Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
My aim today is to present a sketch of Jeremy Bentham's views on punishment, its sources in his writings, and some of its central features.As you will soon see, what I have to say can perhaps be best described as work in progress.2. What would naturally occur to anyone interested in Bentham's views on punishment would be to study the book titled Rationale of Punishment, attributed to Jeremy Bentham on the title page as sole author, published in 1830 in London and in English. 2 What more could we want for an account of someone's theory of punishment than his being the author of a book titled Rationale of Punishment? 3. Very well, let us take a look at this book.Although it appears under Bentham's name and has been used by countless scholars as Bentham's work, it was in fact stitched together from various of Bentham's manuscripts by one of Bentham's young acolytes, Richard Smith.During the day Smith was a minor official in the government's bureau of taxation, but in his spare time he was a devoted editor of several of Bentham's otherwise unpublished writings.Much of the content of the Rationale can be found virtually verbatim in the surviving manuscripts written in various hands and stored in the Bentham archive of University College London.Smith used this material to flesh out the Rationale from the earlier French version of 1811, edited by Etienne Dumont, a diligent and faithful friend of Bentham's.There is no evidence that Bentham ever looked at the product of Smith's labors (he did look at Dumont's), much less that he guided it through the press or otherwise was involved in editing it.4. For these reasons we might advisedly call this book the Smith-Bentham Rationale.Ideally for the purposes of posterity Smith would have turned over to the archives the complete manuscript copy of the text used by the printer to produce the Rationale.But so far as we know, he did not do this; none of that text is known to 1 Paper given at the Bentham Seminar, UCL, 10
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Hugo Adam Bedau (2004) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 6 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: