BBC interview (‘face-fungused wizard in a camp film’). 3 The televisual figure of speech ‘badly-transmitted’ seems to provide an answer to Hill’s rhetorical question, ‘how did [Berryman] slip through | this trawl of gratitude?’ Alvarez’s taste-making of the 1960s and 1970s was both influential on and symptomatic of an appetite among British critics for, as Harold Bloom acidly puts it, ‘American poets [who were] suicidal, mentally ill, and a touch unruly’. 4 This ‘badly-transmitted’ version of Berryman as poète maudit helps to explain Hill’s belated acknowledgement of Berryman. In his revisionary study John Berryman’s Public Vision , Philip Coleman argues that ‘Confessionalism is a profoundly problematic and limiting critical model’; his reappraisal endeavours to ‘[relocate] the scene of disorder’ from the tortured psyche to the fractured and disorienting public sphere of mid-twentieth-century Cold War America. 5 Hill is much more ambivalent than Coleman; one the one hand, Hill’s tardy praise-poem seems to admit that the ‘confessional’ tag as promenaded in the Alvarez documentary for a time obscured his deeper recognition of Berryman’s value as a poet; nevertheless, Hill remains sceptical. As will become apparent, Hill shares Coleman’s conviction that Berryman is a poet of res publica , whose best work is saved by its painstaking technique from the slur of ‘confessionalism’. Hill’s ‘trawl of gratitude’ recovers a Berryman who shares the belief that, in Hill’s own words from a reflection on his own career in lecturing and writing ‘Confessio Amantis’, ‘poetry rightly practised and understood is part of the nervous system of true polity’. 6 But whereas Coleman argues that the ‘confessional’ paradigm itself represents ‘“a communicative deficit” … that hinders clear and accurate critical debate’, 7 and whose revisionary treatment is a sustained argument for its redundancy, Hill, by contrast, is temperamentally and generationally predisposed to cling tenaciously to its validity in describing aspects of Berryman to which he is unsympathetic, particularly in his 1984 Essays in Criticism review of John Haffenden’s biography of Berryman and Eileen Simpson’s memoir. In accepting the premise of ‘confessionalism’, he is roughly in accord with Berryman, who accepts the existence and rejects the attribution of such a paradigm in a 1970 Paris Review interview when he responds to the label ‘confessional poet’ ‘with rage and contempt’. 8 Nevertheless, the ‘no-nonsense scholar’ (as represented in John Haffenden’s Berryman’s Shakespeare and in the 1976 posthumous collection The Freedom of the Poet ) is saluted in Hill’s poem; in the phrase ‘badly-transmitted’, Hill like Coleman suggests that Berryman’s cultural reception in the decades since his death has hampered a true understanding of his erudite, polyphonic verse by unduly emphasising aspects of celebrity (Robert Lowell’s glib ‘all the best of life’) and ‘despondency and madness’. 9
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Karl O’Hanlon (2016) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: