Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Internationally there is a shortage of nursing faculty (Boamah et al., 2021). Doctoral education is foundational to the faculty role in schools of nursing particularly in advancing research inspired teaching. The American Association of Colleges of Nursing (AACN) reports that about 73% of PhD students plan to pursue academic careers for which teaching is one of the essential functions (Fang et al., 2016). Yet, the focus of PhD education is predominately research training and not teaching, and PhD students may not necessarily have opportunities for understanding and learning the art and science of teaching in preparation for their future faculty role. This is of particular importance in the increasing complexity of the higher education environment. A PhD degree in nursing provides a pathway for advancing the foundation of nursing practice, pedagogy, science and healthcare delivery by providing leadership from nursing faculty, intensive mentored research experiences and opportunities for interdisciplinary collaborations. PhD-prepared nurses are essential, not only for research to improve nursing science and practice, but also for teaching future generations of nurses. Lack of adequate preparation for the faculty role may escalate the nursing faculty shortage by limiting the number and qualifications of PhD-prepared nursing faculty. Preparing the next generation of nurse researchers—not only with the skills and passion for research but also with the intention to teach—is essential to advancing the nursing profession. Ensuring there are well-qualified and credentialed PhD prepared faculty to teach is crucial for the nation for multiple reasons. For example, the PhD program is the highest degree and driver of nursing innovation and discovery. PhD-prepared nurses can educate for discovery as well as for research translation and implementation whereas a practice doctorate is typically prepared for scholarship for healthcare quality improvement. The following situations are increasing the demand on healthcare and require PhD-prepared nurses to innovate healthcare delivery and to improve patient outcomes in increasingly complex healthcare systems: the ageing of the population, the rapidly growing numbers of individuals with multiple chronic illnesses and the increasing number of individuals with health insurance. There is also an increasing demand for more highly educated, doctorally prepared nurses who can advance to leadership and teaching positions more rapidly than nurses educated at the baccalaureate or masters level (Altman et al., 2016; Watson et al., 2021). Nevertheless, the shortage of PhD-prepared nurses wanting to become faculty is a concern in the development of the future nursing faculty workforce. For example, the number of DNP programs in the United States has steadily increased from less than 50 programs in 2007 to more than 350 in 2019 (AACN, 2020). In comparison, the number of PhD nursing programs has remained unchanged and kept under 150 for the same period, limiting the pool of PhD-prepared nurses to become faculty. The 2016 Institute of Medicine (IOM) Report Assessing Progress on the IOM Report The Future of Nursing (Altman et al., 2016), noted, ‘more emphasis should be placed on increasing the number of PhD nurses in particular’. Still, the limited pool of doctorally prepared applicants for open teaching positions (57%) is among the top reasons cited by nursing schools for having difficulty in hiring faculty in 2019 (AACN, 2020); insufficient funds to hire new faculty members were the other top reason cited (64%). Similar challenges are identified internationally such as salary discrepancies and limited career paths. To address the issue of PhD-prepared nursing faculty shortage, providing supportive working environments will be important so as to meet the needs of PhD-prepared faculty that contribute to their stress. Insufficient preparation for the future teaching role can cause difficulties for the PhD graduates who pursue a career in higher education institutions where teaching is a fundamental function of their faculty role. According to an online survey of 146 new nursing faculty, defined as faculty with 4 years or less teaching experience after their doctoral program graduation (49% PhD and 51% DNP), 28% of the new faculty indicated they were likely ‘to leave academia’, with more than two thirds (68%) of them ‘intending to leave within the next 6 years’ (Aquino et al., 2018); PhD-prepared faculty had higher emotional exhaustion than DNP-prepared faculty. In the study, the majority (59%) indicated that they did not take any teaching coursework during doctoral programs (Aquino et al., 2018). The PhD-prepared faculty may have higher stress as they are required to maintain higher productivity in the research and scholarship for promotion and tenure. Indeed, new nursing faculty have reported keeping up with research as one of the main sources of stress other than heavy course loads and numerous commitments (Aquino et al., 2018; Wyllie et al., 2016). A systematic review of nine qualitative studies of early career academic nurses (Wyllie et al., 2016) revealed that the time and effort required for new faculty to adapt came as ‘an unexpected surprise to most and having a full-time academic position required a new set of skills for the necessary teaching, administration, and research’. Whether teaching training should be a required component in PhD nursing programs can be a contentious issue. In fact, there is a clear discrepancy between the requirement of a PhD degree and limited formal preparation for a future faculty role in many PhD programs. We argue that the primary focus of a PhD degree needs to be complemented with a targeted and well-structured teaching and learning curriculum for the nearly three quarters of PhD students who aspire to be future nursing faculty (Fang et al., 2016). A recent integrative review about PhD preparation of academic nurse educators (Bullin, 2018) found that—despite recommendations from the AACN for formal pedagogical preparation in PhD programs—little has been done to prepare PhD students as educators; PhD programs continue to emphasize research training only and do not provide structured teaching training, resulting in the lack of adequate preparation of graduates to transition into academic nursing faculty. The review also noted the current academic system in which teaching is often undervalued (Bullin, 2018). With the ongoing PhD-prepared nursing faculty shortage, how we prepare PhD students for their future nursing faculty careers is a critical question to address. Faculty roles typically involve teaching, research and service. Successfully balancing these roles, while learning new skills required to assume the roles, can be challenging for new faculty. Thoughtfully and intentionally preparing future faculty with orientation and structured teaching training may help with the role transition as well as retention of new faculty. For example, McNelis et al. (2019) interviewed 24 current PhD and DNP students and recent graduates from both degree programs to explore expectations and perceptions of their experience in relevance to preparation for an academic career. One of the two themes that emerged from this investigation was ‘equivocal preparation for teaching’, which highlighted the need for doctoral curricular revisions to address role readiness as future faculty. A recent international survey (Molassiotis et al., 2020) of 76 coordinators and 193 doctoral nursing students from 46 institutions offering doctoral programs—primarily PhD programs—across nine East and South East countries revealed a similar finding. According to the survey, more than half (56%) of the students had no teaching training in their programs but wanted teaching training components in the end. Among the 44% of students who reported teaching training, almost everyone (94%) indicated ‘teaching training in a doctoral program is important’ but less than three quarters (72%) were satisfied with the teaching training received. The types of teaching trainings the students received were common roles assumed by graduate teaching assistants with no structured curriculum addressing teaching and learning (e.g. tutoring nursing students, classroom lectures, grading course assignments or proctoring exams). The Johns Hopkins School of Nursing developed and embedded a comprehensive teaching fellowship in our leading PhD program to provide teaching and leadership coaching curricula—the Nurse Faculty for the Future program which focuses on facilitating preparation of future nursing faculty through developing PhD students. The importance of teaching is already emphasized in some PhD programs such as ours where every PhD student in the program is required to complete one semester of teaching residency or of teaching assistantship (analogous to research assistantship through which the student is paid to assist teaching) at other institution. The Nurse Faculty for the Future program distinguishes itself from the common models for exposing future faculty to teaching by systematically augmenting the PhD program through embedding a teaching and leadership fellowship in the PhD program for students who declare a strong commitment to a nurse faculty career. The purpose of this program is to prepare PhD students to be faculty. Students learn educational models, pedagogy and assessment methods and acquire teaching skills by working directly with faculty teaching mentors in a classroom, online course or laboratory setting. This unique curriculum may allow fellows in the program to advance more rapidly towards positions as expert faculty. It is also intended that the skills obtained in this program will minimize the stressors of acclimating to a new faculty role while balancing research and scholarship. For this state-funded educational innovation project at the PhD level, we are in the process of actively collecting evaluation data from the students enrolled in the Nurse Faculty for the Future program. If effective, the program may serve as an enhanced curricular model in the PhD program in real-world settings. During a global nursing shortage made more acute by the COVID-19 pandemic, careful attention must be given to nurturing future nursing faculty as the supply of future PhD-prepared nursing faculty falls short of the anticipated demand in the years ahead. In response to need for a rising number of PhD-prepared nursing faculty, it is important to prepare them to teach in an effective and meaningful way so they can achieve success in developing the next generation of nurses. To prepare nurses for the future, PhD education in nursing should actively promote a positive organizational culture towards teaching and develop a systematic curricular transformation to engage future nursing faculty in a teaching and learning agenda. None declared.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Han et al. (2021) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: